When we talk about thrillers, the audience is huge. And when we narrow it down to psychological thrillers, there’s still plenty of interest, but in any discussion about the genre, the same handful of films always show up. They’re great, of course, but it’s easy to forget that there are also underrated titles or movies that people barely remember exist. There are countless reasons why they don’t get mentioned as often as they should, but most of the time, they’re right up there with the big names — and sometimes even better. All of them deliver exactly what makes a good thriller work: tension, unsettling doubts, and especially that strange feeling that something’s off and you need to figure out what.
Videos by ComicBook.com
With that in mind, here are 5 excellent psychological thrillers every fan of the genre should go out of their way to watch. Every one of these picks delivers an intense experience, with stories that mess with your head.
5) Nope
When it comes to Jordan Peele, you’ve probably heard of Nope, but only around the time it came out, and then it basically vanished from the conversation. On the surface, this sci-fi thriller looks like just another UFO story, but it’s actually a social nightmare wrapped in a modern Western aesthetic. The plot follows siblings OJ (Daniel Kaluuya) and Emerald Haywood (Keke Palmer), who run a horse ranch. After a series of bizarre events, they become convinced that a UFO (or something even worse) is hovering over their land. Their mission? Capture the ultimate shot — the one that could make them money and save the family legacy. The real point, though, is the film’s commentary on our pathological need to turn trauma into internet content.
Nope is brilliant at what it sets out to explore (it probably should’ve even gotten some Oscar recognition), and its core metaphor is surprisingly sharp: the monster feeds on anyone who looks at it. That alone turns every scene into a test of self-control, where human greed and curiosity become the real catalysts for horror. It’s a thriller that forces you to question why we’re so obsessed with seeing, recording, and transforming everything into entertainment. It’s another one of Peele’s masterstrokes — yet compared to unforgettable hits like Get Out and Us, this movie barely gets mentioned anymore.
4) The Invisible Man
A lot of people remember The Invisible Man as “that great Blumhouse horror movie,” but few actually talk about how it works far better as a psychological thriller. The story follows Cecilia Kass (Elisabeth Moss), a woman trying to rebuild her life after escaping an abusive relationship, until she starts noticing signs that her ex (officially declared dead) might still be around. But the film treats this premise less as something supernatural and more as something emotionally grounded, because everything is filtered through the uncertainty trauma leaves behind. In simple terms, this movie is a masterclass in psychological horror about invisible abuse.
But if there’s one thing that really explains why The Invisible Man needs to be talked about more, it’s the way the film puts the audience in the exact same mental space as the protagonist. You desperately want to believe her, yet you also understand why everyone around her doubts. Invisibility is nothing more than a metaphor for manipulation and gaslighting, and the thriller hits hard because it never underestimates the viewer. Every scene has you questioning whether what you’re seeing is paranoia or a real threat, and that uncertainty makes the whole experience far more impactful than any movie relying on classic tools like jump scares. It genuinely understands what psychological horror is supposed to be.
3) The Machinist
Anyone has seen Christian Bale’s extreme devotion to his roles, and the infamous headlines about his dramatic weight loss were everywhere back in the 2000s. But what people rarely talk about is the actual movie he did all of that for. The Machinist is a far more incisive psychological thriller than it looks, following Trevor (Bale), a factory worker who hasn’t slept in a year and starts suspecting everyone around him. What’s great is how the film throws you straight into the same mental exhaustion he’s trapped in. There’s no relief, no pause — just the sense that something’s wrong, even if you can’t pinpoint what. It’s a movie that plays with the experience of watching a film, and for that alone, it should still be remembered as one of the greats.
But even with that approach, it’s also careful not to turn mental deterioration into spectacle. The Machinist is uncomfortable because it’s real: paranoia builds, relationships crumble, and the story makes it clear that the protagonist is both a victim and a contributor to his own collapse. It’s dark, dry, direct, and completely free of glamour — the kind of thriller that gets under your skin without needing much. The script is brilliant at slowly driving the audience insane, and Bale’s performance is absolutely next-level.
2) Coherence
Coherence is the kind of movie you recommend, knowing the person will come back asking how they’d never heard of it. Sure, it’s known in certain circles, but in general, it barely gets talked about. The premise is almost just an excuse: a group of friends meeting for dinner when a passing comet triggers a series of strange events involving alternate versions of themselves. From there, the film becomes a battle between who you are and who you think you are — and, especially, who you want to be when someone “just like you” shows up, making better choices. Anyone who’s watched Netflix’s It’s What’s Inside will get the vibe.
What makes this movie hit so hard is how it throws you straight into the chaos without any kind of instruction manual. There’s zero spoon-fed exposition. Every character reacts to the phenomenon in ways that reveal far more about their insecurities than any scientific theory. And that’s exactly where Coherence shines as a psychological thriller: the threat isn’t the multiverse, but the possibility of confronting versions of yourself you’d rather never meet. It’s an indie, so it won’t land the same for everyone, but it’s absolutely worth watching just for the experience.
1) The Invitation
This is a movie almost no one has heard of, but it’s genuinely fantastic. The Invitation is exactly the kind of film that should be on every “best psychological thrillers” list. The setup sounds simple: Will (Logan Marshall-Green) accepts an invitation to a dinner party hosted by his ex-wife and quickly senses something is off. But the movie uses that already-awkward social situation to build tension in a way that’s far more effective than a lot of bigger, more famous productions — and that’s because it does what The Machinist does so well: it drags you straight into the protagonist’s paranoia.
You start noticing suspicious things happening, but you also understand why he might be interpreting everything through trauma, and that uncertainty is the beating heart of the film. So when the ending hits, it’s not just shocking; it’s the confirmation that all that slow-building tension had a very specific purpose. The Invitation moves at a deliberate pace, but it’s incredibly effective if you surrender to the experience. Very few films build suspense this perfectly, and that’s exactly why the slow burn is necessary. It’s a reminder that social gatherings can be terrifying too (sometimes even more than the supernatural).
What do you think of these movies? Have you seen any of them? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
