TV Shows

HBO Canceled This Fantasy Series Before Its Biggest Battle (& It Could Have Been the Next Game of Thrones)

HBO has canceled plenty of shows over the years, but some still leave you wondering what could have been. Especially when a series has a much bigger story planned and gets cut off before things really get going. One fantasy show had enough material mapped out for six seasons, including a huge battle that would have changed everything. Instead, it ended after just two seasons, leaving fans with plenty of questions.

Videos by ComicBook.com

Carnivร le premiered on HBO in 2003. Set during the Great Depression, it followed a traveling carnival and a young man who could heal people, while a preacher named Brother Justin seemed to be heading down a much darker path. Creator Daniel Knauf planned to take the story all the way to World War II, but HBO canceled the series in 2005 because of falling ratings and high costs. It’s a shame, especially considering what fantasy TV became a few years later with Game of Thrones. Could Carnivร le have been just as big? Maybe, but we’ll never know.

Carnivร le Was HBO’s Weirdest Fantasy Series, and That’s What Made It Special

Forget shiny armor and grand castles. Carnivร le takes place in the dust-choked American Midwest of the 1930s, where people are struggling to survive the Depression and a traveling carnival offers a temporary escape from their miserable circumstances. Ben joins the troupe after discovering his strange healing ability, while Brother Justin builds a following through his religious fervor and increasingly disturbing visions. For much of the series, the two men follow separate paths, and the show takes its time connecting the dots. Meanwhile, the carnival’s collection of performers gives the story plenty of personality, particularly the sharp-tongued Samson, played by Michael J. Anderson. It’s a world where the fellow reading fortunes might know something he shouldn’t, and the preacher down the road might be a bigger problem than anyone realizes.

Daniel Knauf had an enormous mythology behind all this, but he also understood that the characters had to matter. In a 2013 interview, he explained that even the grandest fantasy story depends on the relationships between its characters. That’s a big part of why Carnivร le still sticks with people. It wasn’t simply a puzzle about supernatural forces; it was a drama about damaged people trying to understand their place in a world that seemed determined to grind them into the dirt. The catch was that viewers had to be patient. The series wasn’t going to explain every strange symbol the moment it appeared, and its two storylines took their time converging. For some viewers, that was the appeal. For others, it was probably a reason to find something easier to follow on a Sunday night.

HBO Canceled Carnivร le Before Its Biggest Battle Could Happen

When HBO canceled Carnivร le in May 2005, Knauf had already mapped out six seasons, divided into three two-season chapters. The first two seasons covered 1934 and 1935; the next pair would have jumped ahead to 1939 and 1940, with the final chapters taking the story into 1944 and 1945. That’s a pretty ambitious plan for a show whose central mystery still had so much left to unpack. Knauf later explained that he had known the final image of the series from the beginning: Ben and Sofie kissing goodbye as an atomic bomb exploded. Yes, really. The series was building toward a supernatural story that would collide with one of the most consequential moments in modern history. We only got to see the opening two chapters.

Knauf wasn’t short on ideas for the missing seasons, either. His plans included a much larger role for Sofie, a five-year time jump, and a conflict that would eventually intersect with the Manhattan Project. HBO even considered wrapping up the unfinished story in a two-hour movie, but Knauf felt that cramming the equivalent of four seasons into a single film wouldn’t do the characters justice. It’s hard to blame him. You don’t spend years building a world like this just to speed-run the ending. Would Carnivร le have become the next Game of Thrones if it had reached its intended conclusion? Maybe, maybe not. Its deliberate pace and strange mythology were never going to appeal to everybody. But it had a memorable cast, a distinctive setting, and a story that was meant to get much bigger. HBO gave us the carnival, the mysteries, and the first stage of the conflict. The rest of the journey exists only in Knauf’s plans, which is a particularly cruel fate for a series that spent so much time promising that something enormous was coming. Do you want to see thi series concluded?