5 Sci-Fi TV Shows That Peaked With the Very First Season

The sci-fi genre has found huge success on the small screen, with a number of shows weaving themselves into the fabric of pop culture. For many decades, it has been clear that science fiction works well in an episodic format, with shows like The Twilight Zone and Star Trek: The Original Series helping to define the genre as well as becoming sci-fi shows that changed the world. Many of the best sci-fi TV shows can claim to have had a major impact on the genre and on wider pop culture, but many other small-screen science fiction stories haven’t quite reached those dizzying heights of success.

There are many multi-season sci-fi shows that are perfect from beginning to end, but they are comparatively rare. In fact, many sci-fi TV shows struggle with consistency over a period of time, and on some occasions, they only seem to get worse as they continue. Some sci-fi series can never quite live up to the promise of their first chapter, earning them the unfortunate label of a show that peaked in its very first season.

5) The 100

While The 100 is a sci-fi show with some incredible world-building, it isn’t a show that managed to deliver on the strength of its early ideas. The first season of the show was by far its most successful, with the many unknown elements of its plot hooking viewers as its characters explored their new world. Ratings consistently declined with each passing season, and while later seasons still received some favorable reviews, The 100 never quite lived up to its early potential.

4) The Handmaid’s Tale

The Handmaid’s Tale is an amazing sci-fi show based on a book, Margaret Atwood’s 1985 novel of the same name. While it’s great throughout, the first season stuck to Atwood’s original story, with later seasons moving away from the source material. Although doing so didn’t make the rest of the show bad by any stretch of the imagination, the sense of narrative cohesion that permeated the show’s first season all but disappeared. In that sense, The Handmaid’s Tale seemed to be a much stronger show in its first season than it did in those that followed.

3) Stranger Things

Stranger Things is undoubtedly one of the greatest American sci-fi shows, especially in terms of its cultural relevance. However, from a purely narrative point of view, it peaked in its first season, with the subsequent chapters of its story feeling far less impactful in many ways. After the first season, the group of pre-teen protagonists was forced to contend with wider issues that eventually saw all of reality at stake, moving away from the purer sense of sci-fi horror that earned its early success and replacing it with a story that took place on a much grander scale.

2) Westworld

There are very few sci-fi shows that fell apart after their first season as obviously as Westworld. The TV adaptation of the 1973 movie of the same name started as an artful, subtle rumination on sentience with a darkly paranoid note to its twist-filled story. Subsequent seasons became increasingly complex, forcing the show to abandon its more ambiguous elements in favor of sci-fi shocks that never quite recaptured the early charm that once marked Westworld as one of the most promising sci-fi shows on TV.

1) Heroes

Heroes was once one of the most promising shows on TV, but all that changed after the end of its first season. Its large ensemble cast of humans coming to terms with the emergence of superpowers made for an incredible first season that paid homage to the comic book stories that created the superhero genre. Unfortunately, subsequent seasons relied more and more heavily on tired tropes until the sci-fi show fell apart completely in its final season. It’s a shame considering the clear potential that the first season conveyed, but Heroes simply peaked far too early.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

7 Sci-Fi Shows That Defined Their Generation