You’ve no doubt seen the latest meme making the rounds this week wherein a grid of nine related choices are presented and you’re then prompted to only be able to choose three. Star Wars, ’90s Nickelodeon cartoons, and so many more are being put up against each other and now the Sophie’s Choice game has come to the world of horror. It all started when esteemed horror magazine Fangoria tweeted the meme, saying “you can only keep 3,” posting a photo that includes: Carrie White from Brian De Palma’s Stephen King adaptation, Michael Myers from the Halloween franchise, Freddy Krueger from A Nightmare on Elm Street, Leatherface from The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, Regan MacNeil from The Exorcist, Jason Voorhees from the Friday the 13th series, Chucky from Child’s Play, Ghostface from Scream, and Samara/Sadako from The Ring/Ringu.
Videos by ComicBook.com
you can only keep 3: pic.twitter.com/mHTjZkyAwB
โ FANGORIA (@FANGORIA) April 6, 2020
This has naturally divided the horror community with the majority of replies noting a love for the slasher villains, mostly Michael, Freddy, Jason, and Chucky. Some love is out there for Texas’ own Bubba and California’s Ghostface, but the support of the slashers runs deep on Twitter dot com apparently. Sadly there was little love for 70s classics like Carrie and The Exorcist which are almost assuredly greater than their 80s counterparts.
See for yourself which of these icons of horror are being talked about most below! What’s your favorite out of the options? Think it over and let us know your thoughts in the comment section below!
Unholy Trinity
The Unholy Trinity stays, no contest. Michael, Jason & Freddy, they’re the modern Wolf Man, Frankenstein’s monster & Dracula. Chucky, Ghostface, Leatherface, etc. they’re great, but they’re not as iconic, they’re like Universal’s second wave, with Creature & Invisible Man. https://t.co/8hLqei7ksG
โ SicSexSix [{sic} is the way] (@SicSexSix) April 6, 2020
The slashers win
Michael because i’m a biased bitch, Ghostface and toss up between Jason and Freddy. Anyway slashers win. (Leatherface is okay.) https://t.co/QiCulSerU8
โ Watch Kingdom on Netflix or else (@sirdamienstan) April 7, 2020
Well at least you’re being honest
Keep Leatherface, Ghostface and that scary bitch from The Ring.
โ Rachel #Stay home (@Tinkertot2005) April 7, 2020
Please get rid of Michael Myers that dude scares the crap out of me. https://t.co/Ia8Ee1B4Wa
shots fired
leatherface, michael myers, and jason despite the fact that most of the friday the 13th movies are ass https://t.co/EseBTZKCS0
โ ๐ฉโโค๏ธโ๐โ๐ฉ (@wqosu) April 6, 2020
He wasn’t a choice but go off
Pinhead.
โ Annabella xx ๐ฝ (@RageQuitGirl) April 7, 2020
Pinhead.
Pinhead.
For all three, the rest can be tossed. https://t.co/bvMsXtTMjo
The phone call is coming from inside the house.
By keep, do you mean… in my house? Because I would not like to keep any of them in my house. https://t.co/e0sjG2uy7w
โ Nadia Bulkin (@nadiabulkin) April 6, 2020
One good Leatherface movie is better than every Jason, yeah I said it
Carrie has had a single good film, Leatherface has had a single good film, Samara has had a single good film, Chucky and Ghostface have had a couple of good films, Michael Myers, Jason Voorhees, and Freddy Krueger have all had several good films. Going with them.
โ Critical Thinging (@ThingLB) April 7, 2020
No matter who wins, we lose
this is hard af. No matter who you pick, you’re wrong. I gotta go with Michael, Freddie, Chucky. https://t.co/9dZAYW9hgU
โ Greg the ๐ (@KnnyBlnknshp) April 6, 2020
Scream’s Jamie Kennedy sounds off!
Chunky, Freddy and obviously Ghosty. https://t.co/0D15gJOpmm
โ Jamie Kennedy (@JamieKennedy) April 7, 2020
Keep ’em
If it’s all the same to you, I’d prefer to keep zero. https://t.co/ph4xLKTC6j
โ CT Jeremy (@CriticallyTouch) April 7, 2020