Halloween might be days away, but some are already having a pretty heavy debate about one particular childrens’ costume.
Videos by ComicBook.com
An article by Sachi Feris has been making the rounds in recent days, and recounted Feris’ conversation with her 5-year-old daughter. Her daughter wanted to go as Moana for her Halloween next year, but Feris expressed her worry that the costume would be considered “cultural appropriation”, considering Moana‘s roots in Polynesian culture.
Outlets such as the New York Post and Cosmopolitan picked up Feris’ article, and it’s led to quite a bit of discourse among those online. And it’s safe to say that it’s a very complex debate.
Some agree with Feris’ sentiment, while others argue that the debate around a costume for a child has been blown out of proportion. And the general consensus seems to be that there is a way to honor the Disney princess without drifting into that territory of cultural appropriation, as long as parents use common sense.
Here’s a round-up of some of the tweets surrounding the Moana Halloween costume controversy.
@YungCripp
Kids just love characters and want to be them. They don’t understand cultural appropriation (not even saying that’s what this is)
โ Racist Snoopy (@YungCripp) October 24, 2017
@Lauren_Aleen_R5
As long as you don’t paint your child brown, WHO CARES. Moana is a strong ass female that kids of all skin colors adore… https://t.co/81r4VCCmcQ
โ spooky Lo (@Lauren_Aleen_R5) October 25, 2017
@sweetie_sitake
Iโm Polynesian & I say PARENTS: feel free to dress your child up as anything they want for Halloween, including Moana! https://t.co/PaHCfGyizg
โ #beatSJSU (@sweetie_sitake) October 24, 2017
@madbev1991
If your daughter wants to be Moana, thatโs great. If you buy her a Moana costume for the purpose of offending people, thatโs not great. https://t.co/KMUBjRhGZi
โ Madison (@madbev1991) October 24, 2017
@been_801
As a Polynesian, I will not be offended if your child wants to dress up as Moana. Let the kids be kids, man. ??โโ๏ธ
โ Lyle (?6-1) ??? (@been_801) October 25, 2017
Now for all you grown folks who wanna turn Moana into Hoeana, cut that shit out. Cultural appropriation. Calling it right now. Hahaha https://t.co/Hpcva7OjWe
@weezybutta
Moana is a Disney character. That is ok. Generalizing a culture, race or ethnicity is not. https://t.co/dv2MUHJVmM
โ Carby B (@weezybutta) October 25, 2017
@liamrulz
so I am alone in thinking this MOANA has halloween costume thing is actually kind of complicated and doesn’t have a clear answer? just me?
โ PastorS NIGHTMARE ? (@liamrulz) October 25, 2017