TV Shows

A Forgotten Sci-Fi Series About a Detective in a Time Loop Premiered 20 Years Ago, And It Deserves a Reboot

There was a time when television commercials and television drama boldly embraced the bizarre. Before the days of streamed TV shows and endless murder mysteries with devious plots, there were the networks, which occasionally dared to take oddball plots and turn them into unexpected detective hits. This series asked: What if every choice you made could end your life? That’s enough to be exhausting on its own. Now, try to work through a murder mystery while keeping that in mind.

Videos by ComicBook.com

It’s exactly the kind of perfectly warped conceit that helped turn an underrated ABC thriller into a fully realized series. It was filled with nonstop action, intrigue, and a twisting conspiracy. But unfortunately, the lead actor was underused and underappreciated in his role. Then, the show somehow slipped through the cracks before it could be appreciated by an audience that never knew what to fully make of it. Twenty years later, it’s time to re-explore its ideas.

How Day Break Made a Time Loop a Detective Thriller

When it premiered on November 15, 2006, Day Break showcased Taye Diggs as Detective Brett Hopper, a Los Angeles cop caught up in the murder of Assistant District Attorney Alberto Garza. Doggedly convinced that he’s innocent of the crime, Hopper faces the uphill climb of trying to prove it. When he wakes up after the shooting, he discovers that he’s living the same day over againโ€ฆ only with his previous memories intact. As the days pass, Hopper finds himself reliving the same day, remembering every arrest, every altercation, and every bruise from his previous attempts.

The brilliance of Day Break is how it combines the Groundhog Day setup with the frenzied pacing of a 24-type conspiracy thriller. Hopper can’t just sit there and wait until the next day, because the next day isn’t coming. He has to traverse his current reality and save himself from getting framed, while doing everything he can to save his loved ones. And he’s doing it on a timetable that’s getting out of control. As it turns out, being able to foresee the future doesn’t make life any easier, because saving one person might get another person killed, and fixing one thing means creating ten more. The clever way in which Day Break complicates an already difficult day makes this show a jewel.

Why Day Break Deserves Another Chance 20 Years Later

Unfortunately, Day Break was never able to build the audience that its bold premise deserved. ABC was all too quick to place the series in the prized Wednesday night time slot that was previously occupied by Lost and meant to make the show highly visible. But ABC quickly pulled it from the lineup, dumping it after only a handful of episodes had aired in December 2006. Luckily, the remainder of the episodes were eventually made available online, so fans could follow Hopper’s terrifying quest to its natural conclusion. The first season was only 13 episodes long, but the creators of the series had planned for many more exciting seasons, where instead of having Hopper relive the same day over and over, they could have him stumble into completely new conspiracies and impossible situations.

It’s an enticing prospect. In the original series, viewers experienced the unique storytelling opportunity of watching a detective remember events that everyone else experienced as if they were happening for the first time. A reboot could go in any number of directions and still land close to the original’s exciting combination of action, mystery, and romance. Taye Diggs made Brett Hopper thoroughly sympathetic, anchoring even the wildest of situations. There are dozens of television shows about detectives in pursuit of killers, but how many give their hero the chance to learn from the same terrible day again? Day Break had a truly clever premise, and 20 years later, it’s a premise worth revisiting. Sometimes a show with a great concept goes to waste before it has a chance to take off.

If television keeps bringing back the same old detective stories, perhaps it’s time to give one that literally repeated itself another shot. After all, even a show trapped in a time loop deserves a second chance! Would you bring Day Break back for another season, or do you think its time has finally run out? Let us know in the comments!