The Harry Potter TV Series Needs to Learn One Big Lesson From the Movies

The Harry Potter TV series is already surrounded by expectations – and it’s no surprise, since we’re talking about one of the most beloved and visually iconic universes in pop culture. Every new announcement gets people excited, even the more controversial ones. Comparisons with the movies are still going strong, but there’s one crucial thing from the original adaptation that needs to be respected if the series is going to be done right: you just can’t ditch practical effects. These days, people act like CGI is the magic solution for everything, but the truth is that the work done physically, on set, with real props, makeup, and mechanics, is still irreplaceable when it comes to building a world the audience can actually feel.

Anyone who’s watched the Harry Potter movies knows they nailed a balance that a lot of current productions forget. The Whomping Willow, for example, wasn’t just some digital image. It was a real-life build, with mechanical branches that moved right along with the actors. That makes a huge difference for immersion, because you can tell it’s real, that it has weight, texture, and presence. That’s something most digital effects just can’t pull off. The Mandrake in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is another great example: it was an animatronic that moved and made noise, giving the scene a sense of reality that’s hard to get with CGI.

And what about that scene where Marge Dursley (Pam Ferris) gets inflated in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban? A lot of people assume it was all done with computers, but it was actually a mix of amazing prosthetics and practical effects, with the actress wearing a special suit. It’s decisions like these that leave a strong visual impression, as it’s clear the actress is genuinely present, experiencing that transformation, and that’s something you simply can’t fake. These kinds of decisions might seem small, but they’re what really set apart something that moves you from something that just looks technically impressive.

If anyone still isn’t sold on the value of practical effects, just look at another major franchise that learned the hard way. When the Star Wars prequel trilogy leaned way too hard on CGI, fans were quick to call out how fake it all felt. In the newer phase, especially in The Force Awakens and shows like The Mandalorian, Lucasfilm made a point of going back to practical effects, using real robots, costumes, and actual sets. And what happened? The response was way more positive, and suddenly the universe felt alive again. That just proves it’s not about nostalgia – it’s about quality. Viewers can definitely tell the difference.

And that’s exactly what the new Harry Potter series needs to take seriously. It can’t fall into the trap of thinking CGI is going to fix everything. Sure, digital effects are important and sometimes necessary, but if the series leans on them too much, it’ll lose the soul the movies had. The thing with CGI-heavy scenes is that they often feel fake, and that pushes people out of the story – and a world like Harry Potter‘s needs that emotional connection to really land.

Read Next

5 Characters That Harry Potter Season 1 Needs to Include to Tease Future Storylines

What made the original films feel so magical wasn’t just the story or the awesome effects – it was how the world felt real. Real sets, real props, and practical effects gave it a natural feel that no amount of pretty CGI can replace. When everything’s done by computer, even if it looks nice, you still lose that feeling of “I’m seeing something that actually exists.” The series is going to have to find a balance – to use digital tools to enhance what’s real, not replace it. That might sound simple, but in today’s effects-driven production world, it’s a real challenge. Sometimes, less is more.

Of course, some scenes wouldn’t be possible without CGI, like complex creatures or big magical battles. But the real magic is in the mix – letting digital effects fill in the gaps where reality can’t go, while still grounding things in practical elements that keep it feeling authentic. That’s the only way to make sure this series doesn’t just end up looking good – it has to feel good a well. If the goal is to bring back longtime fans and win over new ones, they need to understand that practical effects aren’t just some old-school technique – they’re an artistic choice that has a big impact on how people experience the story. They’re what give the plot its pulse. Letting go of that in favor of digital flash would be a huge mistake – and a loss for the heart of the franchise.

The movies already showed us that the real magic of Harry Potter comes from that perfect blend of creativity, craftsmanship, and respect for the world we all fell in love with. The series has everything it needs to be great, but it’s only going to leave a mark if it gets this lesson right. Practical effects aren’t outdated – they’re what give any story life and soul. And Harry Potter might be the saga that needs that more than any other, because if you think about it, the reason it’s so easy to love is that it’s so easy to feel like you’re in the wizarding world.

The Harry Potter TV series is currently in development.