Anakin Skywalker’s quip about hating sand in Star Wars: Episode II – Attack of the Clones is among the character’s best-known (and most mocked) lines, but there is a deeper meaning behind this oft-quoted Star Wars line, and it’s rather revealing in terms of Anakin’s fall to the dark side. Star Wars fans may have lamented George Lucas’ departure from the moment that Disney bought Star Wars, but the creator of the galaxy far, far away was no stranger to harsh criticism and mockery, particularly after the introduction of the prequel trilogy in the late 90s and early 00s.
Videos by ComicBook.com
One of the biggest complaints was specifically the dialogue and, even more specifically, Anakin’s dialogue. Yet, Lucas is still widely seen as a movie genius for a reason, and despite the decades-long critiques, many of the Anakin lines that audiences continue to cringe over reflect the same wit. One such line is Anakin’s Attack of the Clones declaration that he hates sand (“it’s coarse and rough and irritating”), which reveals a greater truth about Anakin’s downfall.
Anakin’s Hatred Of Sand Was Metaphorical
For years, Anakin’s explanation for his hatred of sand has been a joke within the fanbase. The scene has been meme’d to death, and even Attack of the Clones and Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith Anakin actor Hayden Christensen has made jokes about the character’s aversion to sand. Yet, there is something much more significant beneath this seemingly goofy line.
Namely, sand is frequently used metaphorically in fiction to represent the passage of time. While there is unquestionably a literal component to Anakin’s feelings—he grew up struggling against sandstorms on Tatooine, after all—there is something to the idea that this metaphorical understanding of sand also applies.
Sand is a figurative stand-in for time because it, like time, easily slips through one’s fingers. For Anakin, this notion underscores his lack of control, which was one of his biggest anxieties before his fall to the dark side. Although he was one of the most powerful Jedi in the Order throughout the prequel trilogy era and was the literal Chosen One, there were some things even he could not prevent, and that drove him directly toward the dark.
Anakin’s Fears Were Linked To Time/The Future
At the beginning of Attack of the Clones, it seemed that Anakin’s biggest grievances were Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi’s position of authority over him and his feelings for Padmé that he could (theoretically) never act on. He had multiple outbursts about both issues in the first half of the movie, until his story took a much darker turn and he learned that the Tusken Raiders had abducted and tortured his mother, Shmi Skywalker, leading to her death.
After that loss, however, Anakin was driven by a fear of losing anyone else he loved, and he became entirely obsessed with controlling the future, particularly as it pertained to Padmé—although Star Wars: The Clone Wars later revealed that Anakin had also experienced anxieties over losing his Padawan, Ahsoka Tano. In the end, that need to control what happened to Padmé led Anakin to accept Chancellor Palpatine’s offer for him to join him as his Sith apprentice, effectively dooming himself and the rest of the galaxy.
This is why Anakin’s nightmares plagued him so severely, particularly in Revenge of the Sith. Seeing glimpses of the future that he had no true control over drove Anakin so mad that he was willing to abandon everything he stood for and believed in just to give himself some semblance of control. Of course, the real irony and tragedy of Darth Vader was that it was Anakin’s willingness to betray the Jedi that led to the loss of everything and everyone he cared about.
Anakin’s Graveside Promise Revealed The True Meaning Behind His Words
It may seem like a stretch to say that Anakin’s hatred of sand was in part metaphorical, but Attack of the Clones makes that clear during the scene in which Anakin kneels next to Shmi’s grave. After saying that he hadn’t been strong enough to save her, Anakin vows that he will not fail again, all while grasping a fistful of sand. Notably, Anakin also holds onto the sand throughout this scene, never releasing it.
That moment alone symbolizes Anakin’s desperation for control and his insistence on dominating things that can’t really be dominated, such as life, death, and the future. Anakin’s vow was never going to hold, as he had no real ability to prevent death or control the fate of his loved ones, but he was determined to uphold it all the same. This very vow would be the driving force behind his obsession with saving Padmé’s life in Revenge of the Sith, which sadly only further cemented that even Anakin wasn’t powerful enough to change the future.
Is it still a little goofy that Anakin was trying to flirt with Padmé by saying sand gets everywhere? Sure. But, the truth is, there was much more to Anakin’s hatred of sand than there initially seemed to be.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Most Viewed
-
Image courtesy of MAPPA -
Image courtesy of Daybreak Game Company
