This Elizabeth Olsen Sci-Fi Thriller Is a Critical Hit (And Fans Totally Missed It)

It’s not every day you find a movie that brings together this much quality, sharp performances, and a plot packed with subtext and tension – and still somehow flies under the radar for most people. So many films shoot straight to the trending charts and get talked about for weeks from the moment they drop, which really makes you wonder why The Assessment didn’t get the same treatment. Picture psychological horror clashing with sci-fi as it follows a couple living in isolation, with a tone that feels claustrophobic and constantly watched. This is a smart, bold piece of work – something rare in today’s film landscape, where studios tend to play it safe instead of taking risks. This provocative Elizabeth Olsen movie offers no comfort – and that’s exactly why more people need to see it and talk about it.

The Assessment, set in a dystopian future where the government tightly controls who’s allowed to have kids, might sound like yet another take on themes that sci-fi has covered over and over. But this movie dodges the usual clichés. Mia (Olsen) is put through an extreme psychological test to prove she’s fit for motherhood, in a tightly monitored, tense space. She’s there with her partner Aaryan (Himesh Patel) and Virginia (Alicia Vikander), the government official in charge of the whole thing. It’s within this trio that The Assessment really kicks into gear: a fight between the need for freedom and the heavy-handed control of a system that thinks it has the right to make decisions about people’s bodies and lives.

However, what really makes this movie stand out is its stripped-down, intense style. Instead of going all-in on flashy effects and building big worlds like most blockbusters, The Assessment leans into psychology, mood, and emotional tension. The direction proves that holding back can actually create more suspense – where silence and subtle looks carry a weight that’s almost crushing. This approach is what makes the movie shine, but also what makes it a challenge: it asks the viewer to really pay attention and sit with that growing discomfort – not something everyone’s up for in today’s fast-paced media world.

It’s worth saying that Olsen’s performance is especially powerful. She nails the inner chaos of a woman being treated like a subject under a microscope, reduced to a checklist in a system that couldn’t care less about her individuality. Her performance is full of quiet intensity, with emotions hanging by a thread, and looks that speak louder than any dialogue. Vikander isn’t playing a typical villain, either. Her character is more layered – she’s the face of the system, someone who truly believes she’s doing something necessary “for the greater good.” That kind of gray area makes everything more unsettling – and more believable.

[RELATED: Was This Horror Movie Starring Elizabeth Olsen Really Shot Entirely in One Take?]

It’s no surprise that The Assessment holds an 82% critic score and a 93% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes – numbers that back up just how strong the film is, both technically and artistically. Movies like Midsommar and Get Out made waves by turning real-world dread into deeply psychological horror, and The Assessment walks that same path. There’s a disturbing, almost dreamlike quality in how it explores anxiety, control, and emotional collapse. That precise kind of off-kilter tension – that feeling that something is just wrong – makes it just as gripping as the best psychological thrillers out there, even if this one is more subdued, more distant, and more internal.

What’s really smart about The Assessment is how it hits a nerve with today’s issues. This isn’t just fiction – it uses sci-fi as a way to reflect on real debates about reproductive rights, surveillance, biopolitics, and how much power the state should have over personal lives. What’s unsettling is how the future it shows doesn’t seem that far off, with personal choices handed over to cold, faceless systems. And that’s exactly why this film matters. It doesn’t hand out easy answers or a neat resolution – it gives you something that feels honest, and forces you to think about where we’re going.

For anyone who likes to dig deeper, ask hard questions, and get pulled into a story that messes with your head a bit, this movie is one that sticks with you well after the credits roll. If sci-fi has a job, it’s to make us look at what’s ahead – not just in terms of technology, but with some real thought about what that future means. The Assessment does exactly that, and it deserves a lot more attention from fans of the genre.

The Assessment is available to stream on Prime Video.