Movies

This Forgotten Superman Spinoff Movie Might Be DC’s Weirdest in History, But It’s Virtually Unwatchable

DC has seen some weird and arguably bad movies over its numerous attempts at a cinematic universe. Wonder Woman 1984 inexplicably complicated, rather than clarified, the heroโ€™s public image, given her numerous public acts of heroism despite her being a mystery in Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice. Supergirl, despite a great performance from Milly Alcock, failed to hit the mark, even outside of the unnecessary scenes with Jason Momoaโ€™s Lobo. The first Suicide Squad has been largely forgotten in favor of James Gunnโ€™s The Suicide Squad.ย 

Videos by ComicBook.com

Still, thereโ€™s a difference between movies that have their enjoyable moments โ€” like the campy feel of Joel Schumacherโ€™s Batman Forever and Batman & Robin โ€” and movies so weird that theyโ€™re virtually unwatchable. Despite a strong starting point in the comic lore for John Henry Irons โ€” who first appeared during the Reign of the Superman storyline โ€” 1997โ€™s Steel is a dumpster fire even moviegoers with the lowest of standards should avoid. 

A Baffling Deviation from Source Material

image from 1997's Steel

At its core, Steel is a movie lost in a battle over what it should be. The filmโ€™s writer/director, Kenneth Johnson, tossed out Steelโ€™s comic storyline, along with Ironsโ€™ niece, Natalie, in favor of creating his own characters for the film. Johnson felt the characters he created better emphasized Steel as a โ€œblue-collar Batmanโ€ and a โ€œsuper human beingโ€ as opposed to a superhero.ย One of the film’s producers, Quincy Jones, spoke about wanting the film to inspire kids to believe in the future again, but it’s hard to see how Steel was supposed to do that.

Steel, originally proposed as a spinoff film from a Death of Superman feature that was never made, simultaneously refuses to be a superhero film while refusing to let go of the cheesiest aspects of the genre. Itโ€™s okay for John Henry Irons, played by Shaquille Oโ€™Neal, to deliver the cheesy โ€œitโ€™s hammer timeโ€ line, but to keep the character grounded, the costume canโ€™t include the comic-accurate red cape.ย For a moving visual of just how cheesy the costume still looks, check out the movie’s trailer below!

The film also changes Steelโ€™s motivation from vigilantism motivated by wanting dangerous weapons out of the wrong hands to a vigilantism fueled by his partner Susan Sparksโ€™ tragic backstory. Sparks was caught in the crossfire when movie antagonist Nathaniel Burke (Judd Nelson) tested Irons’ weapon to its max capacity, and made Sparks a paraplegic. Sparks exists in the film as inspiration for Irons and to serve as a woman in the chair, but has no interiority or agency beyond these two functions for Irons. The ending of the film of course has Sparks showing off modifications to her wheelchair that allows her to walk again. 

While it may be dismissed as a product of its time, this change is frustrating because the comics did a similar storyline so much better for one of Steelโ€™s nephews. During Steelโ€™s spin-off series, his nephew Tyke gets paralyzed by a bullet meant for Jemahl, Tykeโ€™s brother. While Steel takes down the gang responsible, Tyke is still angered by his disability and exposes Ironsโ€™ secret identity to Hazard, a main villain of the comic. Tyke feels closer to a real character rather than a plot device, something that canโ€™t be said for Sparks. 

A Utter Failure

image from 1997 steel movie, steel saving young boy

Steel had a budget of 16 million, but only made $870,068 in its opening weekend. For the second weekend that the film was in theaters, purchased tickets dropped 78%, and the film only ended up making 1.7 million dollars for its entire theatrical run. 

Reviews for the film were brutal. Critics called Oโ€™Nealโ€™s performance dull, unconvincing, and silly, while calling the script โ€œshallowโ€. Itโ€™s a given that special effects usually donโ€™t age well, but even at the time, critics referred to them as โ€œpatheticโ€. Audiences also struggled to take Irons seriously given how the suit looked. Very quickly, DC and Warner Bros. gave up on trying to make a franchise for Steel. There wasnโ€™t even a follow-up comic for the film, unlike other quote-unquote superhero film failures of the time.ย 

The character has made animated appearances since Steel โ€” from Young Justice to My Adventures with Superman โ€” but has yet to reappear in a live-action film. His one live-action appearance in Superman and Lois was again an altered version of the character, this one from an alternate Earth that was terrorized by Kryptonians. Superman and Lois also changed Nat from his niece to his daughter.ย 

While the character certainly has a lot of potential, especially if they keep his tie to his niece, Nat, it’s uncertain whether heโ€™ll be adapted in the DCU.ย 

Even then, will it be a comic-accurate version of him or yet another one bogged down by baffling changes by the creative team? Comment down below on the future of Steel in live action!