TV Shows

5 Mysteries Wednesday Season 2, Part 2 Must Solve

The wait is finally over, as Wednesday has returned to Netflix for its highly anticipated second season, bringing the main cast back for another grim and glorious adventure at Nevermore Academy. Following the first season’s massive success, the series has upped the ante with more mystery, more monsters, and more of the signature deadpan wit that made Wednesday Addams (Jenna Ortega) a global icon. This time, Netflix has split the story into two parts, with the first four episodes of Wednesday Season 2 dropping on August 6, 2025, and the final four scheduled to arrive on September 3, 2025.

Videos by ComicBook.com

The first half of Season 2 masterfully introduces a host of new threats and deepens the existing lore, from a mysterious new killer stalking Nevermore to shocking revelations about old enemies. With the mid-season finale leaving multiple characters in peril and several conspiracies unearthed, the stage is set for an explosive conclusion. Before the final episodes arrive, it is time to break down every major mystery that Part 2 of Wednesday Season 2 must solve.

1) Why Is Wednesday Having Trouble Controlling Her Psychic Abilities?

Image courtesy of Netflix

In the first season, Wednesday Addams discovered her burgeoning psychic abilities, which manifested as unpredictable and often painful visions triggered by touch. Her journey led her to embrace this part of her heritage, guided by the spirit of her ancestor, Goody Addams (Ortega), and she ended the season in possession of Goody’s crucial book of shadows. The Season 2 cold open showed just how far she had progressed, revealing that she had used the book to hone her powers to the point where she could successfully track and identify an elusive serial killer, the Kansas City Scalper (Haley Joel Osment). However, this newfound control proves to be temporary, as upon her return to Nevermore Academy, her psychic prowess begins to falter.

Wednesday’s psychic block becomes a major obstacle in her investigation into the new Avian killer. When she needs her visions most, they either fail to materialize or the effort causes her to cry black tears, a physical symptom Morticia (Catherine Zeta-Jones) identifies as a sign of dangerous psychic strain. This development deeply worries her mother, who reveals that her sister, Ophelia, suffered a complete mental breakdown after pushing her own psychic gifts too far. Fearing Wednesday is on the same destructive path, Morticia tries to protect her from a similar fate. Part 2 of the season must now explain the precise reason behind this debilitating power failure and reveal how Wednesday can regain full control without risking her own sanity.

2) Was Marilyn Thornhill Really the Hyde’s Master?

Image courtesy of Netflix

Season 1 of Wednesday revealed Nevermore’s botany teacher, Marilyn Thornhill (Christina Ricci), was Laurel Gates, the vengeful descendant of Jericho’s founder Joseph Crackstone (William Houston). She manipulated every event from the shadows, using her knowledge of chemical compounds and psychological warfare to awaken and control the Hyde within the seemingly good-natured barista, Tyler Galpin (Hunter Doohan). After her plan was foiled by Wednesday and her allies, Season 1 of Wednesday doesn’t explain her fate. 

Season 2 of Wednesday reveals Thornhill was arrested for her crimes and has been denying she was the Hyde’s master. Nevertheless, in Part 1 of the new season, she is transferred to Willow Hill Psychiatric Hospital by the facility’s chief psychiatrist, Dr. Fairburn (Thandiwe Newton), with the hope that her presence might provoke a breakthrough in Tyler’s failed treatment. 

During the mid-season finale, amidst the chaos created by Wednesday and Uncle Fester (Fred Armisen), Thornhill seizes an opportunity to free Tyler from his high-security cell, clearly expecting her former pawn to join her in a renewed mission to kill Wednesday. However, in a stunning betrayal, Tyler transforms into the Hyde and brutally murders her instead. This act would seem like the monster finally turning on its oppressor, except for a critical clue Thornhill provided earlier: a Hyde who kills its own master is meant to seal its own grim fate. Yet, after killing Thornhill, nothing happens to Tyler. This strongly suggests she was telling the truth all along, reframing her entire role. If Thornhill wasn’t the one in control of Tyler, then Part 2 must urgently answer who is, and what Thornhill’s true purpose was within this larger conspiracy.

3) What Is Judi’s Endgame?

Image courtesy of Netflix

The final episode of Wednesday Season 2, Part 1, reveals that the Avian murderer Wednesday has been chasing is Willow Hill’s administrator, Judi (Heather Matarazzo). Her motivations are tied to her father, Augustus Stonehurst, a former Normie science teacher from Nevermore Academy who was committed to Willow Hill after he had a mental breakdown. The episode explains that Augustus led the secret Long-Term Outcast Integration Study (LOIS), a laboratory in the basement of Willow Hill where Outcasts were kept as prisoners and experimented on. The goal of this research was to find a way to replicate Outcast powers and give them to Normies.

The LOIS experiments were a success in one regard, as they transformed Judi into an Avian. However, when Augustus attempted to give himself telekinetic powers, his mind broke down. Judi kept her father’s research alive after he lost autonomy, even killing former Sheriff Donovan Galpin (Jamie McShane) when he began to investigate the deaths of Outcasts at Willow Hill, which threatened to expose her operation. After a final confrontation with Wednesday (Jenna Ortega), Judi escapes from Willow Hill, her whereabouts unknown. Part 2 of the season must now explain what Judi’s endgame is, what she was trying to achieve with her father’s research, and where she is now.

4) Is the LOIS Patient Wednesday Freed Ophelia?

Image courtesy of Netflix

Part 1 of Wednesday Season 2 explains that Morticiaโ€™s sister, Ophelia, was committed to Willow Hill by Grandmama Addams (Joanna Lumley) after Ophelia’s psychic powers overloaded, against Morticiaโ€™s wishes. At some point after her committal, Uncle Fester broke into the hospital with the intention of releasing Ophelia, but he was told she had already escaped. By the time the events of Season 2 unfold, Ophelia has been missing for two decades.

During the final confrontation with Judi at Willow Hill, Fester and Wednesday release all the Outcasts being held prisoner in the secret LOIS labs. Among the people they free is a woman with a pale complexion and long dark hair, bearing features similar to those of the Addams family. These circumstances create the strong possibility that Ophelia never actually escaped and was instead transferred to the LOIS labs to be experimented upon this entire time. If the woman Wednesday freed is in fact Ophelia, her return could help Wednesday uncover the truth about her family and her own psychic abilities.

5) Who Is Slurp? And How Is He Connected to Augustus Stonehurst?

Image courtesy of Netflix

On the first evening of the new school year at Nevermore, Ajax (Georgie Farmer) tells a story about a prodigy Nevermore student. According to the legend, the boy was always trying to build new machines and experiments, an activity that blew up in his face one fateful night. The story also states that he replaced his own heart with a metal one and was buried in an unmarked grave at the foot of the Skull Tree, where students can still hear the ticking of his metal heart. To prove his own courage, Pugsley Addams (Isaac Ordonez) visits the Skull Tree alone, and his latent electric powers inadvertently restart the heart of the body buried there. This act resurrects a zombie, whom Pugsley names Slurp (Owen Painter).

Throughout Part 1 of Season 2, Slurp devours the brains of his victims, a process which allows him to slowly regenerate his putrefying flesh and restore his cognitive capabilities. After his crimes are uncovered, Slurp is sent to Willow Hill. When Fester and Wednesday overcharge the facility’s electric network during their escape from Judi, they also facilitate Slurp’s escape. In the final moments of the mid-season finale, Slurp is seen stalking Augustus Stonehurst. Using his recently recovered voice, Slurp calls Augustus an “old friend” before devouring his brain. Part 2 of Wednesday Season 2 must now explain who exactly Slurp was when he was alive and what his relationship was with Augustus Stonehurst.

What do you think will happen in Wednesday Season 2, Part 2? Share your theories in the comments!