4 Must-Play Fantasy TTRPGs That Aren’t Dungeons & Dragons

The world of tabletop RPGs is bigger, bolder, and more diverse than ever before. While Dungeons & Dragons still dominates mainstream attention, the tabletop renaissance of the past decade has spawned countless inventive systems, many of which offer deeper customization, more evocative settings, or streamlined rules better suited for modern players. Whether you’re someone who grew up the game or jumped in with 5E, now is the perfect moment to explore beyond the world’s most famous role-playing game. The landscape is vast, brimming with alternative fantasy TTRPGs built with passion, innovation, and a desire to carve new experiences at the table.

This resurgence isn’t just about branching away from D&D: it’s about finding systems that better fit your group’s playstyle. Do you want fast-paced storytelling? Gritty realism? Anime-scaled adventures? Narrative-first design? The indie boom has given players a treasure chest of options that cater to every flavor of fantasy. From bold, rules-light experiments to sprawling epics that rival D&D’s depth, these four TTRPGs are proof that fantasy tabletop role-playing is more alive and vibrant than ever.

4) Draw Steel

Draw Steel, a product by renowned Matt Colville, has emerged as one of the most surprising and fantastical TTRPG releases, a game that exceeded expectations not through marketing hype, but through exceptional design and word of mouth. While some recent high-profile systems launched with big promises backed by large companies, Draw Steel arrived with quiet confidence and delivered a remarkably polished, intentional ruleset that has quickly earned serious praise.

What makes Draw Steel stand out is how fully it delivers on its stated goals of tactical, heroic, cinematic fantasy. Every subsystem feels purposeful, from its fluid combat to its flavorful classes to its carefully tuned downtime mechanics. Even controversial elements, such as the never miss philosophy or layout, make perfect sense once players understand the game’s core ethos: heroes are meant to feel powerful, bold, and effective at all times. The design isn’t just competent; it’s cohesive.

The game’s strength lies in its details. Classes feel distinct without overwhelming complexity, tactical encounters run briskly without losing depth, and narrative tools such as projects and montages create meaningful story progression. Reviewers who expected something merely “solid” instead discovered one of the most thoughtfully crafted fantasy systems of the decade. For any tabletop fan, Draw Steel is absolutely worth watching and playing, especially as it continues to grow.

3) BREAK!!! RPG

Imagine an RPG that blends classic JRPG aesthetics, a pinch of Zelda, and the colorful energy of 90s fantasy anime. That’s BREAK!!! RPG, a vibrant, imaginative fantasy TTRPG tailor-made for groups who want big adventures without big rules overhead. It’s one of the most visually striking indie fantasy RPGs. You’ll find a game filled with expressive art, accessible systems, and imaginative world-building that never talks down to the player.

Designed to be fast to learn and fast to play, BREAK!!! uses a streamlined d20-based engine that feels familiar yet refreshingly modern. Instead of obsessing over complex modifiers or overly crunchy mechanics, the system encourages exploration, teamwork, and creativity. Characters aren’t built to min-max but rather to adventure. And with its generous character options, magic systems, ancestries, and professions, the game offers deep customization without the mechanical overload that sometimes bogs down traditional fantasy RPGs.

The setting is a highlight: sprawling, colorful, and bursting with personality. It embraces both whimsical and dramatic tones, making it perfect for groups who want campaigns that can swing from goofy goblin antics to high-stakes battles against cosmic threats. For fans of Studio Ghibli, Final Fantasy, Slayers, Chrono Trigger, or SNES-era RPGs, BREAK!!! is a must-play system that captures the magic of classic fantasy gaming with a contemporary twist inspired by iconic JRPGs and anime.

2) Pathfinder

If you love the tactical depth of Dungeons & Dragons but want more customization, more crunch, and more ways to shape your character, Pathfinder is the definitive alternative. Widely considered the “crunchy king” of fantasy TTRPGs, Pathfinder offers near limitless build freedom, allowing players to craft hyper-specific character concepts with precision and mechanical nuance. Considering Pathfinder was derived from Dungeons & Dragons 3E, it is no surprise that it bears many similarities. For players who want an alternative to D&D that still offers epic fantasy, deep lore, and years’ worth of published adventures, Pathfinder remains the gold standard.

The transition from Pathfinder 1E to Pathfinder 2E streamlined the system dramatically, making it one of the most elegantly designed rules-heavy RPGs on the market. The game’s famous three-action economy makes combat more dynamic and strategic, offering far more tactical freedom than most fantasy RPGs. Every class, from Champion to Witch to Inventor, feels thoughtfully designed and offers dozens of unique feats and pathways for growth.

Narratively, Pathfinder’s official setting, Golarion, is a jewel of modern fantasy world-building. It’s an enormous, diverse sandbox filled with living gods, haunted kingdoms, ancient doomsday weapons, demonic wars, and richly detailed regions. The adventures and published campaigns are some of the strongest in the industry. Abomination Vaults, Kingmaker, Strength of Thousands, and especially Wrath of the Righteous are widely considered masterpieces and make excellent video games.

1) Daggerheart

After years of anticipation, Daggerheart is shaping up to be one of the most significant newcomers to the fantasy TTRPG scene. Developed by Darrington Press, Critical Role’s publishing arm, Daggerheart aims to become a modern, narrative-first alternative to Dungeons & Dragons that still supports sweeping, long-form campaigns. But perhaps most importantly, Daggerheart understands modern TTRPG audiences extremely well.

One of Daggerheart’s central innovations is its Hope and Fear die system, which injects thematic tension directly into gameplay. Instead of simply rolling for success or failure, every check reveals an emotional tone. Successes and failures are marked with varying degrees based on whether players roll with Hope or Fear as the leading die, giving different shades of outcomes that push scenes in new directions. It’s a design built for storytelling, making every action feel meaningful.

Character creation leans heavily into roleplay: your background, community ties, identity, past traumas, and personal goals all shape how you interact with the world. Players can help the GM shape the world, placing locations and creating plot points in any of its interesting campaign frames. Classes feel flexible and expressive rather than locked into rigid archetypes.

Ultimately, Daggerheart’s designed to streamline rules without oversimplifying them, encourage character-driven narrative, support long campaign arcs, be easy for new players to pick up, and reward creativity and emotional storytelling. With the immense popularity of Critical Role behind it, Daggerheart is poised to become the next major fantasy TTRPG, one that could genuinely challenge D&D’s dominance in the years to come.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!