One of the Most Notorious Comic Book Movies Still Needs a Reboot (And Fast)

Reboots are a fundamental part of comic book movies’ lifecycle, allowing new creative teams to offer fresh interpretations of iconic characters. James Gunn’s new DC Universe is a prime example, a cinematic world that kicked off this summer when Superman introduced a new Man of Steel to audiences. That universe will continue to expand with new versions of Batman and Wonder Woman on the horizon. Marvel Studios is following a similar path. The Fantastic Four: The First Steps just rebooted Marvel’s First Family, while new iterations of the X-Men and Blade are in various stages of development. However, beyond the two major comic book universes lie dozens of other properties that have been adapted for the screen, many of which are in desperate need of a second take.

One of the most notorious examples is The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. Released in 2003, the film adapted the celebrated comic book series by Alan Moore and Kevin O’Neill, which brings together a collection of iconic characters from Victorian literature. The movie was met with a dismal reception from both critics and audiences, and its box office performance was equally disappointing. Despite a production budget of $78 million, the film only managed to gross $179 million worldwide, a return that was not nearly enough to justify a sequel. The film’s failure was so profound that it has since become a cautionary tale in Hollywood, a prime example of how a brilliant concept can be thoroughly mishandled.

Production Chaos and Studio Meddling Doomed The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

The 2003 adaptation of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen was plagued by a series of problems that ultimately doomed it to failure. The production was notoriously troubled, with reports of on-set conflicts, particularly between star Sean Connery and director Stephen Norrington. These clashes, which stemmed from creative differences and Norrington’s reportedly erratic directorial style, created an environment that undoubtedly affected the final product. The situation became so dire that the film would ultimately be the last live-action feature for both Connery, who retired from acting soon after, and Norrington, who has not directed a film since. Adding to the production woes, the shoot was beset by natural disasters, including severe floods in Prague that destroyed millions of dollars’ worth of sets.

Read Next

I Think Alan Moore Was Right About the V for Vendetta Movie

Beyond the behind-the-scenes drama, the film’s most significant failing was its complete misunderstanding of the source material. Moore and O’Neill’s comic book is a dark, complex, and deeply satirical work that deconstructs the heroic archetypes of Victorian literature. The film, in contrast, opted for a more conventional and family-friendly approach, stripping the story of its thematic depth and intellectual rigor. Key characters and plot points were altered or removed entirely, and new elements were added to increase the film’s appeal to American audiences, such as the inclusion of Mark Twain’s Tom Sawyer. These changes resulted in a final product that was a pale imitation of the original, a simplified action movie that failed to capture the spirit of the comic.

Alan Moore’s The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen Deserves a Faithful Reboot

A reboot of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is an opportunity to bring a true literary masterpiece to the screen. Moore and O’Neill’s comic book series is a brilliant work that weaves together a vast tapestry of characters and concepts from 19th-century literature. The series is a loving homage to the fiction of the era, but it is also a sharp critique of the colonialist and patriarchal attitudes that were prevalent at the time. Because of that, the characters are deeply flawed individuals who are forced to confront their own inner demons as they battle external threats. Mina Murray, for instance, is not a damsel in distress, but a strong and capable leader who is still dealing with the trauma of her encounter with Dracula. In addition, Allan Quatermain is a disillusioned opium addict, a far cry from the swashbuckling hero of H. Rider Haggard’s novels.

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is equally rich with intricate plotlines, offering a wealth of material for a multi-film franchise. The first volume alone, which sees the League battling Professor Moriarty and his criminal empire, is more than enough to sustain a feature film. A reboot could also delve into the subsequent volumes, which see the League facing off against Martian invaders from H.G. Wells’ The War of the Worlds and a cabal of villains from the worlds of pulp fiction. A new adaptation could fully embrace the steampunk aesthetic of the comic, creating a visually unique world that is both familiar and fantastical. Finally, by staying true to the dark and sophisticated tone of the source material, a new League of Extraordinary Gentlemen could be the rare comic book adaptation that is both a commercial success and a critical darling.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!