Ahsoka Adapted A Controversial Arc That Star Wars Rebels’ Writers Purposefully Avoided

Star Wars: Ahsoka, released on Disney+ in August 2023, was essentially a sequel to the animated series Star Wars Rebels, picking up the threads left hanging after Ezra Bridger and Grand Admiral Thrawn disappeared to parts unknown. While seeing Ahsoka Tano, Hera Syndulla, Ezra, and Sabine Wren brought into live action was an exciting notion on its own, finally opening the door to answer the lingering questions from Rebels, one character shocked the fanbase and immediately became a polarizing topic among: the choice to make Sabine Wren a Force user and Ahsoka’s former (and eventually, current) Jedi Padawan. Taking Sabine from her established history as a fierce Mandalorian and temporary rightful wielder of the Darksaber, holding and using the saber never equated to being Force-sensitive in the larger Star Wars lore, as the Darksaber’s tradition requires it to be won in battle. With that precedent established, Sabine in Rebels did train with the Darksaber under Kanan Jarrus’ guidance, but she very specifically was not a Jedi or even Force-sensitive.

On the latest episode of the Pod of Rebellion Podcast, Rebels writer Henry Gilroy appeared as a surprise guest and confirmed that this exact character arc was, in fact, heavily debated and then consciously abandoned by the creative team. In embracing this rejected storyline, Ahsoka not only reopened old debates but also established a new future for Sabine, forcing the fandom to question exactly what it means to be a Jedi and whether it is necessary to be a great hero.

Star Wars Rebels Writers Chose to Highlight Sabine’s Important Non-Jedi Identity

The very specific choice made by the Rebels team to keep Sabine and her skills separate from formal Jedi training has been a topic of discussion for years, but recent details from Gilroy on the Pod of Rebellion podcast have shed new light on how much care and thought went into such a delicate decision. According to Gilroy, the idea of Sabine becoming a Jedi or being intrinsically Force-sensitive was certainly a recurring conversation that took place in the writers’ room. Ultimately, the team, led by executive producer Dave Filoni, chose to avoid the Jedi route for several legitimate and thematically appropriate reasons.

Read Next

Star Wars Rebels Stars Reflect on Reuniting for Pod of Rebellion

Most important to the writers and integrity of the character was Sabine’s identity as a Madalorian first and an artist second. Her journey was about finding a way to fight for a cause without relying on the mystical powers of the Force, carving out a space for a different kind of hero in the galaxy. Her power came from strategy, technology, and the Mandalorian tradition of physical fighting—a counterpoint to the Jedi path that Ezra Bridger walked with his Master, Kanan. As Gilroy explained, the writers felt that making her a Jedi would take away from who she already was and the part she played on the Ghost team, especially after her successful, if difficult, training to effectively use the Darksaber. The power of that moment—where a non-Force user wields a one-of-a-kind Mandalorian lightsaber not out of destiny, but out of political and cultural necessity—would have been cheapened if Sabine was revealed to be Force-sensitive all along.

The Rebels showrunners were committed to adhering to the lore they had established—that heroism and destiny were not exclusive to those who could wield a lightsaber through the Force. Rebels already had a very important story centered on the Jedi path with Ezra and Kanan, as well as the eventual return of Ahsoka Tano and even Obi-Wan and Darth Maul. The Ghost crew, and by extension the entire rebellion, needed diversity in its heroes. Sabine was a core member of that crew, representing the ordinary yet fiercely capable warrior. The purposeful choice to keep Sabine off the Jedi path was a commitment to respecting the distinct, non-Jedi space they had created for her. For four seasons, the storyline remained firmly closed, making Sabine’s contributions to the New Republic a distinct achievement for someone without the Force.

Star Wars: Ahsoka Reopened the Conversation and Took the Scrapped Path

When Ahsoka premiered, its very first acts confirmed that Dave Filoni, now guiding the story in live-action as writer and director, was ready to challenge that prior decision. The series immediately established that Ahsoka Tano had taken Sabine on as a Padawan after the events of Rebels, attempting to teach her the ways of the Force. This choice was met with mixed reactions from a fan base who felt it retconned the established themes in Rebels, specifically the idea that anyone could be a hero regardless of their natural connection to the Force.

However, Ahsoka did not approach Sabine’s arc as a simple, easy retcon, but rather as a difficult—and arguably failed—mentorship with the quintessential Jedi, Ahsoka Tano. Ironically, the choice served as support for why the Rebels writers initially had reservations. Ahsoka spent the bulk of its run illustrating Ahsoka’s struggles over the past years. Sabine represented Ahoska’s failure and a larger connection to her and Anakin, as former master and apprentice, rather than focusing on Sabine as a character.

The series ultimately justified its decision in two major ways. First, it recontextualized Ahsoka’s decision to mentor her. Ahsoka admitted her choice was driven by desperation, seeking a student who could find Ezra, suggesting her choice was pragmatic and driven by the goal, rather than the actual means. Second, and most critically, the climax of Sabine’s journey on Peridea involved her intentionally choosing to accept the risk of failure in using the Force. In the final moments of the season, she finally connects with the Force, not in a grand or flashy way, but in a small, desperate act to help Ezra. This moment reframed the controversy: Sabine’s power was not about being inherently gifted, but about her hard-won faith and choice to believe in the potential of the Force, validating Ahsoka’s faith in her, even if she was the most unorthodox student the Jedi tradition had ever seen.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!