August 24, 2019, was a massive day for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The franchise was hot off the heels of the monster hit, Avengers: Endgame, and the future of the MCU was unclear. The D23 Expo opened things up with plenty of major trailers, reveals, and announcements. From Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings to Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness to The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, a lot of projects were lined up on this day to set the tone for the next few phases of the franchise, for better or for worse. While many of the films and TV shows announced at the D23 Expo in 2019 went on to be critical and commercial hits, one project ended up going down as the worst movie in the MCU at that point. It had a lot of excitement behind it, yet it ultimately missed the mark.
Videos by ComicBook.com
That film was Eternals, which technically was first mentioned at Comic-Con in 2019. D23 marked the official announcement of the full main cast, with Gemma Chan, Kit Harington, and Barry Keoghan confirmed. Unfortunately, Eternals turned into such a disappointment that the MCU has mostly ignored it since its release.
Eternals Was The MCU’s First Critical Misfire

When Eternals hit theaters in 2021, the Marvel Cinematic Universe was in the midst of a remarkable run. Every single film released to that point, which had been 25 in total, received positive reviews from critics. The lowest score for an MCU movie on Rotten Tomatoes was Thor: The Dark World, which sits at 67%. Though not certified fresh on the site, that’s still a positive rating. Eternals marked the first change in that trend, landing at 48%. The box office intake of around $400 million on a budget of over $230 million was also lackluster.
Most critics believed that Eternals was an ambitious endeavor that took the MCU to intriguing places, yet it was criticized for kind of getting crushed under its own weight. The movie tried to introduce the audience to a dozen characters in the span of two and a half hours; it’s difficult to make someone care deeply for so many new characters at once. Many of these characters, who were meant to be major new heroes for the franchise, barely got any screen time. For example, the speedster Makkari is the MCU’s first deaf hero, yet she barely gets showcased.
In a lot of ways, Eternals would’ve been better served as a Disney+ TV show. That would’ve given it 8-10 episodes to fully flesh out each of the characters. Each member of the Eternals could’ve had an episode dedicated to a deeper dive into them individually, allowing the audience to bond with and care for them. As a film, it was too much, in too little space, and the result was the MCU’s low point. To be fair though, Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania and Captain America: Brave New World have been just as poorly reviewed in the years since.
Eternals‘ Twist Should’ve Changed The MCU, But It Remains Ignored

Eternals features a pretty big twist that changes everything about the film and, potentially, the entire MCU. Arishem, the Celestial who sent the Eternals to Earth, only put them there to prepare the planet for the birth of a new Celestial. That brings the Eternals, other than Ikaris, who supports the decision, together to stop Earth from being destroyed for this purpose. Because of that, the film ends with Arishem appearing in the sky and taking Sersei, Phastos, and Kingo into space. Yet, the MCU hasn’t picked up on this thread even slightly in the years since.
The Celestials are incredibly powerful beings who set so many things up on Earth, yet when they were denied their big plan, nothing has come of it. Theoretically, they should’ve put those Eternals on trial and figured something out by now. Whether they choose to forgive the Eternals or decide to go forth with some sort of new plan, it shouldn’t take all these years. People even saw this giant Celestial in the sky, and yet nothing has been mentioned of it. The closest we got to mentioning Eternals again was a flimsy connection to Captain America: Brave New World.
The disappointing reception of Eternals makes it somewhat understandable that the MCU hasn’t brought them back. However, leaving this twist up in the air is unlike them. Even if the characters never returned, we should’ve gotten at least a quick line to explain what happened regarding the Celestials. The loose thread hanging over the franchise is inconsistent, and when you add in the cliffhanger of the other Eternals meeting Eros and Pip the Troll, it doesn’t make sense. Beings who are that powerful wouldn’t just forget this kind of thing, and the whole thing is a mark against the overall MCU.
You can stream all MCU content on Disney+.








