Movies

5 Actors Almost Cast As The DCEU’s Batman Before Ben Affleck (1 Missed Out on Superman Too)

The character of Batman is one of the most iconic in all of pop culture, with Ben Affleck famously playing the role in the short-lived DCEU. Many actors have played Batman in live-action, with each new iteration of the Dark Knight bringing their own unique characteristics to the hero. Every actor’s Batman is a little different from the last, with their respective appearances and acting styles each contributing something new to the character’s overall cinematic mythos. Most fans have their own personal favorite, claiming a specific version of the character to be superior to all others. While the DCEU itself never gave him enough chance to shine, Ben Affleck’s Batman is often hailed as one of the more interesting iterations of the hero, with many feeling that he deserved far better treatment than he received.

Videos by ComicBook.com

Many consider it a tragedy that Ben Affleck’s solo Batman movie went unmade, but things might have been different if it had had a different prospective star altogether. In the early days of the DCEU, many actors were considered or auditioned for the role of Batman, and some of the names who were reportedly close make for interesting reading. The following actors were all competing with Ben Affleck to play Batman in the DCEU, and it’s fascinating to consider how their take on the character might have altered the franchise’s ultimate fate.

5) Richard Armitage

While Richard Armitage is relatively well-known in his native UK for several prominent TV roles, he’s likely far less familiar to US audiences. His biggest roles to date include playing Thorin Oakenshield in Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit trilogy, as well as appearances in Ocean’s 8, Alice Through the Looking Glass, and in the TV show Hannibal as Francis Dolarhyde. Many also believe him to be an actor James Gunn should consider for the DCU’s Batman, but it isn’t the first time his name has been connected to the role. In some alternate reality, Armitage would have become best known for playing Batman in the DCEU. Reportedly, Armitage not only auditioned for the role, but actually made the final shortlist along with Ben Affleck. Many fans suggest that Armitage might actually have been a better fit for the role, as his lesser-known status might have helped fans get on board with his iteration of Batman sooner than they did for Affleck. Sadly, we’ll never know what Armitage’s Batman would have looked like, but it’s easy to see why he was considered for the role.

4) Orlando Bloom

Orlando Bloom in Deep Cover

Another British actor who was almost cast as Batman is Orlando Bloom. Bloom is no stranger to the Hollywood spotlight, having played Legolas in The Lord of the Rings movies and also starred in the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise as blacksmith-turned-pirate Will Turner. While Bloom’s star has faded a little in the past decade or so, his impressive career has seen him feature in numerous high-profile roles, cementing him as a major and bankable box office draw. Bloom’s connection to the Batman role actually dates back further than the DCEU itself, as he was reportedly offered the lead in Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins. Had Bloom taken the part, it’s highly possible that later plans to incorporate Nolan’s trilogy into the DCEU — which Christian Bale crucially turned down — could have happened, meaning Orlando Bloom might have taken the place of not just one, but two separate movie incarnations of Batman.

3) Ryan Gosling

Ryan Gosling as Agent K in Blade Runner 2049

Ryan Gosling is, undoubtedly, one of the biggest stars in the world. His repeated Hollywood success over the length of his career has cemented him as one of the most lovable leading men of all time, with his ability to deliver comedic, dramatic, romantic, and action-heavy performances all proving his remarkable versatility. As if his current list of career successes wasn’t already long enough, he was also reportedly heavily considered for the role of Batman in the movies of the DCEU. Gosling was one of several actors being eyed to play Batman in Zack Snyder’s Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, and though he ultimately didn’t get the part, it’s interesting to consider what his Batman might have looked like. He almost certainly would have been considerably different from Ben Affleck’s version, and it’s actually easier to picture him playing the role in a similar vein to Michael Keaton’s quirky, offbeat iteration of the Dark Knight.

2) Joe Manganiello

Joe Manganiello as Deathstroke in Justice League

There were many actors considered for the role of Batman in the DCEU, but only one was also a very close contender to play the franchise’s live-action version of Superman, too. Joe Manganiello’s career so far has seen its share of success, but the actor has also had several unfortunate misses when it comes to casting decisions. As well as reportedly being neck-and-neck with Henry Cavill for the role of Superman, Manganiello was also a serious contender for the DCEU’s Batman. It’s not hard to see why, either: Manganiello cuts a pretty commanding figure physically speaking, and has proven himself more than capable of playing powerful, brooding characters. Ultimately, scheduling conflicts with his role on True Blood were a major consideration, and this led to him missing out on the part of not just one, but two founding members of the Justice League. He did briefly appear in a DCEU cameo as Deathstroke, but that role also proved to be infuriatingly short-lived.

1) Josh Brolin

Josh Brolin as Gurney in Dune 2

Although Josh Brolin has been in many comic book movies, he was almost in even more. He has played various Marvel and DC characters across the span of his impressive career, but he was also a serious contender for the role of Batman in Zack Snyder’s DCEU. Brolin was once considered the frontrunner to play the DCEU’s Batman, and many fans were immediately supportive of his rumored casting. It’s hard to imagine many actors more readily suited to the grittier tone of Snyder’s DCEU, as Brolin’s gruff charm and quiet charisma would have been a perfect fit. However, though Brolin has expressed that the prospect of playing Batman excited him, Snyder ultimately chose Affleck for the part. Of course, Affleck went on to do a commendable job in the role, even if it — and the franchise the character inhabited — did ultimately prove to be much shorter-lived than many fans would have hoped.