The modern streaming environment is an endless content machine, with platforms like Netflix releasing a constant torrent of new series and films to keep subscribers engaged. In this crowded market, survival is a brutal numbers game. Many new shows never make it past their first season, failing to find a large enough audience to justify their existence. The criteria for renewal are often unforgiving, and even securing a coveted spot in Netflix’s own Top 10 is not a shield against cancellation. That’s because a series that performs well in its initial weeks can still get the axe if its completion rate is low, if it fails to generate the cultural buzz needed to become a valuable IP, or if its viewership simply does not justify a high production budget. One recent drama just became the latest casualty of this ruthless calculus.
Videos by ComicBook.com
Deadline reveals that Netflix has canceled its crime series The Waterfront after a single season. The news comes as a surprise, as the show was a dominant performer for Netflix, spending five weeks in the global Top 10 for English-language shows and occupying the number one position for three of those weeks. From creator Kevin Williamson, the series followed the powerful Buckley family, led by patriarch Harlan Buckley (Holt McCallany), whose North Carolina fishing empire is on the verge of collapse. The family’s desperate attempts to maintain their legacy pull them into a dark criminal underworld, kicking off the grim events of the series. The series also starred Maria Bello, Melissa Benoist, and Jake Weary and earned moderate critical praise for its tense atmosphere and compelling performances.
While Netflix distributed The Waterfront as one of its originals, the show was actually produced by Universal Television. This key detail provides a potential lifeline for the series. Given its proven viewership and positive critical reception, Universal has the option to shop a second season to other networks or streaming platforms. As of now, however, no official discussions or plans to move the show elsewhere have been announced, leaving the fate of the Buckley family’s story in limbo.
The Waterfront Is Not the First Top 10 Series Netflix Cancels This Year
The Waterfront is just the latest example of a series with strong viewership getting abruptly cut. Earlier this year, Netflix made similar decisions regarding two other shows that broke into its Top 10 rankings, the medical drama Pulse and the Shondaland mystery The Residence. Both were canceled after a single season, and their respective fates show how different factors can lead to the same outcome. Pulse was a high-stakes procedural that premiered in April 2025, focusing on the staff of a Miami trauma center. The story centered on Dr. “Danny” Simms (Willa Fitzgerald) navigating professional and personal chaos. The Residence, a comedic mystery from producer Shonda Rhimes, debuted in March 2025. The series featured an eccentric detective, Cordelia Cupp (Uzo Aduba), trying to solve a murder inside the White House during a lockdown with 157 suspects.
Pulse met its end primarily due to poor critical reception. The medical drama earned a “rotten” 48% on Rotten Tomatoes, with reviewers criticizing it for a formulaic story that failed to stand out in a well-worn genre. The failure to connect with critics ultimately sealed its fate. The case of The Residence was more complex. The show was a critical success, boasting an 82% approval rating. Its downfall stemmed from its costly and complicated production. The series had a massive budget, confirmed by a major tax credit, and faced a significant shutdown during the 2023 Hollywood labor disputes. Furthermore, the tragic death of actor Andre Braugher mid-production forced the recasting of a major role. These elements combined to make the first season an expensive venture, and its viewership numbers were evidently not strong enough to warrant a second season’s price tag.
Were you watching The Waterfront? Let us know what you think of the cancellation in the comments!
Most Viewed
-
South Park Studios
