TV Shows

24 Years Ago, A Dark Nickelodeon Series Debuted One of Its Best Episodes, & It Featured a Future Fargo Star

If you were a ’90s kid, chances are you watched Nickelodeon. From animated shows like Rugrats to live-action sitcoms like The Adventures Of Pete & Pete, there was no shortage of entertainment for young viewers. But as much as these shows are remembered for their iconic characters and laugh-out-loud humor, they’re also remembered for the stars they produced. Be it Amanda Bynes in the self-titled The Amanda Show or Kenan Thompson and Kel Mitchell in the sketch comedy All That, a re-watch of old Nick shows can quickly turn into a game of “hey, I know them!”

Videos by ComicBook.com

One such series, Are You Afraid of the Dark? served as a stark contrast to lighter shows on the network, but it proved no less popular. Each episode of Are You Afraid of the Dark? told a different tale โ€“ campfire stories shared by members of the Midnight Society, a group of adolescents bonded over their shared love of the dark. While the cast would rotate between seasons and subsequent reboots, future Fargo star Rachel Blanchard appeared as a prominent member in the first two seasons, including season 2’s “The Tale of the Dark Dragon”, an episode regarded as much for its scares as its heart. Released 24 years ago, “The Tale of the Dragon” remains a prime example of what made Are You Afraid of the Dark? so special.

“The Tale of the Dark Dragon” is One of Are You Afraid of the Dark?’s Best Episodes

The title card for "The Tale of the Dark Dragon", appearing over campfire flames.
Nickelodeon Productions

“The Tale of the Dark Dragon” begins like all Are You Afraid of the Dark? episodes do: with the Midnight Society gathering for a meeting. It’s Gary’s birthday, and for his gift, David is telling a story about one of Gary’s favorite things: magic. And so ensues “The Tale of the Dark Dragon”, which follows Keith Saunders, a boy whose leg was injured in a car crash. Hoping to woo his crush, Shelly, Keith pays a visit to Sardo’s Magic Mansion, seeking a potion which promises to “bring out the best” in people. Now, Are You Afraid of the Dark? fans will know Sardo as one of the series’ few recurring characters. He’s a magician and shopkeeper whose wares always go horribly awry for the person buying them.

For Keith, the potion works at first. He becomes a more confident version of himself, successfully charming Shelley while acting as his “cousin” KC. However, Keith’s potion begins to transform him into something monstrous โ€“ like a teenage Jekyll and Hyde. This, he discovers, is all part of the spell: to become your best self, you must defeat the “dark dragon” within yourself. At the school dance, Keith finds out his friend Mariah has taken the remainder of his potion, hoping it would make Keith like her. When she begins to change too, Keith’s tears turn Mariah back, and the episode ends on a happy note, both of them having conquered the “dark dragon”: their insecurity. It’s this powerful message that makes the episode stand out.

“The Tale of the Dark Dragon” Has More Heart Than Scares

Keith in his monstrous form takes some of the potion.
Nickelodeon productions

On its own, “The Tale of the Dark Dragon” isn’t particularly scary, at least not compared to some of Are You Afraid of the Dark’s most well-known episodes, like “The Tale of Laughing in the Dark”, or “The Tale of the Dead Man’s Float.” Instead, what makes “The Tale of the Dark Dragon” so strong can be found in its message and characters. As a protagonist, Keith is easy to like. He doesn’t take the potion for evil reasons, but for something much more relatable to viewers. No doubt many kids (and even adults) can relate to being insecure or wanting to be someone else.

As for the potion itself, it plays out like an allegory for drug addiction. It makes Keith and Mariah feel better about themselves, but it also physically and mentally transforms them. By extension, the episode’s ending becomes both about beating addiction as well as self-acceptance. In general, Are You Afraid of the Dark? was great at things like this: hiding moral messages within its stories. In this regard, Are You Afraid of the Dark? was able to push boundaries beyond just scaring kids. It’s no wonder the show also attracted future talent.

Are You Afraid of the Dark? Was A Platform for Future Stars

The cast of Are You Afraid of the Dark?'s original Midnight Society: Kiki, Frank, Betty-Ann, Gary, David, and Kristen.
Nickelodeon productions

As a Canadian production, Are You Afraid of the Dark? starred both well-known Canadian actors and up-and-comers, such as Ryan Gosling and Neve Campbell. It’s within The Midnight Society itself, however, that there is another familiar face: Rachel Blanchard, who plays Kristen in the show, and would go on to star as Kitty Nygaard in Fargo, the acclaimed drama from FX. Though Blanchard would depart the show following season 2 โ€“ a result of the actress joining UK series Chris Cross โ€“ it was the bold personality she put into Kristen which made her character memorable.

Kristen would serve as the narrator for five episodes total, telling ghost stories, such as the well-remembered “The Tale of the Frozen Ghost.” Today, Blanchard’s career expands far beyond Fargo and her Nickelodeon beginnings, with a prominent role in Netflix’s The Summer I Turned Pretty. She remains one of the strongest examples of the future talent Are You Afraid of the Dark? would produce โ€“ and why the show is still remembered today.

What do you think of this episode? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

Forum Conversation: If Avengers: Doomsday & Secret Wars Disappoint, Are You Still Giving MCU Phase 7 A Chance???

Go to Forum
Valdezology Members
Valdezology Members
July 29

I’ll be there watching all of them of course but doesn’t mean I’m gonna keep liking it. Too far in to give up now

Tom Bacon Members
Tom Bacon Members
July 29

It’s sad the MCU has come to this. I think, for me, Endgame was the mistake; I remember writing at the time that the only way to properly handle an event like the snap was to undo it with time travel. Because the MCU really works when it’s set in “the world outside your window”, and an event like the snap breaks that. There is no sane and sensible way to imagine that this is “the world outside your window” anymore. That five-year time jump made things worse, because you had five years of progression that was unseen. How much of the Hulk’s story, for example, was actually on-screen in the first place? Honestly, I think Endgame broke the MCU. I enjoyed the film – but it was a full stop, not a comma. A conclusion, not a launchpad.

That, to me, is the big issue with Secret Wars. If Marvel get this wrong, it will feel like a full stop – and a bigger one than Endgame, because it will tie a bow over every Marvel story since 2000 (possibly beyond, if Wesley Snipes’ Blade is in it). The stakes are very, very high right now. And I don’t know if Marvel realize it, or frankly can pull this off the way it needs to be.

I’ll still watch. I still am a fan; but I’m undeniably less passionate and excited, and it’s a matter of individual projects getting me engaged rather than the universe itself. I’ve always loved the X-Men, so I’m guaranteed to see those. But beyond that… Marvel hasn’t sold me on much yet. Black Panther 3 has Ryan Coogler, but I dislike that we’ve had an entire Black Panther movie where Shuri becomes the new BP, and the very next film is about a new one. Actually, dislike is too weak a word; that actively annoys me. And if Marvel dare reduce Storm to “New T’Challa’s love interest,” when that’s only one arc for a character who’s been around since 1975, then I will be seriously angry. Coogler’s involves, so I have hope, but the MCU doesn’t do well at handling female characters.

ChrisA90 Members
ChrisA90 Members
July 28
On 9/10/2025 at 11:45 PM, Ben Kendrick said:

This is 100% how I feel these days. I see everything but find that Iโ€™m much much more connected to a great solo story than a cameo packed crossover.

Maybe this is just me being nostalgic for when I was younger, but this year I’ve been rewatching Raimi Spider-Man, Fox X-Men, etc. and there’s almost something refreshing about watching a superhero movie that isn’t part of some massive interconnected universe. I kinda miss movies like that.