With the announcement of โThe Suicide Squad: Is it Canon? The Official Podcastโ earlier this week, the DC Universe Franchise once again revolves not around movies or television, but around the never-ending question of canon. If the answer were simple, itโd be one thing. However, these questions plague the DCU and show no signs of stopping.ย
Videos by ComicBook.com
What was once an annoying quirk about the DCU has become the worst thing about it. James Gunn frequently feels on the defensive, constantly fielding these questions instead of focusing on what is important โ the movies and shows.
The Canon Continuity Trap

Since the MCU pulled off the Infinity Saga, thereโs been an emphasis on the extended, shared universe. Audiences now think that all movies and television shows should be moving the wider story along, and that if they donโt, then it isnโt worth seeing. James Gunn himself came out against the notion, with the recent Clayface release.ย
Compared to Superman and Supergirl, Clayface makes little attempt at moving along the larger story. There are no supernatural forces at play โ no intergalactic traffickers or Lex Luthor-level baddiesย โ or grand romantic love story to root for like Lois and Clark. Instead, thereโs some subtle worldbuilding with Gotham, but ultimately Clayface is only about what the title suggests. Itโs about Clayface. When audiences go to the movie, they will get a movie about Clayface, and thatโs it.ย
Gunn is trying to argue the merit of standalone stories like Clayface, and ultimately, heโs right, but the more powerful move would be to stop arguing. If fans can learn to appreciate Black Label comics for DCย โ comics that exist outside continuity and canon, and thus are allowed to be more experimental โย then movie and television enjoyers should be able to embrace a similar ethos. Being outside of canon doesnโt automatically make the story bad or less valuable. It just means it wonโt be followed up in the main string of movies.ย
Perhaps the best argument for a non-canon movie is the success of the Spider-Verse franchise. Made by Sony Animation, Spider-Verse knows theyโre telling a different story from the mainline live action films and embraces the plethora of differences inherent in storytelling. Miles Morales, Gwen Stacy, Spider-Man Noir all come from different versions of New York but none is necessarily more canon. Itโs just their canon. Spider-Verse was widely successful with fans still anticipating the release of the third film, and proved that animation could be just as prestigious as live action.
The Movies Will Answer the Questions

James Gunn supposedly already has a script done for the next Superman film after Man of Tomorrow, but even if he didnโt, he doesnโt have to field questions on X or Threads like this. Is The Suicide Squad canon? Wait until a character from the movie shows up again in the DCU. If itโs the same actor, and if the character references events from The Suicide Squad, then, yes, itโs probably canon. If the actor changes โย or if the character is noticeably different from how they were in the Suicide Squad โ then no.ย
Even though neither Batman nor Joker has been introduced into the franchise, Gunn went out and clarified Harley Quinnโs DCU status. Itโs unclear when weโll see Harley Quinn in a movie again โ there are so many pieces to set up โ but still Gunn ended up answering that heโd love to keep Robbie in the role if it works for everybody, but that if not, theyโd recast her. Instead of relying on common sense โ as rare as it may be in fandom spaces โ a podcast needs to be made to clarify and once again, Gunn is answering each of these questions individually.ย
These posts may be great for instant gratification, and for clicks, but ultimately, thereโs no real value in them. When the movies come out, and people watch them, theyโll find out if itโs canon. Audiences know the Reevesverse Batman films arenโt canon โ that has been explicit for a while โ but it doesnโt stop the world from being interesting. It doesnโt stop Gunn from enjoying it and perhaps taking bits and pieces and seeing how they could work in the DCU.
At the end of the day, the DCU doesnโt have to be just like the MCU, and itโs greater for comic book franchises, and storytelling in general, if it isnโt. Let movies diverge from each other and not have to be followed like homework. Let characters change from one adaptation to another. Most importantly, let James Gunn get off X and do what he does best โ make tv and movies.
Are we judging Gunnโs posts too harshly, or should the DCU move away from this constant canon-clarification? Let us know in the comments below.








