DC Will Never Get a Better Batman Actor Than Christian Bale

When Batman Begins first hit theaters in 2005, it was immediately obvious that Christopher Nolan was ready to take the Caped Crusader into the 21st Century. Long gone were the days of a campy Batman with colorful DC villains and an unmistakable aesthetic that was like no other. Instead, we were introduced to a realistic world where Batman could logically exist and all of his trauma and mental baggage were a central aspect of his character. And what better actor to bring that gritty version of Batman to life than Christian Bale? His grounded approach to the not-quite-super superhero gave credence to the real-world problems affecting Gotham City. While Bruce Wayne may have been a wealthy playboy with an endless imagination for extracurricular activities, deep down he was still a deeply flawed human who just wanted to make his home a better place to live.

Okay, Christian Bale’s Batman still enjoyed beating his enemies to a bloody pulp and playing with state-of-the-art gadgets that made him look cool as hell. But it was all for a good cause, right? No matter his exact motivations, The Dark Knight Trilogy gave us a live-action Batman that we had never seen before on the big screen. While icons like Adam West and Michael Keaton each gave unmistakable performances as Batman, no other actor was able to provide the all-in physicality as well as the character’s empathy as Christian Bale did. Which is why DC will never get a better Batman.

The Bale Was in His Court

By the time Christian Bale signed on to star in Batman Begins, he was on the cusp of joining the A-list tier of Hollywood actors. He was building heat coming off a string of critically acclaimed movies that put the actor on everybody’s radar. His performances in films such as American Psycho and Reign of Fire not only proved that he was capable of carrying a film, but delivering varied and nuanced performances. However, his most impressive (and dangerous) feat was his dramatic weight transformation after starring in The Machinist.

In the nightmarish thriller, Christian Bale’s weight plummeted to just 120 pounds to play the titular insomniac character. Just six months later, he gained 100 pounds for his starring role as Bruce Wayne in Batman Begins. He gained so much weight that he was actually ordered to lose some extra pounds before filming began. That kind of dedication is what sets Christian Bale apart from his peers; whether or not that dedication is recommended by health professionals is another story. But it’s clear that the Welsh actor takes every one of his roles seriously, and becoming Batman was more than just another paycheck to him.

Beyond the physical transformation to play Batman, Christian Bale tapped into his acting prowess to offer up a performance that we had yet to see in any Batman movie before. While young Bruce Wayne becoming an orphan has always been a cornerstone to the character, Christian Bale tapped into that torment and allowed us to better understand the Dark Knight. Unlike his DC superhero counterparts, Batman isn’t equipped with any super strength or the ability to fly. Instead, his sense of justice is what propels him. In The Dark Knight trilogy, that motivation became more obvious than ever before.

[RELATED: How Creature Commandos Set Up the New DCU Batman]

Taking a Batter Look at the Competition

While DC will likely never get a better Batman than Christian Bale, it’s important to note the actors that came before and after him. Let’s face it, Adam West’s Batman would never pose a physical threat to any criminal in today’s world, but his campiness and screen presence made his performance one of a kind. It would almost be impossible to attempt to duplicate it; instead, just about every modern actor to play Batman has landed in the Michael Keaton camp. He played Batman with such a cool, calm, and collected demeanor that it took the character to a whole other level.

Following in Keaton’s footsteps, Val Kilmer and George Clooney each portrayed Batman as an always-suave crimefighter who is simply never not cool. Unfortunately for both actors, the same cannot be said about the films that they each appeared in. Batman Forever was critically panned and Batman & Robin is regarded as the worst-reviewed Batman movie of all time according to Rotten Tomatoes. While Kilmer and Clooney did what they could with their respective roles, their performances will ultimately be forgotten. Except for Clooney’s Batsuit nipples. Sadly, those will never be forgotten.

Since the end of The Dark Knight trilogy, DC has certainly been on the hunt for its next iconic Batman. Ben Affleck’s take on the character may have been action-oriented, but his performance was neither iconic nor laughably bad – he was just sort of there. As for Robert Pattinson, the jury is still out on his overall performance, but he is off to a great start. He put a unique and grunge-filled spin on the titular character in Matt Reeve’s The Batman. With a sequel currently slated for 2027, he just might be ready to give Christian Bale a run for his money.

You can stream Batman movies on Max.