The 10 Best Punisher Storylines in Marvel Comics, Ranked by Impact

The Punisher made his debut in The Amazing Spider-Man #129 (1974) by Gerry Conway, Ross Andru, and John Romita Sr. He was introduced as a vigilante who kills criminals, and who is tricked into gunning for Spider-Man. Since that time, Punisher became a fan favorite, although he often clashed with other heroes, including Spider-Man and Daredevil, before finally getting his own series in the 1980s. However, Frank Castle exploded in popularity thanks to his solo series in the late 1990s and early 2000s, thanks largely to the stories by Garth Ennis and various artists along the way. While there were missteps along the way with FrankenCastle and an angel-powered Punisher, the Punisher’s best stories remain genuine masterpieces.

From his first appearance with Garth Ennis to some of the greatest battles in the MAX comic book line, here is a look at the best Punisher stories, ranked by impact.

10) In the Beginning (Punisher Vol. 7 #1-6, 2004)

Released in 2004 by Garth Ennis and Lewis LaRosa, “In the Beginning” was part of the Punisher MAX comic, which took place on Earth-200111, where Punisher didn’t have to worry about costumed heroes getting in his way. In this storyline, Punisher’s old partner Microchip returns, now working with a CIA officer named Robert Bethell to capture Frank and convince him to work with CIA strike teams. This was the series that introduced Nicky Cavella, who became one of Punisher’s most persistent villains. The impact of this is clear, as it took Castle into an R-rated, real-world environment, and with no superheroes, he was the only way to stop the worst criminals.

9) Mother Russia (Punisher Vol. 7 #13-18, 2004)

Released in Punisher MAX #13-18 by Garth Ennis and Doug Braithwaite, this run sees Nick Fury from Earth-200111 show up to hire Punisher to go on a black-ops suicide mission to penetrate a Russian nuclear silo. His job is to recover a six-year-old girl who has been infected with a deadly retrovirus that could destroy humanity if it reaches the black market. From the monstrous Mongolian to the Russian generals who would remain persistent villains to Frank over his entire MAX run, this delivered a great story that set up the comic to be one massive overarching tale.

8) Circle of Blood (Punisher Vol. 1 #1-5, 1986)

“Circle of Blood” is the best old-school Punisher story. This was the first Punisher solo comic book, a five-issue miniseries from 1986 by Steven Grant and Mike Zeck. Marvel was testing the waters here to see if Punisher could succeed on his own, and the story itself spun out of The Spectacular Spider-Man #81-83, with Frank Castle imprisoned at Ryker’s Island. When a vigilante organization called the Trust breaks him out to serve them as a weapon against organized crime, it leads to backstabbing and plenty of action. This series proved Punisher could stand on his own, and it made him one of the biggest Marvel antiheroes for the next four decades.

7) Long Cold Dark (Punisher Vol. 7 #50-54)

“Long Cold Dark” is a Punisher MAX storyline by Garth Ennis, Howard Chaykin, and Goran Parlov. It ran for five issues and is the final of the three different story arcs involving one of Punisher’s deadliest villains, Barracuda. This story arc makes things personal when Barracuda learns Frank has a daughter, so the villain kidnaps the baby and forces Punisher to travel from New York to California and back to save her and end Barracuda once and for all. The final fight here, with Barracuda losing both arms before being executed, was one of the most brutal executions in any Punisher comic.

6) Up Is Down and Black Is White (Punisher Vol. 7 #19-24, 2004-2005)

“Up Is Down and Black Is White” is a Punisher MAX story by Garth Ennis and Leandro Fernandez that continues Frank Castle’s war with Nicky Cavella. However, what happens here is dark and grim enough that the R-rating was needed above almost any other Punisher story. It has Nicky dig up the graves of Frank’s wife and children, and then he defiles their bodies and broadcasts it to incite hysteria. What happened next was a bloodbath as Punisher went on a citywide slaughter, killing mafia members and street gangs alike in the most savage rampage in Punisher’s history. This storyline also introduced one of Frank’s best supporting cast members, FBI Agent Janice Lynn O’Brien.

5) The End (2004)

Punisher: The End is a one-shot 56-page comic book by Garth Ennis and Richard Corben. This was one of the comics in Marvel’s “The End” line of comics, which included books dedicated to Hulk, Wolverine, and the Fantastic Four. The Punisher comic takes place in a post-apocalyptic future, one year after a World War III caused a nuclear holocaust. Frank Castle is one of the last living people on Earth, dying of radiation poisoning. However, he has one last mission, and that is to kill the wealthy men living in an underground bunker who ruled the world and hoarded all the money before the war. The painted art makes this look and feel more like a horror comic than any other Punisher book.

4) Valley Forge, Valley Forge (Punisher Vol. 7 #55-60, 2008)

“Valley Force, Valley Forge” is a brilliantly told Punisher story by Garth Ennis and Goran Parlov that ended up as the final story that Ennis would tell after working seven years on Punisher stories. This story tied a lot of the past Punisher MAX stories together, with it revealing the Barracuda’s benefactors from “Long Cold Dark” were the same U.S. generals from “Mother Russia.” Here, Frank is the hunted as a Marine recon unit is sent in to kill him, led by the brother of one of Frank’s comrades from Vietnam. The story is told between current action and chapters from a book being written about Frank’s time in Vietnam, tying his entire life together in this one final Garth Ennis story.

3) The Slavers (Punisher Vol. 7 #25-30, 2005-2006)

“The Slavers” is a story in the middle of the Punisher MAX run by Garth Ennis and Scott Koblish. This is a very personal story for Frank, as he is not blindly killing criminals, but trying to save a group of young women from a Moldovan human-trafficking ring in New York. With one of the young women’s backstories showing forced prostitution, extreme abuse, and the slavers killing her infant child, this was the one story arc that showed Punisher as a hero, albeit still a vengeful killer in his own right. When Punisher chose to torture the trafficking ring’s leader before killing him, it showed how far the MAX series would go to punish its worst characters.

2) Punisher: Born (2003)

Punisher: Born is a four-issue limited series by Garth Ennis and Darick Robertson that was released before the Punisher MAX series. This was set on Earth-200111, the same as Punisher MAX, and told a Punisher story from 1971 when he was in Vietnam. This was before the death of his wife and children, and it showed how the war turned Frank Castle into the man capable of becoming the Punisher after their deaths. This is the best Punisher origin story because it shows that he knew he would become this merciless killer in the Vietnam War, rather than in a horrific moment in Central Park. It was this miniseries’ success that convinced Marvel to move on with Punisher MAX one year later.

1) Welcome Back, Frank (Punisher Vol. 5, 2000)

Released in 2000 by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon, “Welcome Back, Frank” was a 12-issue miniseries that was part of the Marvel Knights imprint. This series introduced one of the best villains in any Punisher story, as Ma Gnucci ruled a crime family in New York City, and when Frank takes notice, it begins a bloody war. In the first issue alone, Frank kills Ma Gnucci’s three sons, and then he methodically takes out the rest of her family over the rest of the series. Unlike most of the Punisher’s best stories, this was part of Earth-616, and Daredevil was there to help serve as Frank’s moral counterweight. After several poor decisions in the 1990s for the Punisher (such as turning him into a weapon of Heaven), this is the series that resurrected him and led to his great 2000s run in Punisher MAX.

The 10 Best Scarlet Witch Storylines in Marvel Comics, Ranked by Impact