For a galaxy so vast and a history so rich, the Star Wars universe has always held an irresistible allure for exploring alternate realities. What if Luke Skywalker joined his father on the dark side? What if the Rebel Alliance failed to destroy the Death Star? These tantalizing questions, the bread and butter of speculative fiction, were once explored in great detail through the Star Wars Infinities line of comics. Released by Dark Horse Comics, these retellings of the original trilogy showed thrilling deviations from the established canon, allowing writers and artists to embrace their creativity and reimagine pivotal moments in a classic saga. Infinities provided a sandbox for exploring the boundless potential of “what ifs” within the Star Wars framework.
Videos by ComicBook.com
In a landscape now dominated by a tightly controlled canon, the spirit of Infinities—that willingness to playfully and dramatically diverge from the familiar—feels sorely missed. The time is ripe for Marvel Comics to revisit this concept, offering both longtime fans and newcomers a fresh and exciting way to engage with the beloved galaxy far, far away.
Exploring Divergent Paths Deepens Appreciation for the Core Saga

The beauty of the Infinities comics lay not just in their diverging scenarios, but in how they illuminate the core narrative of Star Wars by showing us what it was not. These tales aren’t just simple rewrites; they delve into the core essence of characters and conflicts, often revealing surprising new dimensions and possibilities that the constraints of canon wouldn’t allow. The very act of imagining these altered trajectories sparked engaging discussions among fans, enriching their understanding and appreciation of the established narrative. By witnessing the surprise conclusion of Vader becoming Anakin once more after saving his children in Return of the Jedi or the desperate struggle of a galaxy under the Empire’s iron fist after the destruction of the Rebel base on Yavin in The Empire Strikes Back, readers gained a renewed appreciation for the choices made and the sacrifices endured in the main canon. These alternate realities act as powerful counterpoints, highlighting the fragility of hope and the significance of individual actions in shaping the fate of the galaxy.
REALTED: Star Wars: 5 Essential Darth Vader Comics to Read For Revenge of the Sith’s 20th Anniversary
For instance, the A New Hope arc in Infinities tells a chilling tale where Princess Leia succumbs to the dark side and becomes her father’s ruthless Sith apprentice, a stark contrast to her unwavering resolve as a leader of the rebellion in the original trilogy and a exploration of the darkness that lurks within even the most virtuous people. Similarly, seeing Luke Skywalker die on Hoth instead of being rescued by Han Solo in The Empire Strikes Back variation answers the question of whether or not the rebellion would have succeeded without him. These exploratory plots are not simply about shock value; they are about dissecting the fundamental themes of Star Wars—destiny, choice, good versus evil—through a prism of altered circumstances, offering fresh insights into characters we thought we knew intimately.
Reintroducing “What If” Scenarios Could Inject Fresh Creativity into the Star Wars Universe

In an era where Star Wars storytelling often treads familiar ground, revisiting the Infinities concept could be a vital injection of fresh creativity. The current canon, while expansive, sometimes feels constrained by the need to connect every story point and maintain a cohesive timeline. An Infinities style series, whether in comic, novel, television, or film format, would liberate creators from these restrictions, allowing them to explore bolder, more imaginative and unique stories without the pressure of fitting them neatly into the established lore.
Imagine stories where Anakin Skywalker never fell to the dark side, where Qui-Gon Jinn survived his duel with Darth Maul and trained Anakin, or even more outlandish scenarios like the Ewoks developing advanced technology, or the Clone Wars ending in a completely unexpected way. This approach could attract a diverse range of writers, directors, and artists, each bringing their unique vision to the Star Wars universe and offering fans exciting and unpredictable stories.
Furthermore, these non-canon tales could serve as a testing ground for new ideas and concepts, some of which might even subtly influence future canon storylines without being bogged down by canon. By embracing the “what if,” Lucasfilm could unlock a treasure trove of untapped storytelling potential, keeping the Star Wars galaxy vibrant and full of surprises for generations to come. The possibilities are as boundless as the stars themselves, waiting to be explored in thrilling and imaginative new ways.