Every Captain in Star Trek Ranked

From time-traveling womanisers to space dads who make a mean plate of jambalaya, here’s our ranking of every Captain to sit in the Chair.

There’s no question more likely to divide the Star Trek fandom than “who’s the best captain?” Ask it in a room full of Trekkies and you’ll hear impassioned speeches about diplomacy, charisma, and maybe even hairlines. And while there’s no real right or wrong answer, (whatever floats your boat—or ship) it’s fun to debate and Trekkies have spent many a happy hour comparing personal rankings.

While there are some who would argue no one could live up to the commanding presence and charisma of James T Kirk in Gene Roddenbury’s Original Series, over its nearly 60 years of films, animated series and spin-offs, Star Trek has given us a whole host of Captains, each facing different challenges and each inspirational in their own way. While Star Trek Shows are very much an ensemble effort, the captain does tend to appear front and center, so for this list, we’re focusing only on main-series captains in Star Trek canon—the ones whose names appear in the opening credits and who command their ship week after week. That means no one-off favourites, no First Officers who took the con once or eventually got their own command, no Mirror Universe warlords like Lorca, and no animated anomalies like Dal (sorry Prodigy fans).

With those ground rules in place… Engage!

7) Michael Burnham (Star Trek Discovery)

Michael Burnham’s journey to Captaincy in Discovery is one of the more unusual in Trek history—she starts out as a disgraced first officer, mutineer, and prisoner, only to eventually become captain of the ship she helped save more times than we can count. She certainly eared her place in the chair, but she doesn’t get there until season three, and some fans have argued the series would have felt less disjointed had she been made Captain from the start. Making Burnham the protagonist of the show felt a little odd when she didn’t yet have the rank and authority to support her adventures (there’s a reason Captains are usually the focus). Sonequa Martin-Green anchored the series with undeniable charisma, but the early seasons often tied Burnham’s story too tightly to Spock’s and her family legacy.

Once she finally took the captain’s chair in Season 3, Burnham became the clear leader she was born to be, and she truly came into her own when Discovery traveled to the 32^nd Century. Sometimes her storylines skewed a little too far toward her being the “galaxy’s chosen one” for comfort, and she suffered a little from main character syndrome. Still, her empathy, emotional intelligence, and persistence made her a worthy addition to Starfleet’s upper ranks—even if her captaining style sometimes felt a little unorthodox.

6) Jonathan Archer (Star Trek: Enterprise)

The first captain of the original Enterprise, the first Warp 5 capable starship, had the unenviable job of writing the rulebook as he went along—and sometimes, it showed. We have to cut him some slack; Jonathan Archer’s pre-Federation missions meant no Prime Directive, no First Contact protocols, and no long history of Starfleet diplomacy to look back on for inspiration (and yet he still navigated first contact with many species including Klingons and Andorians). Unfortunately, it also meant more than a few instances where he seemed to make rash decisions, or go against his own morals.

Scott Bakula definitely brought an inherent relatability to Archer in Enterprise, especially when hanging with his dog Porthos, but too often the character came across as reactive instead of visionary, stubborn and set in his ways, rather than diplomatic and curious to explore, which some would argue are essential qualities for a Starship Captain. The Xindi and Temporal Cold War arcs gave him more to do in later seasons, but he never quite reached the inspirational heights of his successors, despite being arguably more down to Earth.

5) Christopher Pike (Star Trek Strange New Worlds)

Before Discovery and most recently Strange New Worlds, Christopher Pike was a more of a footnote in Star Trek history—the “other” captain of the Enterprise first seen in the Pilot episode of The Original Series “The Cage.” Anson Mount’s portrayal of the character in Season 2 of Discovery changed that instantly, leading to the actor securing his own show with the creation of Strange New Worlds and firmly securing Pike in Star Trek History. His Pike is a warm, collaborative leader who cooks for his crew, gives them room to shine, and even after learning of his fate (as seen in The Original Series in “The Menagerie” Parts 1 and 2) he somehow makes his tragic future into a challenge to live better, not a death sentence to fear.

Unlike some Captains, Pike doesn’t hog the spotlight; he’s happy to let Spock, La’An, or any of his very competent crew take center stage in any given mission, deferring to their expertise—but that humility is part of his charm. He’s even got a sense of humor, showing us throughout Strange New World’s that he’s a space dad in the best way possible, with just enough swashbuckling energy to remind us of Kirk but setting himself apart by showing the maturity and wisdom that comes with age.

4) Kathryn Janeway (Star Trek: Voyager)

Kate Mulgrew’s Janeway was the first female Captain to lead a Star Trek series, and she did it while stuck 70,000 lightyears away in the Delta Quadrant, cut off from Starfleet, with a decimated crew made up of trigger-happy Starfleet officers and Maquis rebels at each other’s throats—RESPECT! That alone should be enough to cement Voyager’s Captain as one of the most resourceful captains in Trek history, but she’s also a romantic at heart and her occasional loneliness and crises of confidence made her one of the most human of all the captains.

She didn’t like bullies, and she didn’t like threats, and boy did she make it known! Janeway could occasionally be stubborn, but above all, she was fiercely protective of her crew. Despite some inconsistent writing, with her clipped cadence and calm but powerful presence, Kate Mulgrew created a consistency in her character that made her feel trustworthy to her crew and audiences. Whether negotiating with the Borg or deciding the fate of Tuvix (sorry, Tuvix…), Janeway always made choices she could and would stand by—even if they weren’t always easy. Fans were delighted to see Kate Mulgrew reprise her role in Prodigy, where she has rightly made the rank of Admiral. She’s the kind of captain you’d follow into uncharted space.

3) Benjamin Sisko (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)

Benjamin Sisko of Deep Space Nine, had a somewhat different job from other captains. Tasked with running a space station instead of a starship, he nonetheless gave his all to the role, delicately balancing Starfleet’s orders with the needs of the many different species aboard the station. He navigated some complex political situations, and he proved he wasn’t afraid of getting his hands dirty, commanding from the front lines playing a vital part in the war effort during the Dominion War.

As if that wasn’t enough, he managed to balance duel responsibilities, also acting as the Bajoran Emissary of the Prophets. Avery Brooks gave Sisko a commanding and serious presence, necessary for one of Star Trek’s darker shows, but he also gave his character a warmth and emotional intelligence that made him endlessly compelling. He could be a spiritual leader, a baseball coach, and above all a loving father to his son Jake. In short: Sisko got things done, whether Starfleet liked it or not!

2) James T. Kirk (The Original Series)

What?! Kirk’s not top of the list?! Kirk is undoubtedly Star Trek’s original action hero—bold, charming, occasionally reckless, but always decisive. William Shatner’s performance gave the character a swagger that’s often imitated but rarely matched. Kirk showed he could outthink his enemies as often as he could outshoot them. The Original ‘Golden Trio’, ‘The Triumvirate’ of Kirk, Spock, and McCoy was a friendship for the ages, that would never again be matched in Trek, and Kirk clearly valued the counsel of his friends as much as his own instincts.

Yes, some aspects of his character, like his tendency to flirt with any female alien who might stray in his vicinity, are firmly products of the 1960s, but Kirk’s adaptability, curiosity, and willingness to risk himself for his crew remain timeless. Without him, the idea of a “Starfleet captain” simply wouldn’t exist as we know it. In many ways, Kirk was the show in The Original Series. It’s no surprise that the iconic character has made a come back in recent years, with Chris Pine’s portrayal of the Character in JJ Abrams reboot films bringing the character to a new generation of fans and Paul Wesley being the latest actor to step in to the famous shoes, giving us a younger, less refined version of Kirk in Strange New Worlds.

1) Jean-Luc Picard (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

If Kirk was the blueprint, then Jean-Luc Picard is the gold standard. Patrick Stewart’s unflappable Captain of the Enterprise-D, redefined what a Starfleet captain could be: not just a warrior or an explorer, but a philosopher and diplomat with a strong moral compass. Preferring a good cup of Earl grey to a one-night stand, Picard led with reason, empathy, and an unshakable belief in the ideals of the Federation, making him the ultimate embodiment of Trek’s vision for the future. Gene Roddenbury famously didn’t want Patrick Stewart in the part, he certainly had some big boots to fill coming straight after Shatner’s Kirk, but the Shakesperean actor soon proved himself more than worthy of the role.

Sure, Picard’s leadership style might have been a slightly less entertaining than Kirk’s (a little less avant-garde) preferring to do things by the book, but you couldn’t really fault it when, there were lives at stake after all. Whether delivering a spine-tingling speech, outmaneuvering the Borg, or defending Data’s right to self-determination, Picard always placed principle above ego. Fans were delighted to see Stewart return to the role in Picard. He wasn’t perfect—nor was he infallible—but he was the kind of leader who made you want to be better. Every captain since has been measured against him, and for good reason.

Who’s your favorite captain? Let us know in the comments!

All seasons of Star Trek are streaming now on Paramount+.