Regeneration is the secret to Doctor Who‘s success, the reason it’s become the longest-running sci-fi TV series in history. Few shows can survive changing their lead actor, but Doctor Who has done so 15 times (and counting). When the Doctor regenerates, it’s an opportunity for Doctor Who to reinvent itself in a fundamental way. Modern Who has often changed showrunner at the same time, meaning you get a completely different tone and style after the regeneration.
Videos by ComicBook.com
Every Doctor Who regeneration story is a historic moment for the show. It doesn’t matter whether you’re watching William Hartnell’s swan song or Peter Capaldi’s, these are the stories that are truly unmissable. The best regeneration story acts as a code for the Doctor’s latest incarnation, summing up everything they’ve ever stood for. David Tennant’s featured a victory lap in which he revisited his friends and allies. But even that emotional farewell was just the faintest echo of the best regeneration story of all time.
The Caves of Androzani Was the Best Doctor Who Regeneration Story Ever
In general, the best Doctor Who regeneration stories serve to perfectly represent the Doctor in question. Directed by Graeme Harper, “The Caves of Androzani” was different. The Davison era tended to be whimsical and wonderfully creative – one story featured a boat race in space – but this was harsh, dystopian science-fiction with a relentless intensity. The stakes were shockingly personal, because the Doctor and his companion were fighting for their lives, seeking an antidote for poisoning. Around them, the main story riffed on The Phantom of the Opera of all things, against the backdrop of gunrunning and an interplanetary civil war.
On paper, it sounds too ridiculous to work. But Robert Holmes’ script is a thing of beauty, drawing together all the disparate elements with remarkable ease. The story strips the Doctor down to his core, his desperate desire to protect others, his sense of responsibility for the companion he’s unwittingly brought into danger with him. Cliffhangers were tense and emotional, including one of the best in Doctor Who history, where it is the Doctor rather than the villain who crashes a ship with the cry “Nothing you can do can stop me now!”
Peter Davison and new Doctor Who companion Nicola Bryant put in some of their best performances. Davison has spoken about the experience many times, describing “The Caves of Androzani” as unique because of Harper’s relentless energy behind the scenes, which translated into masterful intensity on-screen. He felt the more cinematic approach was a potential turning point for Doctor Who, demonstrating what’s truly possible even on a show that has traditionally had a small budget. But, of course, he was always particularly invested in the regeneration.
Peter Davison’s Regeneration Scene is Unforgettable
Regeneration has always tended to be a bittersweet experience for viewers; a chance to say farewell to a Doctor they’ve come to love, married with the uncertainty and excitement of wondering what’s going to come next. “The Caves of Androzani” gives the most traumatic and dramatic regeneration in Doctor Who history, though, because the Doctor himself isn’t at all sure regeneration is going to happen at all. He isn’t changing because his old body is wearing thin, or because of blunt force impact; no, he’s regenerating because there’s a poison in his system, and he doesn’t know if regeneration can beat it.
This turns “The Caves of Androzani” into an intense exploration of the Doctor’s character. Time Lords can so easily feel invincible, because they can “live forever, barring accidents.” But “The Caves of Androzani” strips the Doctor of his immortality, and in so doing exposes the very core of his being when he chooses to give the only precious drops of antidote to his companion, Peri, rather than save himself. The Doctor has always been heroic, but never like this; choosing a painful death, a potential end to his very existence, to save a single human being he cares for and feels responsible for.
It’s all married with a wonderful hallucinatory experience that brings back so many of the companions and enemies this Doctor has faced. More than any regeneration scene before it “The Caves of Androzani” really feels like the end of an era – a story acknowledging everything that has gone before, while setting up Doctor Who‘s future. Not every regeneration story can be “The Caves of Androzani,” of course, simply because the basic premise is too unique. But this one definitely shows what is truly possible, and has never been matched. It likely never will be.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Most Viewed
-
Image courtesy of Wizards of the Coast -
Courtesy of Bones Film
