This Is Tom Holland’s Best Performance (And I Can Prove It)

When The Crowded Room premiered in 2023, a lot of people turned up their noses. Critics trashed it, ratings were low, and for a while, it looked like the show would just be another ambitious misstep in the endless sea of streaming content. But despite what the numbers say, there’s something seriously powerful about this series – and that something has a first and last name: Tom Holland. I know it might sound bold, especially considering we’re talking about Spider-Man here, the blockbuster star and fan favorite. But I’m saying it with full confidence: The Crowded Room features the best performance of Holland’s career so far. And I can prove it.

First off, you’ve got to understand how complex the role is. In The Crowded Room, Holland plays Danny Sullivan, a seemingly regular young boy who gets caught up in a shooting in 1970s New York. What comes after is a heavy, dark psychological drama. It’s inspired by the real story of Billy Milligan – the first person in the U.S. to be acquitted of a serious crime because of dissociative identity disorder – and it asks a lot from its lead actor. Holland has to navigate through fractured mental states, blurred memories, and a reality that’s honestly just too painful to deal with.

We’re talking about a character with what most people know as Multiple Personality Disorder – not exactly a walk in the park. It’s the kind of role that could easily be wrecked by overacting or turning into a caricature, right? One of the absolute best at pulling this off is James McAvoy in Split, who gave a completely hypnotic and unforgettable performance. But while McAvoy goes big with his transformations and almost theatrical energy, Holland takes a totally different route – delivering something surprisingly subtle and, at the same time, gut-wrenching. He builds Danny with this quiet intensity: his body’s always on edge, his eyes are full of sadness, and every line feels like it’s taking all his strength just to stay grounded in reality.

And the truth is, when the script slips up – and yes, it does here and there – Holland still holds the scene together with nothing but a look. Everything in his performance comes from Danny’s vulnerability, fear, and most of all, his raw humanity. Honestly, it’s rare these days to find actors who can express so much just through their physicality. Of course, Holland’s got a solid background in dance. But that training didn’t just help him move well – it fine-tuned his ability to communicate really complex feelings with the smallest gestures. That’s exactly why his performance hits so hard. He pours all of his artistic experience into this role, giving it everything he’s got, down to every single look, movement, and pause.

[RELATED: 3 Tom Holland Movies That Prove He’s More Than Spider-Man]

If people were hoping to see a more grown-up Tom Holland on screen, The Crowded Room absolutely delivers. He completely sheds that heroic, charming image that made him famous, and dives into a role that demands deep introspection, moral gray areas, and a seriously intense emotional commitment. And he took it so seriously that it ended up affecting his real life. In interviews, he admitted the series “broke” him emotionally. He started therapy, quit drinking, and took a year off to recover. That says a lot about the emotional weight he carried during filming – and also how much he cared about doing this right.

I don’t think it’s something to brag about, but honestly, how many times has this shown us what an actor’s really made of? Heath Ledger, Anne Hathaway, Evan Peters, Adrien Brody, Joaquin Phoenix, among others – they all went through rough patches after going too deep into intense roles. It was tough, for sure, but those experiences also led to some of the most unforgettable performances in film and TV. It just shows how far Holland went with Danny, how much he gave, and how he proved he’s one of the best actors of his generation. He’s not just Peter Parker. “I would come home from work and I would see myself in the mirror and I would see him. So it did take a while to figure out how to put him to bed and wake Tom up and get on with my life and be myself,” he told Radio Times.

Of course, it’s worth saying that the series as a whole got mixed reactions. The harshest critics pointed out the slow pacing, some awkward dialogue, and a structure that takes a while to fully make sense. And yes, The Crowded Room isn’t an easy watch. It asks for patience and a bit of tolerance for its quieter, more introspective rhythm. But trust me, if you can get past that surface level, you’ll find an incredibly rich psychological study – and a lead performance that’s more than worth the time.

Holland isn’t just playing someone with dissociative identity disorder – he’s pulling us right into the head of someone who’s completely shattered, trying to figure himself out, protect himself, and, in the end, forgive himself. Danny, in moments of complete confusion, even looks in the mirror and doesn’t recognize what he sees. In that one quiet moment, without saying a single word, Holland shows us pure fear, heartbreak, and sadness with just his face. It’s the kind of scene that makes you forget you’re watching an actor – you just believe that pain.

His performance is gentle and thoughtful, never slipping into clichés. And honestly, The Crowded Room might be the most important work of his career so far because of how emotionally powerful it is and how much it shows his growth as an artist. While a lot of actors are sticking to the safety of franchises, Holland took a big risk. And he paid a price for it. But you can’t deny that he came out of it stronger, more versatile, and way more interesting. If you’ve been following his career since The Impossible, it’s actually kind of moving to see how far he’s come – and how much more he clearly has to offer.

So, what I’m saying is: if you skipped The Crowded Room because of the bad reviews, you might want to think again (especially since audience ratings tell a completely different story – 92% on Rotten Tomatoes). Somewhere in the middle of all the noise and mixed opinions, there’s a performance that’s bold, fearless, and totally immersive. A performance that doesn’t just raise the bar for Tom Holland – it shows what happens when an artist decides to really push themselves to the limit.

The Crowded Room is available to stream on Apple TV+.