7 Home Alone Moments That Still Make No Sense (And #2 Is a Plot Hole)

One of the biggest holiday classics, Home Alone is the kind of movie you watch for the nostalgia and the cozy end-of-year vibe it brings. But why exactly? Why is it a film everyone remembers so fondly and automatically adds to their annual watchlist? Because nothing in it actually makes sense. Kevin McCallister (Macaulay Culkin) becomes a tiny tactical operative, adults completely lose their common sense, and the whole town seems to operate in an alternate reality. We let it slide because that’s part of the movie’s charm, but if you really pay attention, some character decisions and situations get downright absurd. And not in a small way — these moments break basic logic, even within the rules of a family comedy.

Videos by ComicBook.com

Here are 7 moments that make absolutely no sense in Home Alone. The movie is still iconic, but it stumbles hard on its own logic once you start looking closely. And the wildest part is that these aren’t just isolated inconsistencies; they hold up most of the narrative.

7) The Delivery Guy Didn’t Call the Cops

Kevin is home alone and decides to order a pizza. But when the delivery guy shows up, he hears total chaos happening inside (all because Kevin is blasting a movie to mess with him) and basically sprints back to his car without even thinking about calling the police. It’s one of those scenes you watch and try to let slide, but it makes zero sense. Anyone who genuinely believes gunshots are going off inside a house wouldn’t just run away; they’d tell someone, at the very least. In the real world, that’s an immediate report or, at a minimum, an emergency call. Sure, the movie needs this moment to keep Kevin isolated and vulnerable, but it’s still pretty hard to swallow.

6) Nobody in the Neighborhood Questioned the Noise

The whole plot hinges on Kevin setting up elaborate plans to get rid of Harry (Joe Pesci) and Marv (Daniel Stern), and for that, almost every object in the house becomes a weapon. The entire night is filled with loud crashes, slamming doors, falling cans, screams, and constant thuds, yet not a single neighbor gets up to check what’s going on (and Old Man Marley (Roberts Blossom) only shows up to save Kevin at the very end of the movie). This would already be weird in any regular neighborhood, but in a quiet suburban area, it’s almost impossible. The movie treats the block like it’s completely empty, and the silence works way too conveniently. There’s no logical explanation, no mention of neighbors traveling, no empty houses — nothing.

5) The Police Didn’t Do Anything When They Had the Chance

At one point in Home Alone, the police finally show up at the McCallister house at Kevin’s parents’ request, knock on the door, don’t see anyone, and then just leave. It’s unbelievable, considering they were responding to a call claiming a child was home alone. Any police department with even the most basic procedures would investigate thoroughly, especially with the possibility of a break-in or a kid in danger. The decision to “knock, shrug, and walk away” is almost impossible to justify. And it gets worse: even when the burglars are caught later that night, there’s still no real follow-up: no proper investigation, no welfare check on the child, or assessment of the property. The entire police response is basically reduced to officers hitting the siren and calling it a day.

4) Kevin’s Traps Were Way Too Elaborate to Be Made So Fast

To outsmart the burglars, Kevin builds incredibly complex traps in a single night, using whatever he finds around the house. We get greased-up stairs, slippery floors, doors rigged with nails, swinging paint cans — the whole catalog of cartoon-level mayhem. But all of this requires planning, precision, and especially time, which is way more than a kid could realistically pull off alone. Sure, suspension of disbelief can carry you for a while, but it’s impossible not to notice how absurd it is, mostly because the traps work with perfect timing every single time. It’s like Kevin had professional training. And the wildest part? The next morning, the house is spotless. After an entire night of chaos, everything magically goes back to normal.

3) The Wet Bandits Never Really Got Hurt

Despite slipping on ice, burning their hands, getting hit with heavy objects, and suffering cuts, Harry and Marv stay weirdly functional and determined. In any real situation, those injuries would be enough to completely incapacitate grown adults. But in the movie, they get up over and over again like full-on cartoon characters, ignoring the actual severity of what’s happening to them. Kevin’s traps become punchlines, and any real sense of danger disappears instantly. Sure, it’s fun to watch, and if they were seriously injured, the story wouldn’t be able to keep going — that’s part of why the movie is so memorable in the first place. But there’s no way to take any of it seriously.

2) Kevin’s Parents Couldn’t Call Him

The biggest flaw in Home Alone shows up the moment Kevin’s parents realize he’s missing. From that point on, you’d expect them to immediately try calling him, but the movie explains that they can’t reach the house because the phone lines are “down” after a storm. That works as a temporary excuse — until Kevin manages to call the pizza place that same night with zero issues, using the exact same supposedly dead line. You can stretch the logic and say that local calls still worked, but for the audience, the effect is the same: it’s a glaring inconsistency that only exists to keep the premise alive. It’s a major plot hole, and not one you can easily ignore.

1) The Wet Bandits Kept Insisting on the McCallister House No Matter What

The most nonsensical part of Home Alone is that even after realizing the house is being defended by a kid and getting seriously injured, the burglars still keep trying to break in. Honestly, any real criminal would bail the second things got this dangerous, but Harry and Marv stay absurdly determined, with zero sense of self-preservation. It’s the peak of the movie’s over-the-top comedy. And if you really want to give the plot some coherence, you could argue that the McCallister house is massive, clearly wealthy, and looks empty (at first glance), making it the perfect target. But even then, their level of insistence is ridiculous. It’s like they’re actively trying to get themselves killed with how often they walk into Kevin’s traps. There’s simply no legitimate explanation for why they keep going.

What do you think of these Home Alone moments? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!