Created by Joss Whedon Buffy the Vampire Slayer first aired in 1997 and, after an impressive 144 episodes, finally concluded in 2003. The series became a cultural phenomenon and its still inspiring new TV shows today. Buffy also introduced some iconic characters from the pretty-yet-strong Buffy (Sarah Michelle Gellar) to the dangerous-yet-romantic vampire Spike (James Marsters). Plus viewers witnessed the coming-out of the groundbreaking character Willow (Alyson Hannigan), one of the first of its kind on television and happening in the third season of the series.
Videos by ComicBook.com
Buffy the Vampire Slayer was able to mix supernatural, horror, drama and even musicals into its episodes. With the mix of character-driven plot, comical dialogue and bold social commentary, it still remains as a fan favorite by many. It redefined the supernatural and horror genres on TV. While it’s tough to narrow them down, here are some of the best episodes that showcase the brilliance of this groundbreaking series.
10) “Once More, With Feeling” – Season 6, Episode 7
In this iconic episode, we watch as Sweet (Hinton Battle), a mysterious demon, forces the residents of Sunnydale to communicate through dance and song. It may sound like a harmless curse, just singing and dancing, but we soon find out that these songs bring out the characters innermost thoughts and feelings. As things get complicated between the Scooby Gang members they start confronting each other, with Tara suspecting Willow of altering her memory with magic, plus Xander and Anya begin having doubts about their upcoming marriage. But the most shocking reveal comes from Buffy, when she’s forced to reveal her struggles of being brought back to life by her friends.
This episode successfully explores the characters secret emotions while keeping the humor and drama balanced through music. Unlike modern musical episodes, “Once More, With Feeling” doesn’t use music as a form of comedy. Instead it’s used to convey serious emotions, while keeping the plot moving. Buffy really gave us a musical episode long before they became a trend, once again proving how iconic and ahead of its time the series was.
9) “Graduation Day,” – Season 3 Episodes 21 & 22
This two-part season finale episode is packed with action, humor, and an epic final battle between Buffy and the Mayor (Harry Groener), who transforms into a giant snake, confirming his place as one of the deadliest Buffy villains. The battle is thrilling and it takes two episodes to defeat the dangerous Mayor, and in the process Sunnydale High School gets ruined, bringing the metaphor of hte Scooby Gang’s teenage years to an end. The episode gets emotional for them as they reflect on their growth and the relationships they’ve made over the years.
This finale also solidifies the character’s emotional growth while setting the stage for the challenges to come, but it’s the quieter moments that make it memorable as we watch the Scoobies bittersweet farewell to their high school years and the realization that life as they knew it will never be the same.
8) “Passion” – Season 2, Episode 17
This episode shows us Angel (David Boreanaz) at his worst. We see how his cruel manipulation and chilling actions lead to the tragic death of Jenny (Robia LaMorte), a loss that deeply affects the Scooby Gang. The betrayal cuts deeper because it’s not just a physical loss, but a betrayal of trust by someone Buffy once loved.
We watch as Angel not only targets Jenny but also as he targets the emotional core of the group’s friendship. Buffy and her friends are forced to face the reality that not even their bond is immune to the evils of the world. The dark tones and shocking twists mark the episode as one of the most haunting.
7) “Restless” – Season 4, Episode 22
Another unforgettable season finale, in this episode, Buffy and her friends face surreal visions that reveal their most secret fears and desires. These dreams are triggered by an entity called ‘The First Slayer,’ which has the power to invade the character’s subconscious. Each character’s dream offers a glimpse into their inner turmoil. Once again, we are given the chance to delve into character’s most personal thoughts, and we see that despite constantly proving their strength and intelligence through battles with evil, most of the Scooby Gang is insecure with themselves.
The cryptic messages and emotional depth provide the audience with insight into the characters psyches. We see not only their growth but also get a hint of the struggles yet to come for them.
6) “Doppelgangland” – Season 3, Episode 16
Buffy the Vampire Slayer is one of the first series to introduce alternate dimensions in TV, and it makes full use of this concept throughout the series. In this episode, we are introduced to Willow’s vampire double from another dimension. The appearance of Vampire Willow creates chaos amongst her friends and offers a glimpse into what Willow’s life would have been had she taken a different path in life (plus it showcases the thin line between good and evil).
The episode not only deepens the audiences understanding of Willow’s character but it also raises questions about fate and the choices we make. We also get an amazing performance from Alyson Hannigan, who skillfully portrays two contrasting characters in one episode. Her ability to shift between the innocent Willow and the dark Vampire Willow is absolutely amazing.
5) “Fool For Love” – Season 5, Episode 7
This is the perfect episode for fans of Spike, as we learn about the anti-hero’s backstory. Through flashbacks, we discover how Spike became a vampire and learn about his painful and lonely life as a human, which shaped his dark transformation. We also see the reasons behind his obsessions, particularly with Buffy.
The episode highlights the complexity of his relationship with her. His intense and sometimes violent feelings for her contrast with his vulnerability, making him stand out from his ‘villain’ character. We learn that his love for Buffy is driven by a need for validation and a desire to be seen and loved, stemming from his troubled past. The entire thing adds a new layer of depth to Spike, showing that his actions aren’t just fueled by evil but by a longing for connection.
4) “Hush” – Season 4, Episode 10
“Hush” stands out as one of the most creative episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, as the majority of the story unfolds without dialogue. We watch as demons known as The Gentlemen rob everyone in Sunnydale of their voices, leaving them mute and defenseless against evil.
The choice to have the characters largely silent through out the episode is bold, and the series executes it flawlessly. The horror is heightened by the silence, relying on natural sounds and a haunting score to build tension. Plus, the lack of dialogue forces the characters to confront emotions they often avoid, adding depth to the narrative. We witness Buffy and her friends in a state of vulnerability, with their typical quick wit and banter stripped away from them. In this terrifying silence, they must rely on their instincts and actions to communicate and survive. “Hush” is a masterclass in how silence can amplify both horror and emotional resonance, marking it as one of the most memorable and inventive episodes in the entire series.
3) “Who Are You?” – Season 4, Episode 16
In this episode, Buffy and Faith (Eliza Dushku) unexpectedly swap bodies. To no one’s surprise, Faith fully takes advantage of the swap, creating chaos with her reckless behavior; but Buffy on the other hand faces the challenge of controlling Faith’s rebelliousness. The body swap highlights their differences while forcing them to confront each other’s choices. As Buffy struggles with Faith’s lack of restraint, Faith gets to experiences firsthand the weight of Buffy’s responsibilities as a hero, leading to both characters gaining a deeper understanding of each other.
The episode explores their contrasting approaches to being the Slayer and how each of them wrestles with the consequences of it. As it unfolds, both Buffy and Faith are forced to confront aspects of themselves they usually try to avoid. This moment of empathy becomes a turning point, allowing both characters to realize they are more similar than they thought.
2) “The Gift” – Season 5, Episode 22
Buffy’s ultimate sacrifice in the 100th episode makes it one of the most emotional moments in the series. In “The Gift,” we see her sacrifice herself to save her sister Dawn (Michelle Trachtenberg) and the world from Glory (Clare Kramer), showing not only the growth of Buffy as a Slayer, but as a sister too. Buffy comes to understand that her role of a Slayer includes not only fighting evil physically but also making sacrifices even if it means her own end, and in her last moments she makes peace with it.
The episode beautifully highlights how deep Buffy’s journey has become over five seasons, as she realizes the weight of her responsibilities. Her willingness to face death for others shows her growth from a reluctant hero to a selfless one. The episode also focuses on the relationships that have shaped Buffy, especially her bond with Dawn. Buffy’s sacrifice makes it a heartbreaking moment not only for Buffy but for the Scooby Gang too, who are forced to confront what their lives would be without her. In her final moments, she delivers the unforgettable line: “The hardest thing in this world is to live in it.”
1) “The Body” – Season 5, Episode 16
One of the most emotionally raw and heartbreaking in the series, “The Body” confronts a reality shared by both the world of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and the audience’s world: the inevitability of death. While we’ve seen Buffy fight countless vampires, demons, and even world-ending threats, this time however we see her, powerless against a brain aneurysm that unexpectedly claims her mother, Joyce (Kristine Sutherland).
With no musical score and an intense focus on the characters grief, the episode delivers a profoundly emotional experience. It steps away from the supernatural to focus on the fragility of life and death, showing how each character deals with the unexpected loss. It also forces us to confront a reality we all face: the fragility of life and the inevitability of loss.
