Some anime endings do a perfect job of tying everything together, while others leave viewers staring at the screen in disappointment and disbelief. But there’s a third option: a finale so divisive fans just can’t decide what to think about it. Such controversial endings don’t always ruin a show, but they do spark debates, rewatches, and theories that just refuse to die. Some fans analyze every frame for answers that may not even exist. While others just give up on the series.
Videos by ComicBook.com
There are also cases where fans just don’t agree with the writer’s vision of the ending. But regardless of whether viewers hate how the story wraps up or defend it, no one forgets a finale that stirs this much emotion. And that can lead to even more controversy. The conversation stretches across social media, conventions, and online reviews, where fans dissect every detail. The fallout does not stop with the audience. Studios and creators feel the pressure, and some respond with sequels, re-cuts, or complete reimaginings while others stick to their original vision. But all that aside, here are ten controversial anime endings that left fans split down the middle.
As the List Suggests, MAJOR Spoilers for the Following Anime Endings Ahead
Death Note
Death Note built up a thrilling battle of wits, but Light Yagami’s final defeat left fans split. Light spent the series manipulating, strategizing, and staying ten steps ahead, so his defeat should have matched that intensity. Instead, it felt too simple. Near, L’s successor, set a trap that exposed Light without the same tension as their earlier mind games. The once-calculating Kira lost control, made reckless mistakes, and fell apart in a way that felt unearned.
Some saw this as a fitting end since Light’s arrogance has always been his greatest weakness. Others thought his defeat came too easily, as if Near only won because the story needed to end rather than because he truly outsmarted him. Ryuk’s final move — writing Light’s name in the Death Note — gave the story closure, though the last battle left us wondering what could have been. In this situation, a more intense showdown might have changed everything.
Devilman Crybaby
Devilman Crybaby’s controversial ending dragged us into chaos and never let us catch our breath. Akira gave everything to save humanity, but in the end, there was nothing left to save. His final fight with Ryo, now revealed as Satan, was brutal, messy, and filled with heartbreak. When the dust cleared, Ryo finally realized the truth — he had always loved Akira. But by then, it didn’t matter. His best friend was gone, the world was in ruins, and the cycle of destruction was about to start all over again.
Some called this ending a masterpiece, a gut punch that stayed true to the manga’s tragic roots. Others thought it was pure cruelty, a story that never gave us a chance to hope. The wild animation, the eerie soundtrack, and the way the anime refused to hold back ensured we’d never forget it. Whether we loved its fearlessness or hated how it broke us, Go Nagai’s Devilman Crybaby left us sitting there, stunned, trying to process what we had just watched.
Serial Experiments Lain
At the end of Serial Experiments Lain, Lain erased herself to fix the mess she made, but she never really left. She stuck around like a ghost nobody remembered, watching from the edges of existence, everywhere and nowhere at the same time. Was she a god? A digital phantom? Just a fading memory? The show never gave a straight answer and left us to make sense of it on our own.
This controversial anime ending explored identity, technology, and existence in a way that felt both brilliant and unsettling. The storytelling was hazy, the lines between dreams and reality blurred, and every answer led to more questions. By the end, we sat there in silence while we tried to wrap our heads around what we had just watched. Whether it expanded our minds or completely fried them, Serial Experiments Lain made sure we’d never look at the digital world the same way again.
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Few anime endings have caused more controversy than Neon Genesis Evangelion. The anime’s last two episodes threw out the main story and dropped us inside Shinji’s mind. Instead of a big final battle, the show turned into abstract images, strange monologues, and deep questions about existence. Then came the “Congratulations!” scene, where everyone clapped as if Shinji had just won a prize. To many, this felt more like a puzzle than an ending, even though it’s actually better than many fans think.
The movie The End of Evangelion tried to give answers but only made things wilder. Battles turned brutal, the imagery became nightmare fuel, and humanity melted into orange goo. SEELE attacked NERV, Asuka fought for her life, and Shinji made a choice that changed everything. He rejected Instrumentality but left the world in ruins, making the ending even harder to process. Whether it made sense or not, Evangelion left an impact that never faded.
Steins;Gate
Steins;Gate gave us an ending that still sticks with us today. After endless time loops, heartbreak, and impossible odds, Okabe finally saved both Mayuri and Kurisu. It felt like the perfect victory, but time travel never comes without questions. Did changing the past erase everything he suffered through? Did the story wrap things up too easily for something built on pain and sacrifice?
Then came Steins;Gate 0, showing a world where Okabe failed. He was broken, stuck in a reality without Kurisu, and forced to keep going. Seeing that version of his story made everything more complicated. The contrast between both timelines changed how the ending felt, making it harder to say what was truly right. Whether it felt like closure or just another twist, Steins;Gate made sure its story would never be forgotten.
[RELATED – 10 Best ‘80s Anime for Fans Craving Timeless Classics]
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Puella Magi Madoka Magica led us through heartbreak and ended on a note that was just as painful. Madoka rewrote reality, erasing witches and saving magical girls from their cruel fate. But she paid the ultimate price — she erased herself too. Her friends barely remembered her, and Homura, who had fought endlessly to protect her, was left alone, holding onto a bond that no longer existed.
Madoka’s sacrifice gave meaning to all the suffering, but it also left a deep emptiness. Her choice brought hope, yet it also felt like an endless cycle of loss. Then, Rebellion came along and turned her salvation into something even more tragic, rewriting everything once again. Whether the ending was interpreted as victory or another cruel twist, it left a question that still lingers — can true hope ever exist in a world built on suffering?
Attack on Titan
Attack on Titan delivered an incredible story for years with many twists and turns, but its finale was ultimately less than satisfying. We see Eren go from a freedom fighter to a genocidal villain. While this plot line could have drawn attention to how trauma changes a person or how hatred can eventually make one the very thing they despise, that’s not what happened.
In the end, Isayama tried to portray Eren’s mass genocide as part of a grand plan for world peace. This fell completely flat as not only was it inconsistent with Eren’s character, it also made no sense. Worse was the story’s epilogue. Conflict returned, Paradis fell, and everything we watched the characters fight for led to nothing. While this could have been a powerful statement about the never ending cycle of conflict, its frustrating execution was so controversial fans had to take it upon themselves to make what they believed to be a better ending.
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
A cult classic anime, The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya’s ending is frequently considered controversial due to its Endless Eight arc. Consisting of eight episodes with the same general plot line, the arc is a wonderful depiction of a time loop. But its repetitive nature makes it incredibly tedious to watch to the point that it feels like nothing more than a glorified filler arc.
It doesn’t help that the second season of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya came after a long wait of three years. At that point, its repetitive nature felt even more like an elaborate joke at fans’ expense. And the end result was a dark stain on the anime’s otherwise superb legacy.
Fate/Zero
Viewers knew Fate/Zero was a tragedy, but nothing could prepare us for just how brutal the ending would be. Kiritsugu gave up everything for his dream of a better world, only to learn the Holy Grail was nothing more than a cursed relic that twisted wishes into nightmares. In the end, he destroyed it, saving only one child: Shirou. After all that struggle, the cruelest twist was how little his sacrifice seemed to change.
Saber’s fate felt just as bitter. She fought harder than anyone, yet she was forced to destroy the very thing she had sworn to claim. Gilgamesh survived and strolled into the modern world like he owned the place, while Kirei, who found joy in suffering, walked away victorious. This controversial ending wasn’t just a tragedy for the characters — it was a reminder that sometimes, the world doesn’t care how hard you fight for justice.
School Days
Infamous for its controversial ending, School Days starts off like any other high school romance. But by the end, it’s full-blown psychological horror. Makoto’s endless cheating finally catches up to him in the worst way possible. Sekai, furious and heartbroken, snaps and stabs him. But the nightmare doesn’t stop there. Kotonoha, still obsessed with Makoto, finds his body, decapitates him, and sails away, cradling his head like a twisted love token.
The sheer brutality of this controversial ending shocked everyone. Some saw it as karma; others thought it was way too much, turning a messy love triangle into something straight out of a slasher film. The shockwave even reached real life when the anime’s final episode was delayed due to the Sasebo slashing, leading to the infamous Nice Boat meme. Love it or hate it, School Days burned itself into anime history in the bloodiest way possible.
