Harry Potter Fans Are Still Trying to Figure Out This Elder Wand Mystery

When it comes to the oldest, most powerful magic in the Harry Potter franchise, author J.K. Rowling went out of her way to leave some mystery intact. It’s not entirely clear how things like the Elder Wand really work, but that hasn’t stopped fans from trying to figure it out. The conversation flared up once again this week on the Harry Potter subreddit, with user u/book-khaki wondering, “How did the Elder Wand recognize HP as the rightful owner when at the Malfoy manor, Draco wasn’t disarmed with the Elder Wand on hand but his own?” Commenters shared their own ideas, as well as some of the most popular answers that have circulated in the fandom before, but it’s clear that this was not written to have a conclusive answer.

To recap, the Elder Wand is one of the three magical artifacts known as the Deathly Hallows, the most powerful wand in existence. In the final book — and final two movies — Harry and his friends discover that Dumbledore held the wand for the last few decades of his life, and Voldemort eventually stole it from Dumbledore’s grave. However, because Draco Malfoy was the one to actually disarm Dumbledore before his death, the wand recognized Draco as its true master. Harry, in turn, disarmed Draco during their struggle at Malfoy manor, making Harry the wand’s rightful owner.

Fans have questioned how exactly this works since the final book’s release — for the Elder Wand and for wands in general. The book does explain the mechanics of wand affinity as far as wizards understand it, but it also emphasizes how mysterious this aspect of magic is, even for characters like Ollivander. We know that “the wand chooses the wizard,” and “it’s not always clear why,” but some fans still find it hard to accept that the Elder Wand could switch allegiance based on a struggle it wasn’t even involved in, happening many miles away from it.

[RELATED: Harry Potter Fans Still Aren’t Sure How This Character Actually Died]

Unfortunately, the closest things we have to satisfactory explanations are all this mysterious. The top comment on u/book-khaki’s post cited the Pottermore wiki entry for Elder wood — not this particular wand, but the material used to make it. “The rarest wand wood of all, and reputed to be deeply unlucky,” it reads, a wand made from Elder wood “is tricker to master than any other. It contains powerful magic, but scorns to remain with any owner who is not the superior of his or her company.”

This implies that the Elder Wand has a mind of its own, in some sense, and enacts its will a bit like the One Ring from Lord of the Rings. It will actively try to escape an owner it finds unworthy and try to get into the hands of an owner it prefers. This explains why a wizard like Dumbledore was able to hold it quietly for decades, while other owners had it stolen in bloody conflicts for centuries.

It’s also nice that this explanation ascribes an extra layer of magical mystery to the question. All wands made of Elder wood are tricky to win loyalty from, and of course the legendary Elder Wand itself is the most tricky of all. For fans of “soft magic” fantasy writing, this may be enough, while fans of “hard magic” writing have plenty of other gripes with the Harry Potter series, anyway.

For others, this is one of those contrivances that sticks out at the end of a long, epic series. It’s bad enough that Rowling introduced three new all-important artifacts in the final book — to concoct such elaborate rules for how this one works is distracting to some readers. It can be especially frustrating to have your immersion in a story shaken this late in the game because you’ve already invested so much time and emotion in the series that it’s hard to give up, but it’s hard to get past something you dislike too.

Based on Rowling’s style and future plans for the Wizarding World franchise, it’s hard to imagine we’ll get more details on the mechanics of the Elder Wand anytime soon. The Harry Potter novels are available now in print, digital, and audiobook formats. The films are streaming now on Max. A new adaptation of the series premieres next year on HBO and Max.