We’re Still Upset That This Netflix Sci-fi Mystery Was Cancelled After One Season

It’s frustrating when a high-quality show that grabs your curiosity and creates a super immersive vibe just disappears without any real conclusion. Shows like this, which mix mystery, period detail, and layered storytelling, are rare gems in a sea of quick, throwaway content. They pull you in, make you think, and get you invested in characters and their stories. Cancelled after just one season and with a big cliffhanger, the German series 1899 had huge potential, with a story that dug deep into a mystery, set in a very specific time period, with complex characters – just how a good series should be. It had everything to hook you and keep doing that over time, but nowadays, when decisions are made mostly based on numbers, it’s tough for shows like this to survive.

This brings us to the story itself and why it deserved more than just one run. The plot follows a group of European migrants traveling from London to New York on a ship called Kerberos in 1899. As the trip goes on, weird and unexplainable things start happening, making the passengers question what’s real and even why they’re on the journey in the first place.

When a series puts a lot of effort into a complex, multi-layered plot and mixes historical and supernatural elements, you expect at least a complete story with all narrative threads wrapped up. 1899 had all that, plus an ambition you don’t see much these days. This wasn’t just another short-lived show; it promised to be a real challenge for viewers who had to pay close attention and focus to keep up. So, when it got cut off suddenly, it not only left a bunch of questions hanging but also the feeling that something memorable got wasted.

On top of that, the show had a linguistic and cultural diversity that made it stand out from most big productions. The characters in 1899 came from different parts of Europe and brought rich personal and cultural backgrounds into their interactions on the ship, which was basically the whole stage for the story. This kind of approach, valuing multiple perspectives, is rare in international sci-fi these days, which usually sticks to simpler formulas to attract a wider audience. Honestly, cancelling a series that cared so much about narrative diversity feels like a step back, especially now when there’s so much talk about representation on screen.

[RELATED: 10 Best Netflix Shows Cancelled Too Soon]

It’s also worth highlighting the technical and artistic ambition here, with top-notch visual effects and a carefully crafted aesthetic that easily transported viewers to the late 19th century. The cinematography, sets, and art direction created a thick atmosphere mixing mystery and suspense with a nearly tangible feeling of claustrophobia and isolation, thanks to the confined ship setting. All this pointed to a serious, heavy investment by Netflix, which rarely hesitates to back what looks high-quality, making the cancellation even harder to get. Just to give an idea, the costs were estimated at around €50 million.

But why didn’t it take off? How could a show that made it into Netflix’s Top 10 in several countries and got positive critical reviews fail to keep enough interest for renewal? Even though it was among the platform’s most watched, the total hours viewed weren’t enough to justify the financial risk. One big reason was the low completion rate. Surveys showed only about 32% of viewers who started 1899‘s first season actually finished it. Compared to other Netflix hits at the time, like Wednesday, that number is pretty low, which is a shame.

Of course, in streaming, numbers matter and investments have to pay off, but loyal and engaged fans should count too. 1899 had a fan base that not only watched but sparked discussions, theories, and even petitions to bring the show back. We’re talking about the creators behind the famous Dark – this wasn’t just some random project. The petition to save the show got thousands of signatures (with reports claiming over 30,000 in less than a day), showing real demand for more episodes. Cancelling it ignored the chance to build something solid and quality-driven.

Netflix (and others) have made this a habit lately, but it’s really frustrating how this case highlights so many issues in today’s industry. In an interview with Bloomberg, CEO Ted Sarandos stated that he “has never cancelled a successful show.” According to him, “the key to it is you have to be able to talk to a small audience on a small budget and a large audience at a large budget. If you do that well, you can do that forever.” With that said, it does raise the question of what exactly qualifies as a “large audience,” especially considering the level of fan response and the petition to save 1899.

On the other hand, maybe the timing just wasn’t right. Today’s audiences are used to faster, more accessible stories, and a show demanding patience and close attention can be a tough sell (sad but true). Plus, another thing that probably didn’t help (though less obviously) was the lack of strong promotion. Despite its impressive technical and storytelling quality, 1899 might not have gotten the marketing push needed to reach a bigger audience.

In the end, all we’re left with is disappointment over a cancellation after just one season. Along with 1899, plenty of other shows with complex and intriguing stories have met the same fate. It’s getting clear that streaming platforms often prefer quick hits and broad appeal over depth and artistic risk. The loss is not just for fans, but for the industry too, which misses out on projects that could reshape what we think of as quality entertainment today.

Maybe 1899‘s cancellation isn’t really an end – more like a wake-up call for viewers and platforms to demand more patience and trust in stories that challenge us. The first season is still available to stream on Netflix.