The Stranger Things creative team has a celebrated history of introducing pivotal new characters with each season. These additions often become instant fan favorites, with figures like Max Mayfield (Sadie Sink), Robin Buckley (Maya Hawke), and Eddie Munson (Joseph Quinn) proving indispensable to the series’ sprawling mythology and emotional core. The show’s fifth and final season continues this tradition by welcoming new faces into the fold, but it also executes a surprising narrative pivot by elevating a long-standing background character to a central role. After years on the periphery, Mike (Finn Wolfhard) and Nancy’s (Natalia Dyer) youngest sister, Holly Wheeler (Nell Fisher), has been thrust directly into the center of Vecna’s (Jamie Campbell Bower) endgame.
Videos by ComicBook.com
Warning: Spoilers below for Stranger Things 5, Volume 1
For four seasons, Holly Wheeler existed blissfully unaware of the Demogorgons and Mind Flayers that plagued her town and her own family. Her presence served as a constant reminder of the normal life that was always just out of reach for the main cast. That protective bubble shatters completely in Stranger Things 5. The season immediately establishes her as the primary target of Vecna’s latest horrifying scheme, as the villain launches a campaign to kidnap twelve of Hawkins’ youngest children. Holly is the first person he pulls into his web, making her the unwilling key to his final assault on reality.
Why Did Vecna Target Holly in Stranger Things Season 5?
Vecna’s new strategy is a manipulative departure from his previous methods. He first infiltrates Holly’s life as an imaginary friend she names Mr. Whatsit. This shadowy figure, visible only to her, presents himself as a protector, warning her that monsters are lurking in Hawkins. Her parents, Karen (Cara Buono) and Ted (Joe Chrest), struggling with the town’s quarantine and Karen’s increasing reliance on alcohol, dismiss these visions as a child’s fantasy. To comfort his terrified sister, Mike gives Holly a Dungeons & Dragons miniature of a cleric, naming it Holly the Heroic and explaining its power to cast protective spells and open magic doors. Holly later fashions this figurine into a collar.
Holly’s psychic connection with Mr. Whatsit has an immediate, though initially misunderstood, effect on Will Byers (Noah Schnapp). While preparations for a mission into the Upside Down are underway, Will is struck by a strange sensation, feeling as if the sky itself is turning. The vision is disorienting but lacks context. Later that day, Vecna makes his move. A Demogorgon assaults the Wheeler home with the clear intent to abduct Holly. It viciously mauls Ted and Karen when they attempt to defend their daughter before grabbing the girl and pulling her through a portal into the Upside Down.
It is only after this traumatic event that the true nature of Will’s vision becomes clear. He and Robin (Maya Hawke) return to the location where he felt the spinning sensation and discover the elementary school playground. They realize he saw what Holly was seeing as she played on a roundabout, confirming that Will can now passively detect Vecna’s psychic frequency whenever the villain is actively targeting a new victim.
While Holly’s physical body is trapped in the Upside Down, tied to a mysterious column and being force-fed by a tube, her consciousness is transported to a meticulously crafted mental prison. She awakens in an idyllic version of the Creel house, where Henry Creel appears to her in his human form. He serves her blueberry pancakes and behaves like a benevolent caretaker, telling her he intends to bring other children to his home to protect them from the real monsters.
This illusion is broken when Holly is contacted by another prisoner in Vecna’s mind: Max. Having been trapped in Henry’s consciousness since her near-death experience in Season 4 of Stranger Things, Max has found a sanctuary within a rock wall that Henry is inexplicably terrified of. From this hideout, Max creates a map and tricks Holly into believing it’s from Henry, luring her away from the house and into her safe haven, where they begin to plot an escape.
Vecna’s ultimate goal is revealed much later during a direct confrontation with Will. He explains that he specifically targets children for his plan because he views them as ideal vessels. Children’s minds and bodies are more malleable, making them easier to shatter and reform for his own purposes. Just as Will’s possession years prior showed Vecna the potential of using a human host to enact his will, these twelve children are meant to become the living conduits for his final plan.
There are still, however, crucial pieces missing from this puzzle. We understand Vecna’s general strategy, but the specific reason he chose Holly as his first target remains a significant mystery, echoing the unanswered question of why he selected Will Byers all those years ago. The victims Vecna claimed in Season 4 were all connected by a shared history of trauma, which he used as a gateway into their minds. Yet in Season 5, no such connection has been established between Holly and the other abducted children.
Volume 1 of Stranger Things 5 is currently streaming on Netflix. Volume 2 arrives on December 25th, with the final episode following on December 31st.
Why do you think Vecna selected Holly as his first target? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Most Viewed
-
Image courtesy of The Pokemon Company
