There really isn’t a name more prominent in the world of movie reviewing than Roger Ebert. The longtime critic is synonymous with film reviews, dating all the way back to his days working with George Siskel of the Chicago Tribune in the 1970s. The two turned critical reviews into something popular with their PBS show, Sneak Previews, and then At the Movies. After Siskel’s untimely passing, Ebert kept going alongside Richard Roeper, reviewing and writing until his own passing in 2013, and his website RogerEbert.com is still posting reviews today. Ebert didn’t always agree with the masses, yet always came from a place of honesty and defended his opinions well. When it comes to the sci-fi genre, just over two dozen movies landed a perfect score from him, which is four stars. Some are iconic films, while others famously bombed at the box office.
Videos by ComicBook.com
Due to Roger Ebert’s status as a top film critic, it’s interesting to learn his views on movies that were disappointing in the eyes of others. What did he see in a project that bombed, which was different from the masses?
5) Alien

Although it certainly leans heavily into the horror genre, Alien (1979) remains a sci-fi classic. Roger Ebert understood what made the film so special and gave it the perfect score that so many agree with. He praised the way the titular alien was depicted and how the film evolved the nature of its appearance so the audience never totally knows what it looks like until the perfect moment. He also said that Alien was one of the scariest old-fashioned space operas in history.
Ebert initially reviewed Alien alongside Siskel and agreed with him that the film was something of a disappointment compared to classics like Star Wars and 2001: A Space Odyssey. However, Ebert later revised his review and gave Alien the full four-star treatment. He also included it on his list of the greatest movies ever made. His updated review praised the pacing of the film and how it never rushes anything, allowing the viewer to get fully engrossed in the atmosphere.
4) Cloud Atlas

When it comes to surprisingly great reviews from Roger Ebert, Cloud Atlas (2012) ranks near the top. The sci-fi movie from the Wachowskis and Tom Tykwer was meant to be an epic, clocking in at nearly three hours and featuring a great cast led by Tom Hanks and Halle Berry. Unfortunately, Cloud Atlas received only mixed reviews from critics, sitting at a mere 65% on Rotten Tomatoes. It also bombed at the box office, bringing in just around $130 million on a budget of over $140 million. Despite that widespread opinion, Ebert loved the film.
Ebert listed Cloud Atlas as one of the best movies of 2012 and loved how ambitious it was. He said that after each viewing, he knew he needed to see it over and over again. “But, oh, what a film this is! And what a demonstration of the magical, dreamlike qualities of the cinema,” is a direct quote that shows his admiration for the project. Not many people shared his viewpoint, yet he made his stance quite clear.
3) Avatar

Although Avatar took the world by storm in 2009 by shattering box office records with over $2 billion in worldwide intake, and was liked by critics, it didn’t receive perfect scores from everyone. At 81% on Rotten Tomatoes, it was acclaimed but not considered a classic by many. Roger Ebert differed, as he gave Avatar four stars and compared the experience to the first time he saw Star Wars. He also called James Cameron’s blockbuster a technical breakthrough.
Roger Ebert had positive words for James Cameron for silencing the doubters and delivering an extraordinary movie. While he called the film sensational entertainment, Ebert also loved its anti-war message, calling it a deeper movie than most realized. He was happy that the lengthy runtime didn’t feel long, yet his greatest praise went to how the project ushers in a new generation of special effects. Ebert loved that the movie doesn’t use 3D effects for the sake of it and that it’s actually part of enhancing the experience.
2) Sky Captain And The World Of Tomorrow

Along the same lines as Cloud Atlas, it likely comes as a shock to learn that Roger Ebert gave four stars to Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow (2004). It’s not a film that’s considered one of the best sci-fi projects in history and, for the most part, nobody even remembers it. The movie had an interesting setup and a big cast led by Angelina Jolie, Gwyneth Paltrow, and Jude Law. However, Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow failed at the box office, only grossing around $58 million on a budget of $70 million.
Reviews were mostly middling, yet Roger Ebert was a huge fan. He likened it to his first viewing of Raiders of the Lost Ark, which is high praise. Ebert added, “It’s like a film that escaped from the imagination directly onto the screen, without having to pass through reality along the way.” He understood that the movie was mostly there to inspire silly grins and he appreciated the film leaning into it so much.
1) Inception

Some of the sci-fi movies that received perfect ratings from Roger Ebert are the ones that pull off impressive juggling acts, which is something he loved about Inception (2010). He said that the blockbuster Christopher Nolan movie “is all about process, about fighting our way through enveloping sheets of reality and dream, reality within dreams, dreams without reality. It’s a breathtaking juggling act.” When all was said and done, Ebert ranked Inception in his top ten for 2010.
You could tell that Ebert appreciated the layers of the screenplay, as he mentioned several times that Nolan had been writing the film for a decade. One of his biggest points was how the movie felt wholly original in an era filled with remakes, adaptations, and sequels. Ebert praised Christopher Nolan’s ability to evoke an emotional response while also featuring such a complex narrative, which helped Inception earn the perfect score in his eyes.





![Disney’s Hexed Team Reveal How Film’s Witch School Is Totally Different From Wicked, Harry Potter [EXCLUSIVE]](https://comicbook.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2026/11/hexed-movie.jpg?w=300)



Forum Conversation: LANTERNS – MANHUNTER THEORIES
Go to ForumI hope it’s not Zoe, that’s the most obvious choice. I was thinking the Sheriff, but the kid is absolutely diabolical and was a thought I never even considered until this article. But I did have a thought that maybe most of the town is artificial and the Manhunter created more synthetic bodies to be everywhere and or to replicate to achieve its final goals.
You should! The show is amazing!
The police officer from Gotham is the only one free of suspicion to me, as she’s a friend of John’s in 2026, which means she survived and they have a bond; she can’t just be replaced at the end. My money is her husband. Leading an alien-killing squad would be the best way to avoid attention while also making sure your enemies will die.
I’m more curious about who the benefactor is. Could it be the Guardians? Are they protecting the Manhunters because they feel responsible?
I haven’t started Lanterns yet, but it sounds like I need to catch up!