Movies

24 Years Ago, M. Night Shyamalan Released His Weirdest Twist Ending and Fans Still Think It Makes No Sense

Although M. Night Shyamalanโ€™s earlier horror success quickly made him a Hollywood legend, his penchant for twist endings went a bit too far with a divisive sci-fi blockbuster from 2002. Not all of M. Night Shyamalanโ€™s movies actually have twist endings, but it is still easy to see how the directorโ€™s name became synonymous with shocking last-second revelations. For better or worse, Shyamalanโ€™s earlier efforts The Sixth Sense and Unbreakable earned him a reputation for killer third-act reveals that turn the entire story of the preceding movie on its head.

Videos by ComicBook.com

From 2015โ€™s found footage comeback The Visit to 2004โ€™s offbeat blend of period drama and horror The Village, Shyamalan has often trafficked in twist endings that either elevate or ruin their movies, depending on the viewerโ€™s perspective. However, it wasnโ€™t until his fifth feature film that this predilection became divisive. Shyamalanโ€™s first two films, 1992โ€™s Praying with Anger and Wide Awake, mostly went under the radar, while 1999โ€™s The Sixth Sense and 2000โ€™s Unbreakable were widely praised. Thus, it was 2002โ€™s Signs that split audiences on Shyamalanโ€™s twists.

Signs Was Originally Released On August 2, 2002

The story of a family whose farm is besieged by aggressive aliens, Signs is a rare family-friendly horror movie that generates some genuine chills. Like Disneyโ€™s earlier Arachnophobia, this unsettling sci-fi horror doesnโ€™t need gore to get under the skin of its audience. Mel Gibsonโ€™s former priest Father Graham, who lost his faith after the death of his wife, lives on a remote rural farm with his two young children and his brother, Joaquin Phoenixโ€™s sweet would-be baseball pro Merrill.

When the farm is beset by alien attackers, Graham and Merrill must work with Grahamโ€™s children to keep the invading extraterrestrials at bay. That turns out to be unexpectedly easy when, at the end of the movie, Merrill knocks over a stray glass of water and mortally injures one of the aliens as a result. While this might be a big relief for the family, it was a twist that left many audience members staring in disbelief.

While Signs never claimed that its alien invaders were geniuses, the fact that they are seemingly hell bent on invading a planet that is covered in water, populated by beings that are largely composed of water, even though these extraterrestrials themselves are seemingly deathly allergic to water, raises a lot of questions. Compared to iconic sci-fi horror movies like Aliens, the ending of Signs was a letdown that felt all the more annoying thanks to the effective, genuinely haunting build-up that preceded the twist.

The Divisive Ending Of Signs Was The Beginning of the End For M. Night Shyamalanโ€™s Twists

Although a few half hearted fan theories have posited that the aliens arenโ€™t extra terrestrials, but rather demons, and Merillโ€™s swing worked because Graham regained his faith in that moment, not because of the water itself, the ending of Signs was still the beginning of the end for Shyamalanโ€™s brief reign as Hollywoodโ€™s king of the twist ending. Unlike the later Cowboys Vs Aliens, Signs was far from a flop, but its retrospective reviews couldnโ€™t get past that corny twist, and this soon meant that later M. Night Shyamalan movies had a progressively harder time shocking viewers.