Marvel Rewrites an Important X-Men Scene

Marvel Comics has rewritten what may be one of the most critical moments in X-Men history. Spoilers follow for Inferno #1 by Jonathan Hickman, Valerio Schti, David Curiel, Joe Sabino, and Tom Mueller. The moment in question isn't the single most important from X-Men history. That honor still belongs to Moira MacTaggert sharing her memories of her past lives with Charles Xavier. That act set into motion events that would lead to Krakoa's founding. However, this moment may be the one that sets fire to everything Moira, Charles, and Magneto have built. That seems especially true considering which mutant made a recent and unexpected appearance on the island.

This moment, first revealed in House of X #2, comes from Moira's third life. In that life, she worked as a scientist to develop a cure for mutants. Mystique, Destiny, and the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants were not fans of her work for obvious reasons. They attacked Moira's Muir Island facility and destroyed her research. Destiny discovered Moira's powers and informed Moira X that she was not truly immortal. Should she die as a child, before her mutant powers manifest, then she would be dead forever. Destiny foresaw 10 lives for Moira, maybe 11 if Moira chooses wisely. Destiny warned Moira that if she should do anything less than champion mutants in her future lives, then Destiny would find and kill her again. Destiny then had Pyro burn Moira alive, a memory Moira carried into her subsequent lives.

(Photo: Inferno #1, published by Marvel Comics)

This death has, presumably, been why Moira has barred the Quiet Council of Krakoa from resurrecting Destiny or any other precognitive mutants. But Inferno #1 presents that scene again with some altered dialog and an extra page.

The new page has Destiny implying that Moira may champion mutants for a time but ultimately lose faith and fall back into her old ways out of self-preservation. A change in dialog towards the end also implies the same. In the original version, Moira says she doesn't want to die "like this" when Destiny begins to threaten her life, leading to Pyro setting her on fire. In Inferno, Moira says she doesn't want to die, leaving off the "like this," implying she's more concerned about her continued existence rather than her third life in particular.

Is this the authentic version of Moira's third life events, previously hidden from Charles Xavier? That seems likely. It's also interesting that Moira returned to Muir Island to retrieve notes on her mutant cure, perhaps signaling that her commitment to Krakoa is wavering.

What do you think? Let us know in the comments. Inferno #1 is on sale now.