Ashes of Creation Has Poisoned the Well for Indie Devs

There is a quiet, fragile agreement that sits at the heart of crowdfunding. It is not written anywhere, but everyone involved understands it. Developers promise transparency, restraint, and respect for backers’ trust. Players agree to fund something unfinished, risky, and years away from release. When that agreement breaks in public, loudly and repeatedly, it does not just hurt one project. It scars the entire model.

Ashes of Creation’s very public collapse has done more than damage one MMO’s reputation. It has fundamentally shaken trust in long-term Kickstarter-funded games, reinforcing the worst fears players already had about ambitious, years-long crowdfunding projects. Calling it a scam almost undersells the damage, because the real fallout is how deeply this implosion harms legitimate indie developers who now have to convince a burned audience to believe in crowdfunding all over again. I say this as someone who has personally run a Kickstarter: watching this unfold feels like watching someone torch the bridge while the rest of us are still standing on it.

Why Ashes of Creation Broke Player Trust for Good

What makes Ashes of Creation uniquely damaging is just how visible and prolonged the disappointment has become. You do not need insider context or a detailed breakdown of development decisions to understand the public reaction. You just have to look at the community spaces. The subreddit alone paints a clear picture of a player base that has moved past confusion and into something closer to resignation and anger.

From the outside, Ashes of Creation came to embody nearly every fear players have about crowdfunded MMOs. Long timelines that kept stretching. Promises that felt increasingly distant. Marketing moments that seemed disconnected from tangible progress. Monetization decisions that raised serious concerns long before the game felt anywhere near complete. Whether those decisions made sense internally does not matter to public trust. Perception is reality when you are asking people to fund a dream.

Over time, frustration hardened into skepticism, and skepticism hardened into distrust. That shift is what makes this situation feel irreversible. Trust does not vanish overnight. It erodes slowly, update by update, delay by delay, until players stop giving the benefit of the doubt altogether. At that point, even genuine progress is met with suspicion instead of excitement.

Ashes of Creation has now become a reference point: a warning. When people talk about why they no longer back MMOs on Kickstarter, this is the name that will come up. That kind of association sticks, especially when it plays out so publicly for so long. No amount of context can undo the emotional memory players now associate with the project.

The Crowdfunding MMO Model Was Already Fragile

The hard truth is that the crowdfunding MMO model was already in a bad place before Ashes of Creation reached this moment. Players have been burned too many times over the past decade. Big ideas. Massive scopes. Development timelines that stretched endlessly. Projects that either vanished entirely or were released in states that barely resembled what was promised. Each failure chips away at goodwill.

Ashes of Creation did not create that fragility, but it has absolutely exposed it in a big way with its implosion. This was not a quiet failure or a slow fade into obscurity. It played out in public, across years, across social media, and across multiple phases of renewed hope followed by renewed disappointment. Even players who never backed the project absorbed the lesson secondhand.

Crowdfunded MMOs already carried an assumption of failure by default, and have done so for years. Now, because of Ashes of Creation, the chances of getting a new one funded have become nigh impossible. When a new one is announced, the conversation will rarely start with curiosity anymore. Instead, it will start with doubt. How long will this really take? How much more money will they ask for? When does ambition turn into overreach? These questions are not unfair, but they reflect a model that has lost its footing.

As someone who has run a Kickstarter, this is the part that hurts the most. Most indie developers are not chasing impossible dreams. They are trying to build focused projects with limited teams and realistic goals. Crowdfunding is often the only path forward without publisher support. But now, every long-term project, not just MMOs, has to fight a reputation it did not earn. Indie projects already had an uphill battle. Now, that hill just got way steeper.

Indie Developers Are Paying the Price for Someone Else’s Failure

This is where the damage becomes unforgivable. Indie developers who had nothing to do with Ashes of Creation will now be paying the cost for its public implosion. Every pitch is will be met with suspicion. Every timeline will be treated like a lie waiting to happen. Every stretch goal will be seen as a red flag instead of a promise of growth.

You can feel it in comment sections and social posts. “Not another Ashes.” “I’ve seen this before.” “Wake me up when it actually exists.” Transparency will no longer be enough, because players have learned that transparency does not always lead to accountability. Trust has been replaced with defensive cynicism.

Crowdfunding only works when backers believe that developers are acting in good faith. When that belief collapses, the entire ecosystem suffers. Smaller teams do not have the marketing power or brand recognition to overcome widespread distrust. They rely on goodwill, and goodwill is exactly what situations like this destroy. This is the real sin of Ashes of Creation. Even if the game was not a scam, and was never intended to be, the public perception of its collapse has harmed everyone involved and left signficant colatteral damage in its wake.

There is no excuse for mishandling trust on this scale. When a high-profile project fails publicly, loudly, and over a long period of time, it does not just disappoint its own backers. It poisons the ground for everyone else. Indie developers now have to convince players that crowdfunding itself is still worth believing in, and that is a battle they should never have had to fight.

Ashes of Creation may eventually recover in some form, or it may not. But the scar it has left on crowdfunding will outlive whatever happens next. The real loss is not one MMO. It is the erosion of faith in a system that once allowed small teams to dream big, and players to believe those dreams were worth supporting. Mankind has struck again.

---

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!