Well-done plot twists in TV shows have a very unique effect: they don’t just surprise, they make the viewer rethink everything they’ve watched up to that point, after many episodes and seasons. Sometimes, the impact comes from a twist that’s actually pretty simple, but full of consequence. Other times, it changes the entire story, subverts expectations, and flips the game out of nowhere. It’s not just about shock value, because what really hits are those twists that affect the characters, their relationships, and even the meaning of the plot. Now, imagine that happening in horror? That’s where the genre shows its most creative and striking side (and even traumatizes).
Videos by ComicBook.com
This list brings together seven of the best horror twists that are truly mind-blowing and completely changed my experience of watching the show. Each one here represents a turning point that goes way beyond just being scary or creepy – they’re way too smart and totally stand out.
WARNING: Major spoilers ahead
1) Squid Game‘s True Mastermind
When Squid Game showed that Il-Nam (Oh Yeong-su), after faking his death (which was already shocking), wasn’t just another player, but the architect behind all that horror, my reaction was basically: “Did I really fall for that?” The character was written with so much vulnerability and charm that it was easy to feel empathy for him (maybe a little too easy). And that’s exactly why the twist works so well: it doesn’t just hit as a shock, but as a direct break of trust with the audience. It’s a well-executed trick, I have to say, and it retroactively gives new meaning to several scenes in the show.
But the coolest part is that more than just a basic “villain plot twist,” Il-Nam reshapes the moral debate of the show. It’s not just about inequality and desperation; it’s about how power corrupts even empathy. He created the games out of boredom and curiosity – and that’s what makes it so disturbing. It was the kind of twist that made me rethink everything I had bought into about the story up to that point. And considering it’s a horror show at its core, it’s a pretty phenomenal twist (even if it’s a bit frustrating too).
2) Widespread Infection in The Walking Dead
Few twists in horror shows change the rules of the game as much as this one: in The Walking Dead, everyone is already infected. When Dr. Jenner (Noah Emmerich) whispers that to Rick (Andrew Lincoln) at the end of the first season and the information only comes out later, the entire show flips upside down. It’s no longer about avoiding being bitten, but simply accepting that death, in any form, will turn you.
Sure, the show had plenty of truly scary moments and other great twists, but this was when I felt it truly embraced horror for the first time. There’s no cure and no exceptions for anyone. The fight to survive becomes a race against something that, in the end, is inevitable. And that completely changes the atmosphere of the universe. It’s one of the simplest twists in concept, but one that carries huge consequences. And that’s why it’s still one of the most memorable in the show.
3) The Real Monsignor Pruitt in Midnight Mass
This one was subtle, but more uncomfortable than everything the show had been building. In Midnight Mass, the series slowly starts planting the doubt: who exactly is this Father Paul (Hamish Linklater)? And when we find out that he’s actually Monsignor Pruitt, rejuvenated by vampire blood, everything clicks. It’s worth saying that this is one of those twists that isn’t just shocking because of the reveal itself, but because of what it confirms: you realize you were ignoring the obvious clues because you didn’t want to believe that was really it.
I like how this revelation changes the way you see the “miracles” happening on the island. Suddenly, they turn into a curse, faith becomes fanaticism, and what seemed divine is actually completely monstrous. Obviously, from the start, everything is so mysterious that you know something’s going to come out, but when it finally happens, it’s still mind-blowing. The impact hits hard.
4) The Real Bent-Neck Lady in The Haunting of Hill House
The Haunting of Hill House has a twist that totally caught me off guard and honestly stands out as one of the best-crafted in modern horror. Finding out that Nell (Victoria Pedretti) had always been the Bent-Neck Lady, a figure that had haunted her since childhood, left me frozen for a good few minutes. It’s uncomfortable, it’s tragic, and it absolutely makes you want to go back and rewatch everything with a different lens. That’s the magic of Mike Flanagan.
What hit the hardest was how the show didn’t use it as just another scare, but as a pretty much inevitable consequence of a trauma cycle. The monster was her all along, and that twist redefines the kind of horror the show is trying to deliver. It’s not really about haunted houses, but about how the past is always part of the present, and how pain can become your fate. When you stop and think about that, it ends up being way scarier than any ghost or supernatural creature.
5) Bob’s Possession in Twin Peaks
Twin Peaks was a phenomenon and became a cult classic, but to this day, it still has one of the most shocking plot twists of all time. Even knowing the show would never go for a conventional ending, I still wasn’t ready to see Dale Cooper (Kyle MacLachlan), who spent two seasons as the ultimate hero, give that disturbing smile in the mirror. The fact that it was his doppelgänger possessed by Bob (Frank Silva) is devastating, with no warning.
Here, the twist wasn’t even bold; it was deliberately cruel. It’s the kind of ending that forces you to deal with the collapse of your sense of justice. It’s uncomfortable to watch the protagonist be consumed by darkness, but it’s also exactly the kind of twist that turns a show into something unforgettable. Even now, I have to say that laugh still bothers me – but that’s exactly why it works and why David Lynch is a genius.
6) Dead the Whole Time in American Horror Story: Murder House
An anthology series with plenty of bizarre moments, American Horror Story has delivered its fair share of twists, but for me, nothing tops Violet’s (Taissa Farmiga) arc in Murder House. The fact that she was dead the whole time is still one of the most powerful moments in the entire show. It’s not just the shock factor, but how the reveal is built up. No one could’ve predicted it. When Tate (Evan Peters) shows her decomposing body, the horror isn’t just hers – it’s ours, too.
I really appreciate twists that shift the viewer’s perspective without feeling forced, and this one nails it. Violet’s death completely reframes all her interactions and turns her storyline into something far more tragic (and therefore unforgettable to fans). This twist is about someone who has already lost the fight and didn’t even realize it. Within AHS‘s world, it’s cruel and impactful in just the right way.
7) The Real Time Loop in Dark
If you made it to the end of Dark, you probably felt the same as I did: your mind spinning. One of the best-written shows out there, it simply delivers, after so many twists, an ending where you’re not even sure what to think anymore. Jonas (Louis Hofmann) and Martha (Lisa Vicari) aren’t just victims of the time loop: they are the loop itself, and that literally changes everything. There’s no villain, let alone a simple solution to unravel the whole mystery. The knot that binds the worlds is fueled by their choices.
This twist is not meant to shock, but to give emotional weight to what had already been hinted at. It’s smart. These two characters aren’t just pieces on a board; they are the whole board. They perpetuate the cycle while trying to save it, and that’s as desperate as it is brilliant. When the show reveals this, you realize a happy ending was never an option. Honestly, I really respect when a series has the guts to own that.
What are your favorite twists in horror TV? Let us know in the comments below!
Most Viewed
-
Image courtesy of HBO -
Courtesy of Marvel
