Welcome to this week in comic book reviews! The staff have come together to read and review nearly everything that released today. It isn’t totally comprehensive, but it includes just about everything from DC and Marvel with the important books from the likes of Image, Boom, IDW, Dark Horse, Dynamite, and more.
Videos by ComicBook.com
The review blurbs you’ll find contained herein are typically supplemented in part by longform individual reviews for significant issues. This week that includes Green Arrow #1, Sins of Sinister: Dominion #1, and Deep Cuts #1.
Also, in case you were curious, our ratings are simple: we give a whole or half number out of five; that’s it! If you’d like to check out our previous reviews, they are all available here.
DC #1
ACTION COMICS #1054
This might be the best issue of Action Comics in recent memory – and that holds true across not just the main story, but one of the secondary stories as well. Action Comics #1054 sees Superman face off with Metallo and marks a turning point for the latter while not only reinforcing everything that makes Superman the hero he is, but setting the stage for the real conflict that this storyline has been promising. Superman, in dealing with Metallo, offers the foe not just grace but his help in finding and rescuing his sister despite the threat Metallo has just made on the Super Twins, but he does it without ignoring the harm Metallo has caused. It’s solid writing that shows a keen understanding of Superman on a fundamental level and while the art falls in a “good enough” category, there are a couple of panels at the end of the story that drive home the threat with the return of a more terrifying foe. As for the secondary stories, “Lois & Clark 2″‘s entry is very predictable, but even at that the obvious twist feels poorly constructed. The real winner of the two secondary stories is “Steel: Engineer of Tomorrow” which somehow puts together nonstop action and a lot of heart while setting the stage for something more exciting. It’s a real delight. Overall, solid issue from cover to cover. — Nicole Drum
Rating: 4 out of 5
BLUE BEETLE: GRADUATION DAY #6
Blue Beetle: Graduation Day lives up to its name with a captivating finale that sets the stage for many more stories to come. Graduation Day feels like Jaime’s true next step as a hero, and the discovery of meaningful purpose moves the person beneath the mask forward as well. Writer Josh Trujillo expertly utilizes Superman to magnify throughout the issue, and his continued faith in Jaime parallels Jaime’s own inner confidence in not just abilities but his judgement. Artist Adrian Gutierrez, colorist Will Quintana, and letterer Lucas Gattoni’s work is stunning from beginning to end, and it would seem this team was born to work on a Blue Beetle series. The artwork crackles with energy and the colors pop off the page, and the expressive lettering makes every word hit with impact. The work on Beetle alone is laudable, but Superman, Starfire, Green Lantern, Dynastes, and Nitida are all just as impressive. A new status quo feels like it brings things full circle and yet opens up new horizons for all involved, and I cannot wait to jump right back into this truly mesmerizing world. — Matthew Aguilar
Rating: 5 out of 5
DETECTIVE COMICS #1071
Detective Comics provides the full backstory of the Orgham line and its ties to both the League of Assassins and another surprising DC villain. It’s a fine reveal and helps click many of the little mysteries and oddities surrounding this extended arc into place. My only qualm about Ram V’s strange arc is that it sometimes meanders, which makes the ultimate reveals a little less impactful. For instance, the League of Assassins/Orgham connection was revealed last issue, which made the more fleshed out details feel a bit more extraneous as the series ramps up to a big story crescendo. Still, this is a great series and a fun and weird ride. Definitely, an unforgettable Batman story. — Christian Hoffer
Rating: 4 out of 5
GREEN ARROW #1
[READ THE FULL REVIEW HERE]
Green Arrow is back in a new ongoing series, and it’s already shaping up to be an all-timer for longtime fans of the Emerald Archer. It’s been a few years since DC had a Green Arrow series on newsstands, though Oliver Queen has kept busy while appearing in titles like Justice League and Checkmate. It seems to be an intentional strategy, so that when a new Green Arrow series launched, fans would have nothing to complain about. While there could be moments where new readers don’t know the whole backstory of characters, Green Arrow #1 manages to give enough subtext that any information lost doesn’t diminish the overall story. — Tim Adams
Rating: 5 out of 5
HARLEY QUINN #29
Harley Quinn #27 set Tini Howard’s run with Harley off on a sort of chaotic and weird tone, and while Harley Quinn #28 is equally as weird, the story is starting to come together with a real sense of threat and challenge while also taking the opportunity to dive into Harley as an introspective and growingly self-aware character. Faced with a real threat to reality and thus, sent into a crisis of her own, Harley seeks out a way to protect herself and the world while she figures out how to best address it and in the process, not only interacts with Zatanna (always fun) but ends up with some real lessons about the nature of being a hero and what that means when you’re Harley Quinn. Howard has a real grasp on Harley’s complicated mind and Sweeney Boo’s art is an absolute home run. The backup story in the issue from Adam Warren not only ties in nicely, but is also an excellent exploration of Harley and her psyche – as well as her ever present and rarely dealt with anxiety. Just a solid issue. — Nicole Drum
Rating: 4 out of 5
DC #2
LAZARUS PLANET: REVENGE OF THE GODS #4
It’s frustrating that Lazarus Planet: Revenge of the Gods #4 is as good as it is considering that the other issues of this mini were relatively weak. Sure, the story wraps up in a surprisingly quiet and almost mild way, but it’s well-written and there are some truly lovely emotional moments even if things are a bit predictable and a little without punch. It feels like most of the loose ends are tied up and given how uneven this series has been, that is a pretty big accomplishment. The real winner here, however, is the backup story that was really fun to read and seemed to have a strong handle on Billy and Mary and really sets the Shazam title up in a nice way. — Nicole Drum
Rating: 3 out of 5
THE RIDDLER: YEAR ONE #4
The latest movie tie-in featuring the earlier days of Edward Nashton take us to his orphanage days, and gives us what might be the best issue of the series to date. While the story of the future Riddler might have some “serial killer tropes” in its pages, Dano and Subic are able to weave an excellent, and downright creepy, story of how one of Gotham’s biggest villains was born. Subic’s art is the stand-out here, with the artist seemingly trying his best to find the essence of madness and drop it onto comic book pages. Depending on how this series ends, it might just be the “go-to” story for those looking to learn more about Gotham City’s master of riddles. — Evan Valentine
Rating: 5 out of 5
THE SANDMAN UNIVERSE: THE DEAD BOY DETECTIVES #5
The finale is framed for The Dead Boy Detectives this month and, while not every element of this mystery is connected, readers are able to see all of the strings woven together into a quickly constricting knot. Following Jai’s second death, the surviving child-ghosts rush about Los Angeles to determine who exactly the summoner is and what they are doing. In that mad dash to stop things from getting much worse, they inevitably do and provide some of the most frightening imagery in this consistently spooky series yet. Jeff Stokely’s depiction of Krasues is chilling, especially given their cruel and destructive nature across issues #4 and #5. As the series prepares for its final revelations and conflict, Thessally’s reappearance heralds the significance of this local mystery and frames a decision that appears absolutely gut-wrenching on its surface. However these events may wrap up, The Dead Boy Detectives will leave readers nervously clutching their armrests until it arrives. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 4 out of 5
TIM DRAKE: ROBIN #8
If the entirety of Tim Drake: Robin was even half as good issue #8, this would be a completely different series. This final arc of the series dispenses with the infantilization of Tim and instead portrays him as a competent, more mature young adult balancing his heroics with real-world responsibility and facing some very relatable challenges while simultaneously throwing him into a conflict that feels complicated, interesting, and also happens to involve Batwoman. Fitzmartin’s writing here is solid and the narration style really works while pulling things together and setting up for this big mystery – and the art from Nikola Cizmesija actually works with the story rather than against here. This issue is good and is the shot in the arm this title should have had from the jump. — Nicole Drum
Rating: 4 out of 5
UNSTOPPABLE DOOM PATROL #2
We got a lot of new information regarding how this iteration of Doom Patrol operates. Dr. Caulder made a comeback in a supporting role for the team, plus they introduced the team’s new base of operations. They are taking full advantage of the chaos from “Lazarus Planet” to create their own Justice League-style operation. There’s a heartbreaking moment involving one of the new recruits to Doom Patrol, but that just moves the plot ahead even more in the conclusion of the story. — Tim Adams
Rating: 4 out of 5
Marvel #1
ALIEN #1
The strength in this new Alien series is that its characters are classically blue-collar style workers that are stuck in what will no doubt be a precarious place because of corporate greed and oversight, but this time with the added wrinkle that they’re all a family too. Writer Declan Shalvey is quick to establish these new characters in a satisfying way, making this feel totally new from any other recent Alien comic series. Artist Andrea Broccardo does good work with the interiors, though there are times where tonally the main family seem to not be in the same story as Xenomorphs, which are presented as fans would expect. — Spencer Perry
Rating: 4 out of 5
AVENGERS BEYOND #2
When you read a comic book, and the first thing you think is “Am I still reading the same series?” it might not be the best sign. Avengers Beyond is a strange jaunt into a side story that focuses on the return of the Beyonder, only he doesn’t appear at all in this second outing. The final page of the first issue almost feels as though it was completely forgotten about until the final page of this issue simply reiterates what the initial issue stated! Drew Landy as the writer here drowns the proceeding in exposition, leaving nothing to the imagination, and making the story that much worse for it. This series feels like its having one of the biggest identity crisises in the comic book world this year and luckily, it’s one that you can avoid. — Evan Valentine
Rating: 1.5 out of 5
BETSY BRADDOCK: CAPTAIN BRITAIN #3
Three issues in, this new chapter for Betsy Braddock seems to have found even more of its stride, combining the ongoing conflict against Morgan Le Fay with some endearing family rapport. Tini Howard’s script has some genuinely great moments for Betsy, Rachel, and company, which balance each characters’ sense of responsibility and destiny swimmingly. Vasco Georgiev’s art has some uncanny moments, but they are vastly outweighed by clever panel construction and whimsy. I’m definitely excited to see where things go next. — Jenna Anderson
Rating: 4 out of 5
CAPTAIN AMERICA: SYMBOL OF TRUTH #12
There’s just something gratifying about seeing artwork by R.B. Silva and Jesus Aburtov. “Cold War” wouldn’t be complete without seeing the duo back again to illustrate the adventures of Sam Wilson’s Captain America. Tochi Onyebuchi also cleverly slips in some tension between Sam and Steve Rogers, which will eventually boil over in the later chapters of the event. There are a lot of moving parts to keep track of, but ultimately it succeeds in showing the different story arcs at play. — Tim Adams
Rating: 5 out of 5
CLOBBERIN’ TIME #2
The Thing arrives to Krakoa and hijinks ensue in Clobberin’ Time #2. All of the most obvious qualities from the first issue remain in an irreverent team-up between Ben Grimm and Logan with plenty of gags and some of the most viscerally thrilling action sequences put to the pages of Marvel Comics this year. The covers frightening imagining of The Things individual rocks being pried forward is realized along with plenty of additional body horror that plays upon Wolverine’s healing factor. Fans of Steve Skroce’s style will not be disappointed by what they find here. However, compared to the high bar set by Clobberin’ Time #1, this sophomore outing struggles a bit more to make its non-action sequences pop with a few more jokes falling flat. The continuation of a mysterious, time-traveling villain offers more clues for readers, but the antagonist remains a deus ex machina to drive excuses for absurd Marvel Team-Up-style stories showcasing one of the medium’s modern greats. This villain succeeds in that aspect of his mission, at least. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 4 out of 5
DAREDEVIL #10
Daredevil #10 draws Matt and Elektra’s experiment with rehabilitation to a permanent close in an issue filled with epic tragedy targeting the underlying premises of the superhero genre. There’s no moral instruction to be found in a cadre of colorful superheroes arriving to pummel the series’ heroes—ones who just made mighty sacrifices to save a child’s life and perhaps the world along with it—because they value putting those individuals in cages before anything else. And Daredevil makes that position clear, resulting in even Spider-Man looking like an absolute fool, although to the series credit it remains critical of its own protagonist as well. The visual sturm und drang of this sweeping onslaught and fall for greater aspirations meets the terrible underlying sadness of the moment, and even lands on a note that could be used to conclude this powerful run. Yet Daredevil #10 doesn’t act as a conclusion, it only frames and signals the arrival of one. Whether Zdarsky and Checchetto can stick the landing remains to be seen, but the promise of this Daredevil has never been clearer. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 4.5 out of 5
DEADPOOL #6
Deadpool #6 takes the book firmly back into the world of slapstick comedy. Wade & Valentine are attempting to have a date, only for Lady Deathstrike and Princess (Deadpool’s dog/symbiote/offspring) to keep fighting assassins in the background who intend to kill our two lovebirds. Long-time Deadpool readers are pretty familiar with how Wade’s relationships go and it still feels like there’s another shoe ready to drop. But it’s still nice to see these two being sweet to one another. — Connor Casey
Rating: 3 out of 5
Marvel #2
DOCTOR STRANGE #2
Stephen and Clea Strange go on one of their most haphazard adventures yet as MacKay’s script embraces Marvel’s most arcane plot devices. Featuring cameos from some of the Sorcerer Supreme’s most notorious opponents in Nightmare, this story is being woven into another murderous whodunnit. That’s both exciting and uninspiring as so far, it’s different from the “Death of Doctor Strange” but not by much. With just a few wrong turns, this story could end up being one of Marvel’s biggest redundancies. Trying to predict the future aside, Doctor Strange #2 does a lot of the heavy lifting required to establish an elaborate story and it does an exceptional job of it at that. — Adam Barnhardt
Rating: 4 out of 5
GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY: BANE OF BLASTAAR #1
Guardians of the Galaxy: Bane of Blastaar makes its debut this week, and sadly, it is a rather lackluster outing. The comic follows our guardians on another wild mission with Nova on hand, but its introduction is a slog. The dialogue between characters is sometimes impossible to track, but in its final pages, the new series begins to pull some punches. So as this new Marvel tale unfolds, prepare yourself for a slow start. — Megan Peters
Rating: 2 out of 5
HULK #14
When this “Starship Hulk” story first began, it felt like a saga that could overstay its welcome rather quickly. It stuck around entirely too long, spiraling into a mass of nonsense and unreadable action. It’s nearly impossible to tell what’s happening on any given page of this issue, though Ottley always had a near impossible task trying to tie a bow on everything that came before. Thankfully, this tale is over, and Hulk can begin a new with a (hopefully) more delicately planned direction. — Charlie Ridgely
Rating: 1.5 out of 5
THE INVINCIBLE IRON MAN #5
Tony Stark’s insurmountable journey continues as the invincible Iron Man falls into an even deeper hole. Duggan’s relentless in his punishment of Stark, putting the character into a corner that he may not escape from. This issue is dark, deeply personal, and downright rude to Stark in all of the best ways. This uphill battle is one only Iron Man could climb, and it’s not looking too good for the Avenger. — Adam Barnhardt
Rating: 4 out of 5
MARY JANE & BLACK CAT #5
Mary Jane & Black Cat has followed a familiar heist mode that writer Jed MacKay has employed many times before, but the formula remains successful because of how the Black Cat miniseries and one-shots consistently build upon familiar Marvel Comics lore to develop characters and deliver twists; this comic is no exception. The friendship between Mary Jane and Black Cat is made to be far more dramatic and interesting after they’ve resolved their internal conflict – witnessing them play off of one another throughout the climactic battle and even afterward is thrilling and often humorous. There are plenty of excuses to showcase the sprawling legions of Limbo in battle within that climax, too, and it makes for some of the most fun, hellish images to emerge from “Dark Web.” Spider-Man fans won’t even miss the wallcrawler when these two share the page, and MacKay once again leaves readers craving more Black Cat (and Mary Jane) tales. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 4 out of 5
MONICA RAMBEAU: PHOTON #5
The conclusion to this new Monica Rambeau series has a fine conclusion, but takes a little too long in getting there. Writer Eve L. Ewing is clearly eager to get to the final half of this issue, which is the entire series at its best, but the setup to get there leaves something to be desired. Artist Luca Maresca and colorist Carlos Lopez work in those final eleven pages is some of its best, blending the history of the titular hero and her unlimited power potential into unique panel-free pages. — Spencer Perry
Rating: 4 out of 5
Marvel #3
SINS OF SINISTER: DOMINION #1
[READ THE FULL REVIEW HERE]
“Sins of Sinister” is the newest installment in a 4-year string of ambitious X-Men events helmed by modern Marvel Comics’ cleverest writers and impressive draftsmen (and colorists). Since the launch of House of X/Powers of X, the franchise has embraced grand sci-fi concepts and sprawling, internecine political conflicts that have reimagined the mutant mythos, while still carving out some space for superhero antics. Elements of time travel, interstellar intelligences, and genetic manipulation are all at play in “Sins of Sinister”‘s alternate timeline, and they promise readers that this era of expansion and ambition is far from over. However, they fail to deliver a satisfying ending for the event itself. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 3 out of 5
STAR WARS: DARTH VADER – BLACK, WHITE, & RED #1
Delivering two stories of attempts to eradicate Darth Vader and one story of his inescapable presence, Darth Vader – Black, White & Red continues the trajectory of the Marvel imprint by delivering captivating tales in a rudimentary color scheme that heightens the intensity of each ordeal. The two stories about vanquishing Vader are compelling enough in their own right and are assuredly amplified in their intensity thanks to the black, white, and red color scheme. The true standout of the book, though, is the tale from Peach Momoko, as it marks some of the most hallucinogenic and nightmarish imagery we’ve seen unravel in the galaxy far, far away, especially as the subject matter fully lends itself to such unsettling artwork. If the book was this story alone, it would be one of the most gorgeous and frightening Star Wars books to hit shelves this year, and while the other two stories are assuredly accomplished, they do take away from the effectiveness of the book as a whole and feel like dips in quality compared to what Momoko pulled off. Still, the book delivers riveting tales of Vader’s villainy and we can’t wait to see what else this title has in store for us down the line. — Patrick Cavanaugh
Rating: 4 out of 5
STRANGE ACADEMY: FINALS #6
And so it ends, the first Strange Academy series has come to a close. Though the finale went exactly as most predicted, Young and Ramos manage to check most of the boxes they needed to before this title sailed off into the sunset. Doyle Dormammu fulfills the prophecy, becoming the most heroic student at Strange Academy – despite being the son of one of Marvel’s most notorious villains. In fact, that’s something that has been at the heart of the story all along, and it’s what Young excelled at with this title. Breaking down barriers and preconceived notions while juggling school work and dating problems is something we all dealt with growing up, and it’s something Young has aced throughout his 24 scripts on this title. That’s amplified with his work on Doyle truly coming full circle. Bravo. — Adam Barnhardt
Rating: 5 out of 5
THOR #33
The good stuff here begins and ends with Nic Klein’s cover. Everything after that is, at best, a lifeless mess. Throwing Thanos into the mix may draw some attention, but he only makes the story more convoluted. — Charlie Ridgely
Rating: 1 out of 5
VENOM: LETHAL PROTECTOR II #2
Two issues in, Lethal Protector II is feeling less like a Venom throwback book and more of an opportunity to dive back into the 90s Marvel aesthetic. Issue #2 is littered with references and appearances from the likes of Cardiac, The Vulture, OG Nick Fury and Dr. Doom. Meanwhile, Venom is fighting his way through legions of soldiers alongside Silver Sable while cracking jokes, making it feel more like a Deadpool comic. It’s by no means a problem, just unexpected. — Connor Casey
Rating: 4 out of 5
WASP #4
Once the Wasps resolve the false reality conundrum that colorfully displayed their characters before leading them into conflict, Wasp quickly loses momentum. Much of the issue is set pitting the two against an amorphous green blob which is no more impressive filling splashes than when it appeared in Wasp #1. The pseudo-science used to defeat the creature is thoroughly addressed, but it’s not particularly compelling. That same logic applies to the many emotional beats in which dialogue is used to express exactly what readers should understand about each individual and their mutual relationships. Although the action is always clear, there is a lack of new visuals and sequences often fail to provide much impact or movement within the individual panels. It’s a blunt approach to an ending that doesn’t lose the charm of Wasp, but makes for the least impressive installment of the miniseries. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 3 out of 5
Other Publishers #1
BEHOLD, BEHEMOTH #5
Behold, Behemoth #5 concludes “Book One” in what may become a much longer saga and finds its best moments in that ending. The connections between different timelines and definition of various antagonistic roles remains somewhat jumbled in a sprawling mythos rushing to tell a complete story, but the emotions and motives surrounding Greyson and his problematic ward are clear enough to provide them with a satisfying conclusion. Much of what’s addressed are broad sweeps of purpose and persistence tied to a worsening world or mental health, but the bromides are kind enough to avoid feeling cheap. The greatest strength of Behold, Behemoth remains its visuals and those are well deployed in a number of splash panels and pages depicting twisted, arcane landscapes and the titular Behemoth itself. That imagery still suggesting grand adventures and lore yet to be discovered may be enough to keep readers hooked, especially if the characters and timelines continue to grow clearer in a potential “Book Two.” — Chase Magnett
Rating: 3 out of 5
BLUE BOOK #3
Blue Book delivers a banger of a backup story, thanks to Lonnie Nadler and Jenna Cha’s grotesque take on the infamous Tarrare, who lived during the French Revolution and was afflicted with an unceasing appetite. The comic is the best story to appear in Blue Book to date and finds a way to re-frame Tarrare’s life story in the context of the French Revolution, which was very well done. Compared to the still painfully dull lead story (which continues to tread well-worn ground to anyone familiar with UFOlogists), Nadler and Cha show off what modern day interpretations of folk lore and “true weird” stories could be and how this book’s format could produce some real gems in the future. — Christian Hoffer
Rating: 3 out of 5
BULLS OF BEACON HILL #4
Bulls of Beacon Hill #4 unravels an already divided house. As our hero finds himself confronted by a gnarly past with their mom, things come to a head when they are reunited with their lover. In its final moments, this week’s issue pits our man against his father in a final showdown, and the winner will get to walk away with their life in tact. — Megan Peters
Rating: 4 out of 5
DEAD ROMANS #2
Dead Romans #2 immediately follows the fallout from the premiere issue’s carnage, putting us in the driver’s seat of Honoria. The artistic style for the Image Comic by Nick Marinkovich takes a more minimalistic approach to these new “final days” of the Roman Empire and it’s the highlight in the second issue. Story-wise, it could use a little more “meat on the bone” but this feels like more of a feast for the eyes in this alternate history story. If you’re a history buff or are looking for a solid story that plunks readers into the story of Rome, this might definitely be worth your time. — Evan Valentine
Rating: 3 out of 5
DEEP CUTS #1
[READ THE FULL REVIEW HERE]
Deep Cuts #1 might not reinvent the wheel in regards to its storytelling, but the craftsmanship on display makes it a worthwhile read. The issue weaves the series’ first, but not last, tale of the intersection between jazz and the human experience, all while introducing characters that are worth following, whether or not they pop into future issues of the anthology. There is definitely a lot of potential within these pages and some clever artistry, too. — Jenna Anderson
Rating: 3.5 out of 5
DUNE: HOUSE HARKONNEN #4
Dune: House Harkonnen #4 functions more like an illustrated history of lore than a narrative. The many characters detailed in the title all receive a check-in, but many are spaced by captions detailing multi-year leaps. Readers never invest in Duke Leto’s first paramore or child because they are only shown to reveal new conflicts or threats. Each leap forward provides clear exposition but little reason to continue reading, especially as almost any reader of Dune: House Harkonnen is already well aware of how these events and lives conclude. Rabban’s appearance in issue #4 merely reiterates previous events and a cruelty that’s defined the character. Although the layouts and compositions on these pages capably deliver relevant information, they lack the space or attention necessary to craft deeper emotions or impressive moments within any of the surrounding events. While this might be more indulgent and accessible than scanning various wiki pages, it’s worth noting that the wiki version would still be free. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 2 out of 5
GARGOYLES #5
It’s only taken the better part of six months to get this comic on the tracks, but Weisman and Kambadais really start cooking with Gargoyles #5. After getting readers situated in the world they may or may not have watched growing up, Weisman is able to focus on concocting a coherent plot that’s stronger than anything this comic’s seen yet. Better yet, Kambadais gets to flex his action muscles again with a couple more scenes that are a delight to see. — Adam Barnhardt
Rating: 4 out of 5
Other Publishers #2
GRIM #10
It may seem like a simple scene, but seeing Jessica and Annabel talk woman-to-woman for multiple pages was very nice to see. Annabel delivered sage advice, and helped guide Jess along the way after losing confidence and admitting how scared she was to storm the afterlife. I never paid attention to it before, but the color contrast with just about every character wearing red and the dark, grey background was a nice touch. And just as I’m soaking up the girl power moment, the final page throws all of that out the window with a surprise swerve. I must say, well done. — Tim Adams
Rating: 5 out of 5
IMAGE! #12
Image wraps up its 30th Anniversary year-long anthology on a high note, loaded with fun little one-shots like “Dirty Deeds,” “Mascots,” “Chance Meeting” and “Science Dog.” Geoff Johns’ “Blizzard,” the highlight of the anthology from its opening issue, manages to stick the landing even if I’m not quite familiar with the franchise referenced in the final panels. Reviewing this anthology for the past 12 months has left me incredibly interested in various Image comics, so mission accomplished! — Connor Casey
Rating: 4 out of 5
INDIGO CHILDREN #2
Indigo Children‘s structure is baffling. After spending the oversized first issue speeding through a journalist’s investigation into the mysterious children, its second issue is a vaporous, style-over-substance stretch introducing a second character. Despite that, readers come out knowing little about the character beyond that he’s another of the Indigo Children and an architecture prodigy due to his gifts, adding up to little more than another block in the mystery box wrapped in a powerset. Now that these children are in open conflict with those that would control them, the series has begun to resemble Joshua Dysart’s excellent reimagining of Valiant’s Harbinger from about a decade ago. Except, Dysart filled his book with complicated young characters and steeped his story in a matching tone. By comparison, Indigo Children feels thin and sterile, with its minimalist artwork that often stumbles over its panel flow. Some pages want to slow down time with panels of glass shards falling to the floor, but because of the haphazard placement, they come off more as affectation than something purposeful. The whole thing feels hollow, a style in search of a purpose, and a mystery imploring readers to place unearned trust in the book as it unravels. — Jamie Lovett
Rating: 2 out of 5
KAYA #7
Kaya #7 introduces the series’ second arc and it promises to be even more rewarding than the bright, beautiful, and boisterous first outing. This time the story takes Kaya and a small party of companions into the Poison Lands – a new landscape filled with toxic green landscapes and deformed flora and fauna. The new setting radiates wonder and danger simultaneously and even suggests the ground beneath Kaya’s feet may be untrustworthy. It is a wonderfully introduced new arrangement that also provides Jin an opportunity to explore his own role in the growing epic. Captured by an array of terrifically designed fearsome monsters, Jin is compelled to recall his earliest memories and faith in himself, including a gripping cliffhanger that makes the escalation in Kaya clear. Kaya has already proven itself to be one of the most visually innovative and engaging new tales in comics, and issue #7 makes it clear that the best is still ahead. — Chase Magnett
Rating: 4.5 out of 5
KILLADELPHIA #30
It is not an exaggeration that if you read just one comic this week or maybe even this year, it should be Killadelphia #30. The issue sees the eagerly anticipated crossover between the title and its spinoff Nita Hawes’ Nightmare Blog as Nita comes to the city to be part of the fight, but the confrontation between her and James isn’t the only reason this book is easily a masterpiece. It’s the other story that runs along with this, a glimpse into Seesaw’s life before, well, everything, in which he tells the story of someone close to him and how human cruelty and violence destroyed them. Killadelphia as a story broadly does an incredible job of balancing it’s horror story with an authentic examination of the human experience, but this particular issue perhaps most soberly and beautifully addresses both the humanity and inhumanity of people. That’s its brilliance: there’s a lesson here and Barnes offers it up in a way that you can’t help but receive it and never sacrifices story to do it. — Nicole Drum
Rating: 5 out of 5
LOCAL MAN #3
Local Man somehow manages to be even more outstanding than the issues that preceded it. As Jack’s newfound efforts as a hometown vigilante begin to escalate, his past and future as a 90s superhero—and an imperfect man—only grow more relevant. Tim Seeley and Tony Fleecs’ work on this is nothing short of exceptional – it’s reverential without ever feeling derivative, and a darn good mystery to boot. — Jenna Anderson
Rating: 5 out of 5
THE NEIGHBORS #2
The Neighbors #2 manages to add in quite a bit ore emotional depth but doesn’t do much in the way of progressing the plot. We take a deep dive into Oliver’s physique this issue, how he has developed what appears to be agoraphobia since his transition and how he continues to struggle with the outside world reacting to him. It’s a fascinating angle, one that likely would’ve benefitted the introductory issue. Unfortunately, the time devoted to that takes away from the big mystery, leaving a clearly possessed (or an outright imposter) Casey to stand around with a creepy smile while nobody seems to notice. — Connor Casey
Rating: 3 out of 5
PLUSH #6
Plush has been a series unlike anything else I’ve read, and though there aren’t as many surprises in the finale, that didn’t keep it from delivering a brutally fulfilling conclusion. Writer Doug Wagner hits all the right notes and gives fans satisfying payoffs to the battle they’ve all been waiting for, and artist Daniel Hillyard, colorist Rico Renzi, and letterer Ed Dukeshire fill the issue with some of their most best and goriest work yet. The book’s first two pages set the tone of what’s to come brilliantly, and by the end fans will have this particular story wrapped up but will also leave the door open for future possibilities. I was kind of waiting for a big swerve or two, but that never really happened. That’s a small complaint hough, and overall Plush has been an unexpected gem that I’m glad I experienced, and hopefully this isn’t the last time we see this oddball crew. — Matthew Aguilar
Rating: 4 out of 5
STAR TREK #7
After battling a mad Klingon Emperor within a living god-city, the crew of the USS Theseus has earned a little shore leave, and they get that in Star Trek #7. Sisko and those under his command return to Deep Space 9 for an issue that allows these characters some time to breathe and be characters. Collin Kelly and Jackson Lanzing have the voices of these characters down perfectly to the point that readers may find themselves reading dialog in the voices of the actors who played them, from Avery Brooks’ jazz-like line deliveries as Sisko to Gates McFadden’s playful bemusement at Quark’s advances as Beverly Crusher. Mike Feehan manages to capture crucial moments in the faces of these characters, from the cautious wonder in the eyes of Sisko’s daughter as she meets her father for the first time to Kasidy Yates’ hidden consternation over her husband’s proclamations of commitment to their mortal, linear life. And yet, the creative team still mages to fit in a thrilling double-page spread of the Theseus in battle, putting Sisko’s reputation as Starfleet’s wartime commander to the test. It’s pretty much everything a fan could want from a Star Trek comic. — Jamie Lovett
Rating: 4 out of 5
Other Publishers #3
STAR WARS: THE HIGH REPUBLIC ADVENTURES – QUEST OF THE JEDI #1
While just a one-off story, Quest of the Jedi quickly establishes itself as one of the more intriguing entries in this High Republic era. It’s a simple, straightforward story that makes great use out of its time period and characters. An exploration of the mysterious ways in which the Force works continues to be a compelling journey in Star Wars lore and Claudia Gray does it quite well. — Charlie Ridgely
Rating: 4 out of 5
TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES #139
While reading Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #139, it may dawn on some readers how far afield this era of the Turtles’ saga is from where they started. Once, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles followed a close-knit family of martial artists who would sometimes moonlight as street-level vigilantes. Now they’re learning magic to control the pseudo-scientific concept of “radiant gravity” to defeat a nigh-omnipotent godlike being. It’s particularly odd considering how intimate and community-focused the earlier issues of Sophie Campbell’s run on the book were. And a months-long event will do that to any ongoing title. And it isn’t like it’s off-brand for the Turtles. That the series has previously jumped from action, the dimension-hopping sci-fi, to mystical fantasy has been part of its appeal. Perhaps Kitsune’s attempt to quantify the idea of a magnetic personality in terms of quantum physics brushes a little too close to a Jedi explaining the Force via midi-chlorians for comfort, making the wonderous less so by trying to define it. And yet, Fero Pe and Ronda Pattison remain capable of bringing crisp energy to even an issue mostly about presaging what’s to come, with subtle shifts into a more watercolor-like style during softer moments. The central idea may be on the clunky side, but the execution of the issue is top-notch. — Jamie Lovett
Rating: 3.5 out of 5
TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES: THE ARMAGEDDON GAME #7
The central “Armageddon Game” maxiseries had to carry the weight of the scale of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles event, often touching on multiple ongoing subplots. However, as the story approaches its close, this penultimate installment of the series gets to play host to several climactic payoffs that have been building throughout the saga. The issue is one page after another of solidly drawn action that should keep Turtles fans on the edge of their seats. Admittedly, the endless posturing in the dialog accompanying the action gets tiresome. It even goes the full Chris Claremont at one point when two female characters are fighting, and one combatant threatens to drain the other’s “life force” before proceeding to do so. But while the script might have done with leaner verbiage, the issue never gets bogged down, instead moving at a breakneck pace toward its finish. By the end, it is clear that the main thrust of The Armageddon has come to a satisfying conclusion, and the final act is about to begin. — Jamie Lovett
Rating: 3.5 out of 5
TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES: THE LAST RONIN – THE LOST YEARS #3
The Last Ronin – The Lost Years continues struggling with its split focus, primarily due to the writers’ insistence on flashing back within those stories. It’s natural enough when April tells the next generation of stories about her past, but to open the issue with a single-page cold in the past before switching to the future is baffling, especially when it means Michelangelo ends up filling readers in on everything that cold open jumped over. The issue is also heavy on tropes, such as Michelangelo coming under the tutelage of another wise man while traveling through Asia, this time one who gained wisdom after going blind. At least the issue has the good grace to acknowledge that it’s pulling from martial artist B-movies, which is essentially what the story offers. It feels like the middle act of a movie one might watch on Tubi on a Saturday afternoon. That’s not bad if you’re into that kind of thing, but it doesn’t live up to what the original The Last Ronin series offered. Hopefully, this doesn’t turn into a series of diminishing returns. — Jamie Lovett
Rating: 3 out of 5
TORRENT #3
While Torrent #3 is still overwritten and relies too much on some really bad tropes, this issue is a marked improvement from the previous two issues – at least in terms of the writing and story. The art is still not great, but it’s also just the style of the issue now so it is what it is. When the system fails her, Michelle again takes things into her own hands and honestly, it’s pretty interesting, watching the system laid bare like that for a few pages. There’s a harsh reality there that really comes up off the page before the story slides back into its cliches and tropes. At least Michelle is starting to be just a little bit less of a caricature in small moments this issue. It feels like a shift in a better direction. — Nicole Drum
Rating: 2 out of 5
VANISH #6
Truth be told I’m rather conflicted about Vanish #6, but that conflict isn’t about the series really, but more about the characters, revelations, and story found within the issue. In that regard, this is easily the most compelling issue of the series yet. Writer Donny Cates played with readers perspective and emotions last time around, but things become far clearer in issue #6, and it’s turned my perception of the book upside down. You still can’t help but feel for Oliver’s internal struggles and how they’ve affected his life, but revelations here bring Elynnor and Halcyon’s perspectives into the light, and afterwards you can’t help but look at Oliver in a much different way. Oliver’s role in all of this has never been murkier, but I can also say that I’ve never been as immersed in finding that out since issue #1. The artwork of Ryan Stegman, Netho Diaz, JP Mayer, Jay Listen, Sonia Back, and John J. Hill is stellar throughout, and those heartbreaking reveals don’t hit nearly as hard without this team at the wheel. So much is done with expressions alone, but when the book wants shift gears, the character designs and action sequences pack plenty of punch. I have no idea at times who to root for, but I simply can’t turn away, and I need more answers ASAP. — Matthew Aguilar
Rating: 4 out of 5
WHAT’S THE FURTHEST PLACE FROM HERE? #12
Sid’s journey takes an unexpected detour as she crosses paths with “elders,” which has been a rare occurrence in What’s The Furthest Place From Here?. Of course, the elders have to be depicted in the most horrifying way possible, with over-exaggerated facial expressions and sayings. The overall story has taken so many twists and turns it’s been hard to keep track of all the main players, but just seeing how this new society has created its own class system is something to behold. — Tim Adams
Rating: 3 out of 5
